This was my first Mark Roeder book, chosen for the YA Saves reading challenge, but I'm interested enough to want to read the entire series.
One part spine-tingling murder mystery/ghost story, one part preachy. That preachiness aspect seemed so out of character for a teenage gay male, which is sad because Sean, the protagonist, is such a wonderful character. He's like any typical teenage boy obsessed with sex (in his case his own), his self-esteem and just high school life in general. He's out but still wandering that wilderness of just what being gay means for him. What ruined his voice is the author preaching to the choir, so to speak. We get it--homophobia is bad.
As the title suggests, someone IS killing the gay boys of the fictional small town of Verona, and the ones being murdered just so happen to be Sean's friends. It's up to him and a rather interesting cast of characters, including two ghosts, to solve a deadly mystery and save his own life in the process.
One thing that made me face-palm was Sean's parents, who were conspicuously absent the last half of the book. They just seemed to have plunked their son in a haunted house and leave him to his own devices. Not sure how realistic that is, but oh well. I also hope in subsequent books that there is more diversity as far as characters are concerned. Sorry, but all-white towns no matter how small, just don't seem realistic at all, especially for a modern setting.