**Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Kim Foster for an ARC of this book! Now available as of 10.10!**
"Hunger is not a problem. It is an obscenity. How wonderful it is that nobody need wait a single moment before starting to improve the world." - Anne Frank
Kim Foster's Las Vegas community is full of poverty, and it comes in all shapes and sizes. There are neighbors dealing with every struggle under the sun from addiction to homelessness to the cycle of foster care, and Kim and her husband are there to lend a kind ear and more often, to provide a meal. Food is the universal language of love, after all, and when Kim gets the idea to start a community pantry in her front yard, this tiny spark of kindness blossoms into an impassioned flame, growing and expanding its reach ever further during the height of COVID.
But as her tiny yard pantry becomes a true beacon of hope for one of the hardest hit communities in the United States, conflict and trouble also follow, and Kim begins to question the future of the endeavor. Can she truly feed everyone who needs her help? And what about the bigger social issues and systemic issues at play? If she continues to provide a "Band Aid" in her own sense, isn't that just saying to the world that she is okay with picking up the slack in a country that often exploits its poorest, KEEPING them stuck in that strata...literally gridlocked in a cycle of generational poverty with no hope for escape?
I was drawn to this read primarily because of the focus on social issues, and the discussion of wealth and income inequality and how it relates to food (or the lack thereof). While Foster does spend PLENTY of time in the book discussing different aspects of these issues, she spends a lot MORE time with 'case studies' in the form of essays...and long, descriptive passages about some of the recipes she cooks for various people in her life. While the beginning of this book caught my attention (Foster literally details how she found a man working on her house passed out in the backyard from meth---that'll grab you!), the focus doesn't solely stay on this man and his family...and this is where she started to lose me.
It was very unclear (to me at least) what Foster's role even was---was she simply an altruistic foster parent who's also a foodie? Although it wasn't necessarily needed, I think a bit more background on Foster's life and times would have been helpful for context. There are so many different sets of people introduced via their stories throughout the book that by the time I got comfortable reading about a few of them, we were then introduced to someone else. For this reason, I never felt like I got into the 'groove' of the book. It was hard to balance so many individual stories and try to find the through lines, and I didn't get the emotional punch I was hoping to find, with such an inside look at some of the deepest and darkest struggles of those in her community.
The food descriptions were also just OTT for me. I know this is what Foster is known for (to some extent) so I probably should have prepared myself more for this fact, but as much as I love EATING incredible food (and have no doubt of Foster's culinary prowess!) I don't really need to read a page and a half or more each time she mentions a recipe. Again, the writing is probably drool-worthy to foodies and connoisseurs: this just isn't me. Again, I realize food is the driving force behind the entire book so in some respects it makes SENSE for Foster to include them: I just could have lived without it.
There's also a LOT of 'random' research sprinkled in to remind you that Foster's done her homework: some of it impactful, some that seemed sort of sporadically interspersed. In some ways, it made the whole book feel a bit less focused than I would have liked, and took away from the conversation I found more compelling: a look at how the criminal justice system and foster care system have essentially devolved into systems that keep people poor rather than give them a pathway out of poverty. Children sometimes end up with foster parents when their parents can't afford to keep them fed, clothed, or clean...yet in a foster family, the foster parents are given a check to help pay for the child's care. Who's to say if the birth parent received the same funding instead that they COULDN'T provide a suitable living environment?
Foster also brings up how misdemeanors in the criminal justice system were originally invented to 'find reasons' to criminalize people: you roll through a stop sign, get pulled over, end up with a ticket, can't pay the ticket, and now have a warrant for your arrest...and everything spirals from there. These are monumental, systemic problems: some that are being addressed, and many that are yet to be addressed in a meaningful way...and THIS is the book I was hoping to read. The whole premise of this one began as an article and in some respects, I actually preferred reading the brief article to reading this whole book. While I find Foster kind, honest, thoughtful, and inspirational, I believe I grew more enamored with her discussion of how we COULD change the world if everyone got on board rather than the in depth exploration of the various ways she tried to do it personally.
Though the structure and some of the detail in the finished product didn't quite give me the satisfaction I was looking for, this book was far from 'bare bones'...and in terms of the ever evolving discussion on how to truly solve poverty in our world?
It proved MORE than enough to whet my appetite!🍽
3.5 stars
#TheMethLunches #KimFoster #SMPInfluencers #StMartinsPress