I received an ARC from Netgalley. My thoughts are my own.
Note: I wrote this review largely as I read, finishing a story and writing my thoughts, then adding to it later on as the anthology unfolded and I noticed trends.
Overall thoughts: I liked every story to varying degrees, no clunkers. All the stories featured queer characters of color, with those aspects always represented, but taking more of a center stage in some stories more than others. I am a romance fan, but I came to this anthology looking for the scariness to be front and center. Which means that the stories I rated a little lower might be the ones you like more than my top stories.
That doesn’t mean I didn’t want deeper meaning in the stories and so my favorite ones were scary, but also thoughtful, insightful, and moving.
My favorite story was Leyla Mendoza and the Last House on the Lane, by Maya Gittleman. Not the scariest, but spooky Halloween vibes with a little fantasy, but what stole my heart was the hopeful message of – well, no spoilers, darlings!
Lots of Ouija Boards, at least 3. Being YA, there are also a lot of babysitting gigs and siblings in distress.
I love short stories and find them their own artform. Some of the authors handled this perfectly, and others missed a beat or two to allow their story to fully realize its potential. A couple of the stories needed a few more pages than they were allotted.
Welcome to the Hotel Paranoia, by Vanessa Montalban. *** ½ The first story, Welcome to the Hotel Paranoia, by Vanessa Montalban had great vibes. Set in a never-opened hotel (the ground was no good, you all, and an earth goddess might not be pleased with the violation) in the middle of nowhere that seems surprisingly intact. Overlook vibes, complete with a party that cannot (should not) be. Some glaring plot holes, though. I have questions!
This is in so many ways my ideal setting with my ideal mood, filled with my ideal tropes. My confusion on a couple points, though, weaken this a fair amount for me, but this as the first story in the anthology still made for a strong start. Based on what was done near perfectly, I’d love to read more from this author! Looks like she has a book called A Tall Dark Trouble, which I’m very interested in. Sapphic.
The Visitor, Kalynn Bayron: **** Another story with great atmosphere. The author did a great job of setting up a familiar Halloween in America, and foreshadowing. I really felt the fall air as a father and daughter sit down to watch horror movies ... and wait. The story felt really meta, as the character who are well aware of horror tropes fall into horror tropes, as if they had to fulfill the requirements of the night. I think there were elements there just to be a misdirect, but I don't know, and so I have questions. There's something missing here stopping me from full love. I would have liked an extra beat or two to even better establish the longing that lead to the choice. What was the catalyst?
If I could compare it to one classic horror story, I’d have to go Monkey’s Paw, by W.W. Jacobs, but it’s very much it’s own story.
This was the story that made me, in May of 2023, turn on the wax melter for the scent of cocoa and leaves and campfire. Sapphic.
A Brief Intermission, Sara Farizan: *** ½ Afsaneh and Rusty are drive-in employees and film buffs. They're asked by the incapacitated owner, mauled by an invisible something, to do him a favor. Also not to interact with any visitors. They do anyhow. "Hilarity" ensues. Nice.
While set in the modern era, there are links to the 1950s, when people weren’t fans of non-conformity. It reminds me that there’s a portion of Stephen King’s Christine, a novel about a possessed 1958 Plymouth Fury, called Teenage Death Songs. I’m also reminded of the line from Into the Woods about nice being different from good. Sapphic.
Guested, Rebecca Kim Wells: ****1/2 Nina goes to a different kind of Halloween party in order to help her sister, who has been acting strange. Genuine chills. At first, I rolled my eyes at the story being told in 2nd person, but it very much works. The premise of a mysterious company trying to change people, but something goes wrong, reminds me of More Happy than Not, by Adam Silvera. Sapphic.
Rocky Roads with Caramel Drizzle, Kosoko Jackson: **** A boy has an opportunity to exact revenge after a hate crime. Ouija board! Moving story that asks why we have to always turn the other cheek, or rise above. I didn’t 100% gel with the writing, but found myself moved and introspective as to what we expect of victims – to be so much better than those that hurt them in a world where justice feels sometimes like the least likely result. Why? I suspect this is going to be one of the hardest reads due to the subject matter. Achillean.
The Three Phases of Ghost Hunting, Alex Brown: *** 3 words: Food court ghost. Nice, and I love the mall setting, Daisy de la Cruz and Iris Chen, but I'm not sure this one will stick with me. In fact, I’m writing this a few days after reading it, and the title brought up nothing, but once I had my memory triggered, I smiled. The romance is sweet, so no chills but several of the feels. According to her bio, the author loves rooting for the final girl, especially if she’s a monster. Sapphic.
Nine Stops, Trang Tranh Tran: ***** This one IS scary. Watch the video, or die, but watch the video and maybe die anyhow. Creepy, and seemed to be a commentary on the way we passively watch real-life tragedies as if they exist for our voyeuristic entertainment. Nine Stops is also about the connection between those grieving loss. Very The Ring, and stories in that vein. The author has She is a Haunting coming out this winter, and it looks amazing.
Leyla Mendoza and the Last House on the Lane, Maya Gittleman: ***** I’m writing the reviews as I go, talking about each story as I finish it. At this point, this is very much my favorite story so far. It’s horror, but it’s fantasy. It takes place at the house everyone is afraid of – you know that place. It’s a story about fear, and when it is and isn’t justified, and it’s ultimately hopeful. And it definitely made me cry. Even if I read a story Iike as much, I definitely won’t read one I like more. Some of the family dynamics reminded me of The Cemetery Boys, by Aiden Thomas. Maya Gittleman is definitely on my radar now. Trans rep.
In You to Burn, Em X. Liu: ***1/2. Luce/Lucy (a name that refers to light) unintentionally starts fires with her mind, pyrokinesis, when she’s angry. She thought she’d burned Harley alive, but Harley is still walking around, and now she’s at the party. Based on a Chinese tale called Nezha and the Dragon King. As much fantasy as horror. Objectively, a good story, but not fully my vibe, and I really think it called for at least as novella. Maybe animal death, not clear. Sapphic rep.
Anna, Shelly Page: **** This story has A LOT going for it: a New Orleans setting, a main character who believes in ghosts & is off to babysit, a Ouija Board, and a scary attic. A couple moments didn't land for me, but there was so much right with it. Sapphic rep.
Hey There, Demons, by Tara Sim: ***1/2 Noah thinks his house has a poltergeist. Will trusting a (cute) demon to exorcize it work or be a big mistake? Possibly one of the most romantic tales in this anthology up until this point. Also, funny and creepy. The ending felt a bit rushed for me, even as a short story. Achillean.
Save Me from Myself, Ayida Shonibar: ***1/2 was perhaps the hardest book for me to read on an emotional level, & that's saying something in a book with a story about hate crimes. "Save" is about how intrusive thoughts/depression/anxiety steal joy and keep us from forming bonds.
Not every writing choice felt smooth for me, and the tone varied a little too much, but the concept touched me deeply. I mean, I related. The ending is an absolute gut punch. Sapphic
Knickknack, Ryan Douglass:
*** The story had a scary dead clown and a Nightmare on Elm Street echoes, and was one of the stories that prioritized attraction/romance, but the tone didn't sell the horror for me. I love romance, but came to this book wanting horror as the star. Obviously, subjective, and a personal preference, and I might have liked it more on a different day. Achillean.
Final Thoughts: Publication is set for 8/29/23. Terrific book to pick up then, and have on your TBR pile when October rolls around. This would be wonderful to read while the wind blows and the smell of burning leaves is in the air.