My grade: C. This is a novella and it's pretty well confined to the romance between Cathy and Ethan. The premise is different, but other than falling in love, the characters pretty much stay the same throughout the story. They're also pretty one dimensional. We don't really learn much about who they are and what shaped them. Yes, Cathy is deaf, but she's very well-adjusted and the nicest person ever. Ethan is a bit arrogant. His family is wealthy and unable to show love/emotion. But he's a hero. We don't really see any struggle as Cathy spends months caring for Ethan and working. It's just what she wants to do and it makes her happy. Well, even loving the person, such a life would be very difficult. There would be times when you'd be down and be struggling. But we never saw that with Cathy. The same goes for Ethan. His physical therapy had to be hell, there had to be days of overwhelming discouragement, yet we never see it--except when Zack influences him. Different for an inspirational (which I am only assuming it is categorized as) there is a bit of sex in it. What was there--the romance--I liked. I liked Cathy's determination. But there just wasn't enough. Given the premise, this should have been a meaty story. Instead it was a sweet, fluffy romance. I was really disappointed at the epilogue. Ethan is back at work and still recovering, but he's a bit of an ass! I guess he's supposed to be funny, but I ended up not liking him in the scene. Although we'd been told he was a bit demanding prior to the shooting, it was the first scene where we saw him dealing with others in the workplace. I didn't like him! But I liked him for the rest of the book,