Premise: In the aftermath of the solar eclipse, ShadowClan has decided to renounce StarClan in favor of following Sol. And things aren't much better for Firestar's grandchildren. Hollyleaf despairs that the warrior code is lost forever; Lionblaze is tormented by nightmares in which he murders Heathertail; and when disease strikes ThunderClan, Jaypaw is struck with desperation to save them. But nothing can compare to what the siblings will soon face – specifically a shocking revelation that will turn all that they ever believed about themselves upside down.
Story/Writing: What a mind-blowing treat this book was to read! Granted, had I not been going through a lack of sleep I probably would've gotten through it much sooner. But regardless, this story has all the intrigue, action, and high-stakes tension I've come to expect from a "Warriors" book. Yet even though I have come to expect those things I crave from a story in this series (or rather from any story in general), that in no way means it's old! The authors somehow manage to find a way to keep me on my toes and write hit after hit even now that I've read over fifty titles in this series. While I wasn't feeling well and therefore had a bit of a harder time reading this one than the others, that didn't stop me from reading it in just three days! I knew I had a good story in my hands and I just could not put it down! As with most other books in this series, the characters' conflicts and struggles feel so real. If anything, they've gotten more serious now that the main characters have really grown up since the first couple of books in the "Power of Three" arc. That may sound obvious, but if you were to take those first couple of books and compare the way the siblings are portrayed in those to the way they're portrayed here, it's like looking at two similar yet very different portraits. More on that in a bit though. I felt some pretty heavy emotions as I was reading this. I felt the desperation that the siblings and their "cousins" felt when they thought up their plan to restore ShadowClan's faith in StarClan. I was completely floored when Raggedstar and Runningnose appeared to Blackstar, but not in a bad way. I may not have been expecting that at all, yet it made perfect sense in hindsight. Speaking of which, while I knew from the novella "Leafpool's Wish" that the siblings are in fact the children of Crowfeather and Leafpool rather than Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight, reading the scene where Squirrelflight reveals she's not their mother just really got my heart pounding against my chest. And don't even get me started on what Jayfeather discovers. I was just really impressed with how this story was built and how natural the three-act structure of it all felt. The writing was not too descriptive but not too vague. The emotions of everything that happened felt real and got me in the gut. It was all just great!
Characters: If there's one part of the story that the writers always get right, it's the cast of characters. The three siblings specifically go through trials and tribulations that really had me rooting for them. The more they discover about themselves, their destiny, and of course the past, the more intensely I felt the emotions I was getting. I can tell that they're all going to play incredibly important roles in the coming future that will soon be full of turning points in the history of the Clans.
Jayfeather – Once again, I consider Jayfeather the main character in this book. But in this case, it's because of what he discovers. We finally learn about the origins of the prophecy, as well as how the ancient cats who lived by the lake are connected to the modern Tribe of Rushing Water. And the way we learn about both was probably the best part of the book! While I don't think it's as simple as saying Jayfeather is Jay's Wing reincarnated, my mind was blown when Jayfeather lives through Jay's Wing's memories and basically sets in motion the events that lead to the formation of the Tribe of Rushing Water and (eventually) the Clans. I even let out a bit of a fangirl scream when Half Moon showed up! Since I've been reading the books in chronological order, I already knew about Half Moon and her brief love for cat called Jay's Wing. And seeing her again after so long, as well as making the connection between Jay's Wing and Jayfeather, was such a sweet treat! Plus, while the love they shared was bittersweetly brief, I found Jayfeather's affection for Half Moon to be just adorable! Mostly because Jayfeather is usually a grump (though in a charming way), so you wouldn't think he'd be capable of having feelings like that toward someone, especially since he's a medicine cat. Yet it didn't feel out of character. If anything, I wished just as much as he did that circumstances were different. But that past is past. Aside from that, Jayfeather is as great as ever. I thought his plan to set up a sign from StarClan was risky but clever, and I loved how he was willing to go to such great lengths to save ThunderClan from the greencough outbreak. As grumpy as he can be, Jayfeather is now one of my favorite characters in the series!
Hollyleaf – Hollyleaf is also just as good as she's ever been! Now that she's a warrior sworn to protect the warrior code, she definitely has her paws full already, that's for sure! You could say she is a bit obsessive about defending it, but she really does raise some good points as well. If even one Clan didn't live by the warrior code, they could invade any of the other Clans at any time, no questions asked. What I found to be really interesting about her though was that there were two occasions where she had the same response toward a cat who betrayed her, yet one made me feel a different way than the other did. For example, when she pretty much told Sol off and told him to get lost, I was like, "Yeah, you tell him, girl!" But then it really got me in the feels when she reacted the same way toward Squirrelflight, especially considering that just one book prior to this, she was sleeping next to her when she thought Squirrelflight might die. And now here she is not wanting anything to do with the cat she thought her whole life to be her mother, when she never was. Even though I wanted to remind Hollyleaf that Squirrelflight nonetheless raised her and loved her like she was her own, I did understand her reaction. Squirrelflight had lied to her, her brothers, and her Clan for all of Hollyleaf's life. If anything, I probably would be a bit uneasy if she didn't have a reaction like that. Even then though, you can tell that the love she felt all her life toward Squirrelflight has never really left her. In any case, I gotta say I'm a little nervous about what happens to her in the next book, given what I kinda know already.
Lionblaze – Given how floored I was in my feelings toward Lionblaze in the last book, I'm surprised the authors made the risk of playing around with that a bit more in this book! Lionblaze was made a warrior the same time his sister was, so he's also gotta get used to being a warrior with all its responsibilities as well. And, it's kinda surprising that he adjusts as well as he does. He's got so many regrets from his past, both near and far, and you can tell how hard he's trying not to let it all overwhelm him, as well as how afraid he is of the cat he fears he could turn into. On the one hand, I remember wanting him to put aside his issues and get the catmint for his Clanmates who were getting close to death's door by that point. At the same time though, I really did get where he was coming from. He believes Heathertail betrayed him by showing the tunnels to WindClan, but his feelings for her have never truly faded away, given how horrified he is when he has nightmares about violently murdering Heathertail and hearing Tigerstar make fun of him for it. He doesn't want those nightmares to come true and doesn't want at all to become like Tigerstar, now that he knows for sure that the crow-food-eating Dark Forest monster was just using him. I'm just happy that he was brave enough in the end to get the catmint and even more so that he successfully restrained himself from lashing out at or even killing Ashfur.
Ashfur – Speaking of which, my feelings toward this character took a complete one-eighty toward the end when he revealed that he was in on the plot to kill Firestar! Not to mention he threatens to let the siblings die in the fire, and then decides to humiliate Squirrelflight at the next Gathering and have the three driven out of ThunderClan, all because of his petty, bitter, and obsessive jealousy toward Squirrelflight. I thought there was a bit of resentment in him toward Lionblaze, his own apprentice. But I didn't think he would stoop to this level of low! I felt as betrayed as Squirrelflight and the three siblings did toward him. I thought he was better than this! And honestly, while I know I might be hoping in vain that this doesn't turn out to be the case, I wouldn't be surprised if it turns out that Squirrelflight was the one who murdered him in the end. I personally wouldn't have wanted such an end for even a scumbag like him, but Squirrelflight and the siblings had far more on the line and he would've risked the safety of his Clan as well had he told on them. If nothing else, it makes sense that he's on the cover (of the version I read, anyway), given how his character and his death end up being crucial turning points for the rest of the arc, not just this story.
Firestar – Once again, Firestar goes above and beyond to show why he's the best leader ThunderClan could ever have asked for. He takes it upon himself to be a true servant-leader when he comes up with the idea to quarantine himself along with the cats in the advanced stages of greencough. On the one hand, it does make practical sense, given he still has a few lives left when all the others have one. But even if he did have only one life like the rest of them, I think he probably would've done it anyway because he's their leader and would literally do anything for his cats. He truly embodies what ThunderClan has now become famous for: defending and caring for the weak when no one else either can or will.
Various Other Characters – Sol, you are a bad, bad kitty! Even if Midnight did tell you everything, you clearly care about no cat but yourself, just as Leafstar said! In all seriousness though, it really creeped me out how determined Sol seemed to rid ShadowClan of the warrior code. I know it was likely done as a sort of revenge on Leafstar, just taken out on all the other Clans. But still, his quest for power was a haunting one to read, and I don't think I've seen the last of him. Moving on though, it was just mind-blowing seeing the founding leaders in the prologue after being away from them for so long. That was awesome! I'm proud of Littlecloud for keeping the faith and helping to convince Blackstar to return to his. I'm probably prouder of Tawnypelt for taking the risk of leaving ShadowClan with her kits. Speaking of whom, I thought Flamepaw, Tigerpaw, and Dawnpaw were cute and funny! They felt like great counterparts to their "cousins" and I thought their interactions were charming. I can tell they're gonna be some of the greatest ShadowClan cats in a long time, and for the right reasons. Despite how awful things have gotten between the two of them, I was so happy that Heathertail wasn't willing to let ThunderClan die for what Lionblaze nearly did to her. I felt sorry for all the ThunderClan cats who had to go and be quarantined at the Twoleg nest, and even more so for their healthy loved ones who had to watch them leave the their camp. I felt particularly awful for Graystripe. He's already lost his first mate, Silverstream. I don't know if either he or I could bear it if he lost another. But thankfully he didn't, and easily a big chunk of the thanks goes to Leafpool, who went above and beyond with how she cared for the ill cats! With that said, I thought Brightspirit and her parents, Shiningheart and Braveheart, were really interesting, even if the story behind the creation of those characters is rather tragic. From what I know, they were inspired by a young girl who was a "Warriors" fan but tragically lost her life in a natural disaster, which also killed both of her parents. I thought that was a really touching tribute and showed that the authors do care about their fans. But on the bright side, I was really intrigued when I read that Whitewing and Birchfall were expecting kits, 'cause I know those kits are gonna be Dovewing and Ivypool, whom I absolutely cannot wait to read about!
Overall: This book was just an absolute thrill to read! The themes of losing faith, regaining faith, betrayal, regret, despair, hope, and, of course, shock and awe just seemed to emanate from the pages for me. And since the book leaves on the cliffhanger of Ashfur's murder, I know that this is just the calm before the storm that is the sixth and final book in the "Power of Three" arc: "Sunrise!"