Early in this gentle novel, Brady, a pastor’s son, stumbles upon a neighbor’s Underground Railroad “station” while playing in the woods with a friend. When Brady, unable to keep a secret, shares his discovery with his family, he is surprised by their reaction. Unsure of his own feelings about slavery, Brady begins to notice the tension between those around him who are on opposite sides of the controversial issue. Then Brady stumbles across an even bigger secret related to the Underground Railroad and, while proving he can keep this secret, he begins to sort out his own feelings about slavery and eventually Brady proves that he can do a “man’s work”.
I read this book with a group of 5th grade students for the Battle of the Books competition in April. This novel was simple and well-written. Many student readers will certainly enjoy this one, however it is not very exciting and may not be powerful or interesting enough to draw in those kids who are not big readers or do not enjoy the historical fiction genre. Of the five students in the group I worked with (all big readers), three kiddos said they liked the book and two admitted that they did not.