Just to clarify: David Wellington is not the only author contributing to this anthology.
The horror short stories in this collection revolve around the fictional town of Pinebox, Texas; though the dozen stories are distinct and can each stand alone, they share a setting, some characters, and regular social interactions (for example the mutual dislike between townies and students, staff, or faculty associated with the local university). It's a device used effectively in anthologies like the Thieves' World books, and it works well here: the first story establishes the town history and the peculiar nature of Pinebox, that is, the fact that strange things happen here. Dead bodies turn up or people just disappear, and the town residents accept this with equanimity and the unspoken agreement not to talk about it. With these aspects shared by all the stories, the authors don't have to use word space for world-building or scene-setting. The first story, which introduces Pinebox to readers like me who haven't been following this series, does a great job of introducing the town and setting the tone for the rest of the book. The epilogue consists of newspaper articles relating to the stories. A reader could skip this part but would then miss out on the the epitaph that shows how some of those evil forces in the stories continued to plague the residents of Pinebox after the end of the story. Some of these "newspaper articles" are misaligned as if they really are clippings pasted into a scrapbook; it reinforces the idea that Pinebox is a complete world.
Some glitches crop up in this system. For example, Sheriff Anderson as he's described in one story doesn't seem like the same person in another story: different attitude, different persona. Such problems are neither too numerous nor too stark to detract from the whole, or from the individual stories.
The cover of this volume has a glossy, full-color photo on sturdy paper -- this book will withstand some bumps and banging and still look good. Likewise, the pages are thick, very white paper. Unfortunately, the high quality of the physical aspect of the book is out of sync with the attention to the inside: two dozen typos are scattered throughout the 170-ish pages of the volume, the kinds of mistakes that a spell-check won't catch but good proofreading will (e.g. "door jam" instead of "door jamb"). While reading, I made like Pinebox residents and tried to ignore the anomalies.
Predictably with an anthology like this, I like some of the stories more than others. There's one story with familiar werewolves and others with malevolent ghosts, but most of the stories use original -- and very creative -- ideas. Most feature an outsider coming into town without any understanding of how strange, evil, and malicious things prey on people here, so I see the town through their (fresh, disbelieving) eyes and they easily become the victims. I wish the collection included more East Texas voices -- not just the distinctive dialects, but also the speech patterns, topics, and world-view. About three of the authors are from Texas, and I could feel the difference even before I read the authors' brief bios at the end of their stories: their protagonists are native Texans, and they have a more integral relationship with the place than the other protagonists do. Considering that Pinebox -- the place -- is the raison d'etre for the anthology, there should be a stronger sense of place in these stories. As it is, some of these stories could be set anywhere; a change of setting makes no difference to the story. To be fair, I can understand why a non-Texan author would refrain from using an unfamiliar voice; the question of authenticity is relevant. Plus, not having read other collections in this series, I have no idea if the other anthologies include more East Texas voices. My only recommendation is that the editor find more Texan/East Texas authors to fill the anthology; hey, it's a big place -- huge! -- so it can't be that hard.
Only one of these stories is truly creepy so if you're looking for horror stories that will give you nightmares, this isn't the book. Not surprisingly, the creepy one was my favorite. Some of these stories could have been very good if they'd been written better. Some just lacked internal consistency (e.g. why would a man who sees ghosts and wants to avoid houses with ghosts then go and buy one with two angry spirit residents?), and another was too confusing to be absorbing (but had the potential to be a really good horror story). I object to those stories where the point-of-view protagonist dies at the end or where the whole story is narrated from one person's PoV until the very end when a sudden switch in PoV reveals what was really going on. I see these as cheap ploys where the author wants to pull out a surprise ending but is too lazy a writer to figure out how to structure it.
You might want to consider this book as a gift for a teen who likes horror stories, unless you object to: references to an adulterous affair, teen pregnancy, intra-familial strife, mercy killing, explicit death/violence, supernatural forms of justice, or sex between two people who are possessed by cats (alluded to, not described).
~bint