The story of what a child feels and how they act after losing their only parent tends to set up a book to be angsty and even difficult to read. I started this one with the usual trepidation, wondering how the story was going to go. Sadly I was a little disappointed.
There seemed to be so much that could have been said. It's hardly fair, because we've had books written since then (such as "A Monster Calls") that handle this kind of story with so much more depth and emotion that it doesn't begin to compare. But then this book was written years before, and so needs to be judged within that context. Talking openly or honestly at all about death in children's books has been an area off limit for a long time, so when this book comes alone and hints at the anger and fear that a child goes through...then you have to appreciate the groundwork laid so that other books (again, such as "A Monster Calls") can come later.
So, I'll give this three stars even if the characters maybe lack depth and the answers are a little too easy. There's still good here to enjoy.
Note: Maybe I wasn't in a good place the day I read this. Maybe it was too close to my own mother's death. But in re-reading this book today in April 2021, I have discovered that I like this book more than I did then and am happy to be changing this to 4 stars. I think it was really tackling something different and really did get at the heart of what this feels like to a child.