This is such an unusual book and so hard to pin a rating on, but I've settled on 4 stars because the story telling and writing ability were excellent.
It lost a star because of the old fashioned additions of readers hooks - like the last two lines on page 20, personally I'd delete all of them! Also for the continued acceptance of infidelity. I don't really know what that was meant to add to the book, evidence of forgiveness maybe? I don't know, but for me it just detracted from the characters and their lives rather than adding anything.
The book poses a wonderful ideal for life after death; the idea of Midway Manor with it's incredible data room and Reunion Valley where you can catch up with lost loved ones is delightful.
I found Stardust Dads to be a really sweet and enjoyable read, it's life affirming message is clear as is the message not to bank on the afterlife but to enjoy the short time we each have on Earth. It is very well written and easy to read, I think this is a real achievement especially given that it is written by a husband and wife team. Personally I couldn't see any conflict in styles and I would've guessed it was written by one person.
Given the premise this could have been a patronising, mushy tale but it wasn't, it was a descriptive, entertaining and a very charming book. It isn't a genre I would usually tend to select but I still found it a really good read and actually read it in just 2 days which shows how keen I was to keep turning pages!
I think David and Josephine George could easily turn their hand to romance novels or crime novels and fit in very nicely on the mainstream shelves.