If you thought the delay between book one of the Unicorn Chronicles (Into the Land of the Unicorns, 1994) and book two (Song of the Wanderer, 1999) felt interminable, how much more so the wait for book three, Dark Whispers (2008)? Bruce Coville took his time getting this story aligned, and it shows: Dark Whispers is a lush, nuanced narrative, divided among several main characters whose separate storylines are converging toward a barnburner of a conclusion in the final book of the quartet. A few key mysteries were cleared up by the previous book, but the unicorns of Luster have miles to go before they rest. Twelve-year-old human Cara Hunter's grandmother has assumed her rightful role and form as Amalia Flickerfoot, Queen of the Unicorns, succeeding Arabella Skydancer after the aged Queen faded to her eternal rest. The new Queen has lived most of her life on Earth as Cara's grandmother Ivy Morris, unaware of her unicorn heritage, but she must quickly learn the ins and outs of royal responsibility. Cara's ageless ancestor, Beloved, has finally obtained an amulet to gain passage for herself and her Hunter kin into Luster, and once they breach this fantasy world, the final hunt will commence. The Hunters want to eradicate the last of the unicorns, a tragedy Amalia Flickerfoot must prevent. But how to resist a foe as cunning, hateful, and backed by mysterious powers as Beloved?
"What we do not wish to remember we sometimes hide. That which we hide long enough is sometimes forgotten altogether, even if it never forgets itself."
—Alma Leonetti, Dark Whispers, P. 39
"But it's often the case that our most intimate enemies are rooted in our own darkness."
Dark Whispers, P. 403
The oldest human in Luster, Alma Leonetti, arrives in the unicorn royal court at Autumngrove to warn of an ancient spiritual presence called the Whisperer. It is a fanatical enemy of unicorns, but all record of the Whisperer has vanished from the Unicorn Chronicles. Grimwold, official Keeper of the Chronicles, can scarcely believe anyone would tamper with the sacred text. Informed by M'Gama the Geomancer that only a few weeks stand between now and the Blood Moon, the time of year when Beloved is almost certain to invade Luster, Amalia Flickerfoot dispatches a team to the realm of the centaurs to meet with their King, the Chiron. He will know the origin of the Whisperer, though he's sure to demand a heavy price for telling the tale. Cara (accompanied by the squirrel-like Squijum, of course) and Grimwold set off for centaur territory, joined by unicorns Lightfoot, Finder, and Belle, as well as M'Gama. The journey is long and muddled with danger from delvers, but Cara cannot fail if the unicorns are to avoid extermination.
"For what kind of world is it that has no unicorns?"
—Dark Whispers, P. 95
On Earth, Ian Hunter—Cara's father—has his own mission. Martha, his wife and Cara's mother, is locked inside the Ruby Portal in an enchanted realm called the Rainbow Prison. Beloved banished her there, irritated by Martha's influence over Ian, but now Ian has broken ranks with his Hunter relatives and sided with Cara to protect the right of unicorns to exist. Traveling the boisterous, crowded byways of urban India, he seeks a prophet called the Blind Man who knows how to access the Ruby Portal. The Blind Man is calculating and cynical, but if rescuing Martha means submitting to his games, Ian is prepared to do so. The debilitating method of payment exchanged for entry into the Ruby Portal may be Ian's undoing, but he has to take the chance; stalked by Beloved's unrelenting Hunters, Ian hasn't the time to be coy with the Blind Man. At a serendipitous moment Ian and Rajiv, a young Indian boy who led him to the Blind Man, meet another traveler, a tall, graceful man named Fallon who wishes to enter Luster and is willing to help Ian gain entry to the Ruby Portal. Trekking high into the Himalayan mountains, the three are a team to be reckoned with, but have little idea what to expect from the Ruby Portal. Their greatest test awaits.
"There would not be much left if every useful thing that could be turned to bad ends were destroyed."
—M'Gama, Dark Whispers, P. 140
Unicorns are not the only society of Luster in turmoil. King Gnurflax of the delvers is behaving erratically, prompting some of his subjects to fear he may be insane. Delvers have been at odds with unicorns since time immemorial, but now King Gnurflax is guided by a hostile, unseen spiritual entity. Nedzik, that rare delver with a functioning conscience, is concerned, but to question King Gnurflax would invite any one of many torturous punishments the King has devised for those he wishes to make an example of. When Nedzik's doubt is discovered, the King abandons him in a bleak dungeon at the end of the labyrinth of subterranean tunnels the delvers have built in and around their lair of Delvharken. Condemned by all his peers, Nedzik resigns himself to being a hopeless, nameless prisoner for life.
"It is easy enough to reject a story because you do not like what it says, but wiser to examine it first, to see what can be learned from it."
—Alma Leonetti, P. 454
Adventure blooms as Cara and her companions migrate to the land of centaurs. Tragedy awaits at M'Gama's home, which is cut into the mountainside and pulls energy from Luster itself. Bitter though the loss of a loved one is, our heroes don't have the luxury of time to mourn properly; the Blood Moon draws nearer and with it, Beloved's day of reckoning. Unaware of King Gnurflax's predations, Cara and her friends are headed for a trap. Why are delvers obsessed with harming unicorns? It's a mystery this book may clarify, if Cara ever makes it to the Chiron to hear the tale of the Whisperer. The truth will be both painful and liberating, a final proof that the unicorns bear a portion of the blame for the current situation that threatens their existence. Will Luster ever find peace, or is Beloved's hatred too powerful to overcome? What of the Dimblethum, Cara's former loyal companion who wages a quiet war with the ugly side of his own nature throughout this book? Cara, Ian, Fallon, Rajiv, M'Gama, Lightfoot, Belle, and even the Squijum would sacrifice anything for those they love, but evil is a potent counterforce. Luster is on the brink of destruction as Dark Whispers comes to a close, and perhaps nothing can curb the wave of vengeance that threatens them all.
"(T)he downfall of the wise and the mighty comes not from being strong or wise, but from thinking you are stronger and wiser than you truly are, than any being can truly be."
—Dark Whispers, P. 395
Unlike the two previous books, Dark Whispers is challenging and wise on many levels, a novel to grapple with as much as enjoy. What should you do if you're part of a malevolent society that has no interest in changing? Outsiders may look at you and perceive a villain, but what if you value truth, peace, and love, and are willing to stand for them at the cost of ostracism from peers? Will you be embraced by those outside your social group, or prejudged by them based on external characteristics? This is Nedzik's dilemma, a morally complex vision of delver culture more nuanced than anything from Into the Land of the Unicorns or Song of the Wanderer. On Earth, Ian has to confront his own lingering pride and prejudices from years of training by Beloved. She squeezed him into the mold of a killer, teaching him to refuse comfort or aid from anyone who isn't a Hunter, but community with his band of brothers isn't worth losing his daughter or wife. It takes time to unlearn old patterns, but Ian is determined to earn Cara and Martha's trust even if he may need to accomplish this next part away from them. Proving yourself to the companions you have right now is no small blessing, even if you'd rather be with others; Rajiv and Fallon are an opportunity for Ian to reshape his character to be worthy of his wife and daughter when he reunites with them.
"Each of us is a miracle. Alas, it is a fact we too often forget."
—Fallon, Dark Whispers, P. 125
Gruff yet tenderhearted, the Dimblethum's personal demons have only been hinted at before, but his brief involvement in Dark Whispers is the crux of everything to come. Will his fiercely loyal heart win out, or will he commit a devastating act driven by a betrayal he only dimly recalls? Struggling with one's dark side is exhausting, but even the goodhearted must do it or be swallowed by their own internal abyss. Cara's days have been consumed by drama since she first jumped into Luster, but someday it will calm down, and her affections will be torn between the two realms she loves. "Now that she had lived in two worlds, would she ever again be completely at home in either of them? Or would part of her always long for the other, no matter where she was?" Each of us has one life to live, and must commit to a future in order to enjoy the full richness of being alive. But will you feel incomplete if you do, longing for the surprises and pleasures of the road not taken, the person you may have become had you chosen another path? Life is a brimming pot of decisions to be made by people woefully inadequate for the task, but such is the nature of human existence. Our adventure never promises to be free of regret.
Song of the Wanderer was about one hundred seventy pages longer than Into the Land of the Unicorns, and Dark Whispers is nearly one hundred forty pages more than Song of the Wanderer. Bruce Coville uses the extra length to craft a third novel that taps into the exotic potential of Luster, merging several good plot concepts into a story rich with doubt, angst, perseverance, and bravery. Dark Whispers is a much more complex piece of literature than its predecessors, a strong indicator that Bruce Coville is capable of fulfilling the potential of this series. Rebecca Guay's cover art for the original editions of the first two books was as delicate and robust as a stained glass window, but Petar Meseldžija's jacket illustration for Dark Whispers may be the best yet, suggesting the energy of a true epic ready to be unleashed in this book and the finale, The Last Hunt. I'm thrilled to dive in, though anxious about what the end may bring. There's a good chance I'd rate Dark Whispers the full three stars, and if you've read volumes one and two of the Unicorn Chronicles but never moved beyond, I strongly recommend it. Bruce Coville and his most famous series both improved with age.