I'm thwacking myself with a pillow right now for adhering to a strict rating policy... But I can't say much more than three and a half stars--I liked it, but it didn't hold anything special.
The mystery is excellent, the plot wonderful. Each chapter was planned out nicely, with the mystery suitably unsolved until the very end. The author keeps you guessing all the way through as to who did it, making it a true page-turner. It takes off slowly, but it's an exponential growth--by the time you get really into the book, you're hooked. There are more twists than I can count, and again, it's wonderfully planned.
Twenty-Five Years Ago Today is certainly an excellent murder mystery. The author's work planning out each chapter shows, as does her meticulous attention to details while writing.
But perhaps it's in part the meticulous attention to detail that detracts slightly from the novel. It's written fairly by-the-book--it has its moments, but the writing itself isn't any more vibrant than a decent piece of FictionPress.com. The author appears to know the rules to writing inside and out, and is clearly very talented. Just, not practical. If it makes any sense, the book is written correctly, but not effectively.
The entirety of the book also retains a slightly unpolished air. It feels like it was written too quickly, without being entirely edited or in some cases researched. Again, take my nit-picking with a grain of salt, but there are several instances in which some detail doesn't sound entirely thought through, such as when introducing a character who was supposed to be the hot young male teacher, a young woman who addresses him as "Mr. T" (presumably a student) mouths to Kris "He's so gorgeous." According to my calculations, the man has to be in his mid 40s. He's not exactly young anymore, but still can charm the heck out of his students? I'm sorry, but it just doesn't seem like that was thought out properly.
I learned from the author's discussion group that the book was outlined, which makes sense for this next bit: There are lots of details, but they're not always remembered. Something might be mentioned in two chapters, but in the second chapter it is a slightly different detail. Yet every element of the mystery itself is remembered perfectly. A bit detracting, but it's able to be overlooked.
While the mystery is incredible and gripping, the romance aspect is not. It's rather cliché and predictable, almost painfully obvious. No spoilers, but if you're reading it and have a guess...you're right.
Overall--an excellent mystery novel. Nothing to mull over later, but a good read nonetheless. Not perfectly written, but the author has clear talent. I read as an editor and read books almost designed to make you think on them, so I'm slightly biased against--hence the three (and a half!) stars. Don't let the rating set you back from reading this book. If you want a good, solid mystery, Stacy Juba is serving one up on a platter with Twenty-Five Years Ago Today.