If my eyes had not caught the bright green color of the front cover of Peeled, I probably wouldn’t have even picked it up. After I picked it up, though, I realized that it was exactly what I was looking for. I wanted to read a book about a small, innocent mystery, and a realistic one too. And boy, did this book deliver a realistic mystery. If you’re looking for a small town mystery with relatable characters and nostalgic charm, I highly recommend picking up Peeled.
This story begins in Banesville, New York, set in the “Happy Apple Valley”. Hildy Biddle, the town’s high school reporter, works for the school newspaper called The Core. The Core is devoted to always telling the truth and spreading it in the community, but after rumors start swirling about a “ghost” at The Ludlow House, the newspaper business gets intense. After loud noises, ghost sightings, and a dead body show up at the house, the town falls into a state of terror, and it’s up to The Core to fix it. As Hildy tries to get to the center of the story, she starts to uncover dark truths about The Ludlow House. She discovers secret plans to flatten apple orchards and build a haunted theme park in Banesville, which could cause harm to their economy. Racing against time, threats, and an enemy newspaper called “The Bee”, Hildy realizes that she can save the town through the press and that the pen is truly mightier than the sword.
In Peeled, I liked how Bauer didn’t focus primarily on one aspect of the book, instead jumping around from characterization, to mystery, to more characterization, etc. The mood was consistent from start to finish, and the plot twist at the end was a great bonus. Also, Bauer did a great job of description and used many descriptive words that made me picture the storyline in my head, rather than just reading words on a page.
Although this book had a good storyline, it could’ve been way longer. The story is 240 pages long, and I could easily see it surpassing 400. Some parts were skimmed over, and if those ideas were built more upon then the story would’ve been a lot better. This story featured Hildy Biddle, and did much description on her, but failed to do so on some of the supporting characters. If these supporting characters were written to be more significant, and the storyline was stretched out, this book could have gone from great to amazing. Also, the reading level felt kind of low for me personally. It was labeled Young Adult Fiction, but I could easily see this book being read by a 6th grader, maybe even 5th.