When I was studying for a psychology degree in the late 1990s, a lot of a child psychology modules went on about “nature vs nurture”, debating whether a child’s environment and upbringing or their natural genetic makeup was more decisive in how they would develop. Psychologists could never seem to agree at that point and you could read as many viewpoints from either side of the argument as you wished. This made the characters in Mandasue Heller’s “Two-Faced” even more interesting to me.
The two faces of the title belong to identical twins, Mia and Michelle, who live in Manchester with their single mother. Whilst identical in looks, their personalities couldn’t be more different, with Mia being spoilt and confident in her looks and Michelle, who is bulled into submission by her sister, taking little care in her appearance and preferring to go unnoticed and to spend time reading. Mia, on the other hand, has no respect for her sister or mother and wants everything her own way, to the extent of stealing a man Michelle had her eye on.
After being flattered by a man who only wanted to get into her knickers, Mia decides her future lies in modelling. Her attitude counts against her in many ways, but her looks and sheer stubbornness prove enough to make her a success. However, fame results in her attracting the attention of some dodgy people and becoming addicted to drugs, which results in Michelle having to cover some of the modelling assignments and take some of the blame for Mia’s failings, which upsets Mia even more when Michelle turns out to be surprisingly good at modelling, as her gentler character impresses people more than Mia’s does.
I love the gritty and realistic setting of the book above all else, with some of the less affluent areas of Manchester depressingly portrayed. The twins’ mother, Kim, has all the attitude and life traumas that so many television programmes portray those on long-term benefits as having, with her constant smoking, going out to bingo and relationship dramas. Admittedly, on occasion this does stretch reality a little too far into television, but her favouritism of one child over another and her reactions to Mia’s impending fame and her need for acceptance through reflected glory is naked in the appeal.
I liked the characterisation of Mia and Michelle, which worked psychologically as well as in depiction. Whilst Michelle’s lack of backbone did get irritating at times, this was easily explained by the treatment she received at the hands of Kim and Mia and the blossoming when she was given some attention and compliments instead of being brow-beaten all the time was interesting to read. I did feel her character change was perhaps a little too quick to be entirely realistic, which took some of the edge off things, but the two girls were so different in attitude that they were easy to tell apart, even when they were both living the modelling lives.
The other aspect of the book I felt spoiled the realism was how inter-connected all the characters turned out to be and the ultimate ending. Having been taken in by Mia pretending to be Michelle once, it was a shame to see Liam make the same mistake further down the line. Indeed, having being written out of the picture for so long, the way Liam came back into the novel was a bit coincidental to be believable and the connections between him and Mia throughout to book didn’t feel quite right to me, nor did the soap-opera gangster style ending.
I felt the story was a shame, as the way the book was written was superb. The dialogue was particularly realistic, especially in the way the twins and their mother reacted to each other and to everyone else depending on who needed what from whom. This didn’t just feel right in terms of the dialogue, but felt realistic in terms of the psychology as well, with personalities changing based on the treatment they were receiving and, whilst it may be nasty on my part, I did particularly enjoy seeing Mia’s arrogance taking a hit, but her reactions when she felt a greater betrayal had occurred were psychologically convincing.
I thoroughly enjoyed “Two-Faced” and, based on this, I would be inclined to seek out more of Mandasue Heller’s work. Whilst there were aspects of the story which seemed a little too wild to be real, as if some of the research had happened through fictional sources rather than through direct experience, which did take the edge off, much of the dialogue and the psychology seemed spot on and realistic to me, which made for an enjoyable read. What was great about the story, as well as the fast pacing, outweighed the down moments and made for an entertaining and grittily realistic read.