Most people talk about red tape as thought it were some kind of loathsome disease or the deliberate product of a group of evil conspirators or the result of bureaucratic stupidity and inertia. It is rarely discussed rationally, dispassionately, and analytically; most of us rage about it when it comes up.
In this book, Kaufman attempts a detached examination of the subject to find out why something so universally detested flourishes so widely and enjoys such powers of endurance. Part of the explanation is the protean character of the term "red tape"; each of us applies it to our own pet grievances, not realizing that other people's grievances are often quite different from our own. Underlying this variance, however, is a common core of meaning, and the first part of the book identifies that shared understanding.
The second part searches for the origins of the despised phenomenon in the federal government, and finds the source not in a clique of fools or villains, but in all of us. Red tape, according to this analysis, springs largely from the diversity of values to which people in our society subscribe, from the demands on government to which these values give rise, and from the responsiveness of the government to the demands. In this sense, red tape is of our own making.
Consequently, getting rid of it entirelyrewinding the spools, as it were-is a hopeless quest. The major proposals for eliminating it are found wanting in this regard (though there may be other reasons to favor some of these reforms); they may even generate as much red tape as they cut. That being the case, Kaufman concludes that a more fruitful policy would be to concentrate on relieving the worst of red tape's irritants so as to make bearable what we cannot end, and he explores several steps he believes will have this effect.
Although many readers will find this book depressing, most will probably acknowledge the persuasiveness of its argument. And some, like the author, will take heart from the analysis on the grounds that relief measures rooted in reality are much more likely to succeed than proposals for improvement based on delusive optimism and false hope.
Simple explanations of how the world works and why. Extremely balanced - it praises red tape and explains all the reasons it grows and isn't so simple to be rid of, while acknowledging the goal is to have as little as possible. It's at the perfect level of abstraction: it's explanations are evergreen while being very grounded in practical realities. A masterpiece of a book. Doesn't outstay its welcome.
Not sure this is the book I read, but if so, it is a greatly useful book on bureacracies, red tape, and how they have related to public administration and governance in many historical instances. I read this book for a course I took in public administration, circa 1982, and this is one book that really impressed me, and stayed with me during the ensuing years. Another couple of books I cannot find, that similarly impressed me greatly, were "Choice Points" something about fight or flight and other dipolar choices we all make in our human lives, a social psychology text of around 100 pages or so; and "Class, State and Crime" a truly great survey book with critical analyses of crime and punishment rules, regulations, laws and traditions, and how we got to where we are today. The Author was rumored to be a Marxist, but I found his incisive, "outside the box" thinking refreshing and bracing. If you want to rethink what you think on this subject matter area, from top to bottom, short of grabbing a French Intellectual's book in translation, this is the book for you.
Considering the subject, the book is remarkably short. There's one chapter on what it is, one on why we have it, and one on why we ain't gonna get rid of it any time soon. The topic, tied so closely to the idea of shrinking government, is also quite current since many of Trump's appointees seem to disapprove of the purpose of the agencies they are nominated to head. It will be interesting to see if they can make any headway or if Howard is right that they will only end up generating still more red tape.
Read this for my public administration course. Not bad for a political science book. Also, being that it's really the only book that gives an objective (not purely negative) perspective about the origins and uses of red tape in our government it's a good read. It's dated, but still relevant.