Quite a few spoilers ahead!
Some positive things I have to say about this book are that the writing style and story felt very captivating despite being a middle grade novel and it was lovely to see so much criticism of fox hunting and animal cruelty in general, which was not a totally shared sentiment at the time, and still isn’t today to a lesser extent. However, I’m not sure if the concept of “taming” a wild fox cub, everyone being completely fine with it and it all working out in the end is the best or most realistic message? Of course, it’s only a work of fiction, but children WILL extrapolate this to their own problems and desires, similarly to how David initially wanted to have a pet to be like everyone else and not feel so lonely in his new neighbourhood. Even ignoring the infamous “taming wild animal” trope, I loathe books that imply having a pet will solve all of your problems just like that, as well as religion of course. While this was written in a far less secular time and the story about Saint Francis may initially seem sweet, what happens when a child reader prays, like our protagonist, to Saint Francis extremely hard only for their pet (for example) to never appear, run away or die regardless? The priest tells David to be “less selfish” with his wishes and prayers, but even by the end of the book the boy wants Foxy to survive for himself and for the happiness Foxy provides HIM, so I don’t understand where the potential lesson to kids is there, either? Also, what was up with that escaped convict? I get that, from David’s perspective, he was always helpful and kind, but if we’re being for real his behaviour and scenes in which he appears are so creepy to me. I mean, if ANYONE (criminal or not) tells you not to mention them to your parents or any other adult and literally BREAKS INTO YOUR HOUSE, just maybee something is up.
Anyways, I probably took this children’s book was too seriously haha, but that’s just how I am. The reason I even read this was to help pick favourite fox-related books for an OC of mine (who was hyperfixated on foxes particularly as a child) lmao.