1 star- did not enjoy.
It's been a while since I've met SUCH an unlikeable protagonist. The book centres on the progtaonist's quest to find the perfect man —Mr. Right— despite her previous, unceasing repetition about how she loves being single and single life is amazing. Alice, do you want a life partner or do you just want an extravagant wedding? It seemed to be more about the wedding than the man. Alice was incredibly rude, snotty and discriminatory (how ironic, for someone who prides herself on knowing every single thing about Koori culture and hating on others when they do not). She's the worst part about the book. The plot was repetitive and thus, boring— find a man, find a problem with him, whinge, repeat. This caused the ending to feel incomplete, because this cycle never really could be broken and was just nipped off at this random point. This book bored me and the characters angered me, and ultimately, I wouldn't recommend to anyone.
Longer, more specific review (more so a rant, with this book💀) below. All main points are in bold if you'd rather skim :)
what I liked:
-the diversity? (with a question mark, because Alice's professional hater behaviour felt weirdly (and ironically) white lol).
what I didn't like:
-Alice, the main character.
a) she has SUCH narrow mindsets. For someone who prides herself on being knowledgable about diversity, she is one of the most discriminate characters I've ever met. A chapter into the book, she was telling a MOTHER that she shouldn't be sending her kids to daycare; instead, the mother should've been at home, raising her kids. HELLO? It's 2024. Women ARE allowed to work, Alice. I don't see you talking about the father, either? Are both parents not equally responsible for their children, or are only mothers obligated to erase their need for friends and for financial in this hypothetical, disgustingly misogynistic world of yours? Mothers are people. Everyone needs an environment outside of their home, ESPECIALLY if it's something they want. Alice isn't a mother. Alice wouldn't know. Alice thinks her opinion is relevant anyway, and decides to argue her point with someone who IS a mother. Alice makes me angry for her narrowmindedness, and this is just ONE example of many.
b) she is consistently contradicting herself. She calls herself a feminist (LOL) and goes on to say women shouldn't work when they have kids; they should stay home. She says she loves being single (SO SO MUCH. SO SO SO SO SO SO MUCH) but then acts in embarrassing, desperate ways to find a man. I mean, she EVEN repeats her I love being single mantra WHILE DISCUSSING A MAN SHE'S VERY INTO AND MAKING EXCUSES FOR HIS DISINTEREST. Clearly, Alice, you don't love being single. It's okay to change your mind about something, but to be so deluded that you preach two opposite things SIMULTANEOUSLY, and consistently, is incredibly annoying and confusing.
c) she slut shames people. Again, it's 2024. It's not cute.
d) she judges people (nastily) due to their appearance. She called someone "crater face" because he had chicken pox scars. How incredibly mean. She yelled at a man because he said his grandparents were Aboriginal, but he looked white. Who are you to correct someone's identity? If you don't like how they act, leave them. Why did she have to scream at him lol? Nasty.
e) she cares WAY too much about fake science. Horoscopes are cool and all, but do you really have to base your love life around them? Why did she have to cancel out whole people because she didn't like their horoscope😭 It's not that deep and it's concerning to see people (ahem, Alice) obsessed with it.
f) she's incredibly vain😭 Yes to self-love, but not when it blinds you to literally everything else on the planet. Yes to self-love, but not to the point where you fail to see that there's room for improvement within yourself. Yes to self-love, but not to the point where you make a cringey mantra about how deadly you are and repeat it 24/7. Self-love is loving yourself while working on yourself, not just the belief that you're entirely flawless. Maybe if Alice hadn't been so unlikeable (ie. look at points above) then maybe this wouldn't have been such a problem and maybe it would've come off differently, but it didn't.
-the other characters weren't much better. I just finished the book and I don't remember anyone's names💀
-the plot was repetitive and predictable. Find a man. Date the man. Hate the man. Repeat mantra (I love being single) while crying about man and simultaneously planning wedding to some unknown man. Repeat.
-the ending felt incomplete and weird. Because of the cyclical plot, it felt like the author just needed a spot to wrap things up and chose that random one. BOOM, character has epiphany, BOOM, good man comes into her life (who doesn't even stick around? They decide they're better friends as she finds another new man in the EPILOGUE), BOOM, the end. Sigh.
-the "true" (lmao, let's be real, it probably won't last) romance was only introduced at the end, which meant there was no development. What's the point of a romance with no emotional connection, or a romance where readers aren't able to feel the spark along with the characters?