Understanding Deviance: First Canadian Edition

by Chris McCormick, David Downes, Paul Rock

Understanding Deviance is an essential guide to criminological theory framed in a Canadian context. Prominent theorists such as Durkheim, Merton, and Thrasher are used to highlight the roots of the discipline, while the likes of Cicourel, Matza and Garland show how early approaches can be revised for the present-day. Some of the topics covered include juvenile deviance, street crime, aboriginal poverty, global capitalism, environmental crime, and living in a risk society. To ensure a balanced perspective, the major sociological theories of deviance are coupled with any important criticisms that have been voiced against them. Critical thinking questions and other pedagogical features showcase interesting issues that reflect the complex character of deviance in the modern world and act as a springboard for student exploration. This text offers students and instructors alike an excellent resource for studying deviance from a fresh new standpoint.

Genres: Sociology, Nonfiction

461 pages, Paperback

First published November 10, 1988

Reviews

[Radcliff Gregory · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book may help you if you need to critique the socio-criminology of "deviance", but only to a very limited extent. The book does not properly ground the assorted theories the authors address, and it offers still less in terms of "understanding deviance" .

Downes and Rock do point out that even defining deviance is problematic because of the subjectivity of the subject in general, and the lack of consensus in academic theorisation. However, given that this book was published in the 21st century, some of the behaviours and identities the authors lump under deviance really raised my eyebrows. The book is rampantly homophobic, repeatedly listing homosexuality in the same breath as paedophilia and bestiality, and elsewhere alongside rape and incest, though they do occasionally concede that gay relationships could be considered a "victimless" form of "deviance" . Some of the judgements do feel well over half a century old, given the women giving birth or who have a baby while not in a (heterosexual) relationship are classed as deviants more than once, the first time 'pointing out ' that she will inevitably keep repeating this scenario over and over again. Apparently disabled people are deviants, too...

To be fair, Rock and Downes do make some relevant observations about the various socio-criminological theories of deviance and raise some interesting points. They include a chapter on feminist theories with reasonably modern engagement, but it doesn't stop them, in a different chapter, citing the "'Gay Lib'" and " 'Women's Lib'" (their single quotation marks) as movements arising out of "deviant" subcultures.

One of the better things about this book is coverage of criticism of theories and a huge wealth of ideas for pursuing research, with excellent signposting to relevant further reading, along with an interesting account of the history of sociological and criminological deviance research and theory.