Through a good portion of "The Sound of Wings", I believed the book was going to rate a 4. But reading the final third became a real chore and dragged down the rating. While the writing is good, the actual telling of the story hit too many snags.
To me, the book was more a biography on Amelia Earhart AND George Putnam. Interesting, but not what I was looking for. Maybe a truer cover portrait would be a snapshot of both of them so the reader is prepared. I understand that a nuanced picture of George is essential to getting a complete grasp on Amelia's life, but I got the feeling that Ms. Lovell really wanted to write a biography about George Putnam, a book which would not sell as well as one with Amelia Earhart's picture on the cover. Once finished, I have a much better picture of George than I do of Amelia. Not the book I had planned on reading.
I also felt the book was very biased toward George and the author went to great lengths to excuse his behavior and paint him in a favorable light even as she's relaying all the shitty things he does (such as cheating on his wife, trying to ruin the careers of other female pilots such as Elinor Smith and Mary Heath, bullying people to get his way, etc.). All of which dims my view of Amelia. I can't believe she had no knowledge of the dirty tricks he pulled on the aforementioned pilots, making her complacency quite troubling, and the fact she had no qualms about getting involved with a married man. Yes, people fall out of love with their spouses, but get a divorce and then start fooling around instead of needlessly adding to the third party's hurt. I was especially disgusted by George's successful attempt to drum up publicity for his book by claiming facist terrorists were sending threatening letters, etc., a stunt which prompted a large police investigation costing a great deal of manpower and money. And, still, the author attempts to portray George in a favorable light.
Lovell makes a persuasive case that Amelia and George truly loved one another and that their marriage was not simply a business arrangement as so many people have previously claimed, but she fails to persuade me into thinking that George was anything but an arrogant bully. Not that Amelia didn't have her faults, too. While I understand her resentment of her mother and sister (having to financially support, not only them, but a brother-in-law, too), she could be really annoyingly bossy and condescending, right down to telling them what clothes they could and could not wear. Of course, at the end, her mother is no better, trying to make money off her dead daughter's name.
I really struggled through the last third of the book. Too many technical terms which didn't interest me and too much George, so I started skimming paragraphs in order to get to the meat of the story, Amelia's disappearance and the subsequent search. (I did watch the recent History Channel special about Amelia and Fred Noonan being held prisoner and executed by the Japanese and found it quite interesting and credible.)
I'll end by apologizing if this review does not give you a good overview of Amelia Earhart. All I can say is take that as a warning. If you want a book which discusses her accomplishments, but gives a much clearer view of her husband's personality, then this book is for you. I will end with a question. Can anyone recommend a biography on Amelia Earhart which focuses mainly on her? While I'm glad to have read "The Sound of Wings", as stated previously in this review, this was not the book I was hoping to read.