What do you think?
Rate this book
Windows in Time #1
Windows in Time
Fate added injury to insult when Jonah Sellers’s live-in boyfriend left while moving out his ex’s belongings, Jonah fell down the stairs and broke his leg. Now his house is a prison, and he's working from home while his sister checks up on him. The only diversion in Jonah’s routine is catching the odd glimpse of a man in the apartment across the way taking off his clothes in front of the window.
But then Jonah is distracted by Liam Brooks, the nurse his sister sends over when she goes on vacation. As they dance around their growing attraction, Jonah and Liam begin to wonder about the man in the window. Why is he always dressed in the same clothes? Why is he there one minute and not the next? How is it that he lives in an old woman's apartment? It's while trying to answer these questions that they stumble across a fifty-year-old missing persons case they can't resist trying to solve.
But then Jonah is distracted by Liam Brooks, the nurse his sister sends over when she goes on vacation. As they dance around their growing attraction, Jonah and Liam begin to wonder about the man in the window. Why is he always dressed in the same clothes? Why is he there one minute and not the next? How is it that he lives in an old woman's apartment? It's while trying to answer these questions that they stumble across a fifty-year-old missing persons case they can't resist trying to solve.
221 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 1, 2009
6 people are currently reading
484 people want to read
About the author
M. Jules Aedin
12 books109 followersGrowing up Southern has been an interesting experience for Jules, who discovered that labels for things like gender and sexuality are, at best, approximations. When not reading or playing video games or writing (or doing all three at once!) Jules is generally trying to convincingly pretend to be a responsible adult and at least do laundry once in a while. Oh, and show up for the evil day job and finish that pesky degree that's been languishing for a while now...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
September 3, 2010
Housebond after he broke his leg, Jonah Seller discovers that there is something very intriguing happens through his apartment window, as he sees an image of a handsome man in the process of stripping. But the image appears and disappears and it makes Jonah wonders. When his young and attractive nurse, Liam, shares his interest, Jonah is involved in ghost hunt and a possibility of a new relationship.
There are two stories happening in this story; one in present time between Jonah and Liam and the other one involves "the ghost" in the window, between Buck Addison (a Hollywood reporter) and Oliver Caldwell, a son from wealthy businessman who likes to cross dresses as Minna Redding, a gorgeous woman back in 1957. I do like both stories, even though Buck/Oliver's story is more tragic. Jonah and Liam's on the other hand is a bit lighter and slowly develops. As characters, though, I find Buck and Oliver to be more "present" compared to Jonah and Liam. Buck and Oliver feel like the players, the ones with stronger story to tell, while Jonah and Liam act more like the audience. Even the revelation of what had happened to Buck and Oliver is more like "a coincidence" rather than a thorough investigation.
I have read Ms. Aedin's short stories prior to this and I love them so much. My only "complaint" for this story is that it lacks of that "first grip". Not the book mistake, merely my own preference. When it comes to full length novel, I prefer stories that give me the "kick in the solar plexus"; it can be in form of dead bodies (yes, I like my murder/mystery, thank you *g*), angst, intense emotion, or just things that squeezes my heart and won't let go.
This one feels like it flows a plot in timely pattern, no real conflict until near the end. Everything is fine and dandy, even the "danger" that Buck and Oliver must overcome doesn't feel like threatening, well, until near the end. It's romantic, sure, but I have a problem to read it as fast as I want because it takes time for the climax.
BUT, I still give it a 4 star review because in overall, it's still a lovely story and wonderfully written. I will keep my eyes on Ms. Aedin's other stories, most definitely.
There are two stories happening in this story; one in present time between Jonah and Liam and the other one involves "the ghost" in the window, between Buck Addison (a Hollywood reporter) and Oliver Caldwell, a son from wealthy businessman who likes to cross dresses as Minna Redding, a gorgeous woman back in 1957. I do like both stories, even though Buck/Oliver's story is more tragic. Jonah and Liam's on the other hand is a bit lighter and slowly develops. As characters, though, I find Buck and Oliver to be more "present" compared to Jonah and Liam. Buck and Oliver feel like the players, the ones with stronger story to tell, while Jonah and Liam act more like the audience. Even the revelation of what had happened to Buck and Oliver is more like "a coincidence" rather than a thorough investigation.
I have read Ms. Aedin's short stories prior to this and I love them so much. My only "complaint" for this story is that it lacks of that "first grip". Not the book mistake, merely my own preference. When it comes to full length novel, I prefer stories that give me the "kick in the solar plexus"; it can be in form of dead bodies (yes, I like my murder/mystery, thank you *g*), angst, intense emotion, or just things that squeezes my heart and won't let go.
This one feels like it flows a plot in timely pattern, no real conflict until near the end. Everything is fine and dandy, even the "danger" that Buck and Oliver must overcome doesn't feel like threatening, well, until near the end. It's romantic, sure, but I have a problem to read it as fast as I want because it takes time for the climax.
BUT, I still give it a 4 star review because in overall, it's still a lovely story and wonderfully written. I will keep my eyes on Ms. Aedin's other stories, most definitely.
May 18, 2022
Interesting mystery if a little over the top. The main love story was awkward and boring but Oliver and Buck were delightful.
December 14, 2009
This was a really cool book. I love the interweaving of the two stories, with Jonah and Liam in the present, and Buck and Oliver in the past. We not only get Buck and Oliver's tale from their perspective, but we get a peak at what history says about the two men who disappeared, with the mysterious Minna, on the same day back in the 1950's.
After reading a bunch of present day m/m romance books, it was interesting to see a gay couple portrayed in the 1950's.
After reading a bunch of present day m/m romance books, it was interesting to see a gay couple portrayed in the 1950's.
September 28, 2009
I loved that there were two stories tied together (two for the price of one!). I enjoyed all the characters. I thought Aedin did a good job of building up the mystery and suspense, and the reason for Liam's reluctance really hadn't occurred to me so that was a cool surprise. Intelligent and witty writing. Loved it!
August 19, 2009
As a fan of the author’s short stories, I had some trepidation if the excellence of previous work can be extended into longer novels. It’s not always a smooth and positive transition but Aedin has delivered a wonderfully engrossing tale of two sets of lovers. Clever with a bit of homage to the Hitchcock’s classic “Rear View Window,” the interesting take on the concept allows this great book to stand on its own. Emotional and sensual without any explicit sex, this is a classic romance story that is sure to delight fans. Be sure to set aside the time so you can read the book in one sitting, you won’t want to put it down.
Jonah Seller’s is having a rough month. His boyfriend of three years left him and in the process of moving the inevitable boxes, Jonah broke his leg. Now housebound, the inspiring writer discovers an image of the man in the apartment directly across from his. This image appears and disappears, tantalizing the often bored Jonah who can’t resist the distraction. Soon, Jonah involves ghost lover Liam into the mystery and the two balance a slow seduction with an irresistible ghost hunt.
The book follows two stories in parallel. The first is the story of Jonah and Liam as they meet and become embroiled in this mystery. Their relationship has a few stops and starts as the shy Liam and emotionally recovering Jonah don’t just fall into bed together. Alternating chapters with this story is the relationship between Buck and Oliver set in 1957, the months before both men went missing. Buck is a Hollywood reporter and Oliver is the son of a local wealthy businessman. The relationship has its own problems as Buck is a closeted homosexual and Oliver frequently cross dresses as a gorgeous woman. The stories contain numerous parallels as the two relationships progress to the climax of the book when the mystery of Buck and Oliver’s disappearance is finally solved.
The combination of the two stories is wonderfully blended, showing the parallels between the characters and situations even as they are separated by half a century. The story is told from third person point of view from Jonah and Buck’s perspective; however, all four of the main characters are given depth and developed as much as possible. Oliver is perhaps the least well known of the characters but this only increases his appeal as his emotions are clearly shown through various situations, quiet comments, and pictures during that time. Oliver is a complicated character as he struggles with his dual nature as Oliver and Minna, while trusting his heart to Buck. Oliver has hidden depths and strengths for all his fragile and pretty exterior and captivates scenes.
Buck is an equally interesting character but perhaps less complicated than Oliver. He is strong and outgoing while covering a deeply romantic and sensualist persona. He loves the game of Hollywood and the mystique of escorting Oliver as Minna, a subtle finger to the oppressive environment. Buck is also a wonderful support for Oliver, falling for his female persona first and then Oliver with his masculine strength and force of will. Buck’s musing sums up his feelings about Oliver perfectly:
He was mouthwatering as a man and was the only woman who had ever made Buck’s heart beat double-time.
Buck and Jonah have many parallels in their characters and response to love. Both men reach for happiness where it exists and only question their actions in regards to how the other man is affected. This selflessness is an essential part of both Buck and Jonah. Whereas Buck leaps headfirst into the relationship with Oliver, Jonah has several moments questioning if he is on the rebound and will ultimately hurt the shy, questioning Liam. Jonah experiences frustration with Liam’s actions but eventually comes to understand Liam, his soft heart, and inability to communicate very well. Jonah instinctively understands the other man, eliminating Liam’s awkwardness and replacing it with an attractive confidence. Jonah’s curiosity and sensuality are an inherent part of his personality and add a wonderful texture to the character.
Liam is perhaps the least interesting of the four men, but not by much. His love of ghosts and desire to live a secret life as a ghost hunter on TAPS is hilarious and adds a quirky charm to the sometimes tongue tied young man. His competency and confidence emerge just as often creating a dynamic, multifaceted character. Liam parallels Oliver in a lot of ways, but perhaps less so than Buck and Jonah. The couples are clearly drawn to show their connections, with each other and with each couple, yet there are inherent differences and unique attributes that define the men as individuals.
The tale is engrossing and absorbing, even as the mystery is predictable. The mystery itself and the question of what happened to Oliver and Buck is not meant to be surprising and shocking, although whether the two run away together or something more sinister is a question to the very end. The journey and relationship of both couples is really the main element, and strength, of the story. It’s not so much of a who-dun-it or even a question of why, but the depth of emotion, the progression of both relationships and the exploration of the characters which shine and engage the reader. Both stories are incredibly romantic and sensual without adding explicit sex, instead allowing the men and their emotional connection to entice and tantalize. The combination produces a lovely story of four men, set half a century apart, and still modern.
Wonderfully written and instantly engaging, this story will appeal to romance fans and especially those who love a glimpse at old Hollywood. The dual settings are well crafted and although they are more for atmosphere, the texture and detail add to the fuller picture. The clever twist on the classic idea show how homage can shine while creating a story standing easily on its own without too much comparison. Be sure to pick up this book, you won’t be disappointed.
Jonah Seller’s is having a rough month. His boyfriend of three years left him and in the process of moving the inevitable boxes, Jonah broke his leg. Now housebound, the inspiring writer discovers an image of the man in the apartment directly across from his. This image appears and disappears, tantalizing the often bored Jonah who can’t resist the distraction. Soon, Jonah involves ghost lover Liam into the mystery and the two balance a slow seduction with an irresistible ghost hunt.
The book follows two stories in parallel. The first is the story of Jonah and Liam as they meet and become embroiled in this mystery. Their relationship has a few stops and starts as the shy Liam and emotionally recovering Jonah don’t just fall into bed together. Alternating chapters with this story is the relationship between Buck and Oliver set in 1957, the months before both men went missing. Buck is a Hollywood reporter and Oliver is the son of a local wealthy businessman. The relationship has its own problems as Buck is a closeted homosexual and Oliver frequently cross dresses as a gorgeous woman. The stories contain numerous parallels as the two relationships progress to the climax of the book when the mystery of Buck and Oliver’s disappearance is finally solved.
The combination of the two stories is wonderfully blended, showing the parallels between the characters and situations even as they are separated by half a century. The story is told from third person point of view from Jonah and Buck’s perspective; however, all four of the main characters are given depth and developed as much as possible. Oliver is perhaps the least well known of the characters but this only increases his appeal as his emotions are clearly shown through various situations, quiet comments, and pictures during that time. Oliver is a complicated character as he struggles with his dual nature as Oliver and Minna, while trusting his heart to Buck. Oliver has hidden depths and strengths for all his fragile and pretty exterior and captivates scenes.
Buck is an equally interesting character but perhaps less complicated than Oliver. He is strong and outgoing while covering a deeply romantic and sensualist persona. He loves the game of Hollywood and the mystique of escorting Oliver as Minna, a subtle finger to the oppressive environment. Buck is also a wonderful support for Oliver, falling for his female persona first and then Oliver with his masculine strength and force of will. Buck’s musing sums up his feelings about Oliver perfectly:
He was mouthwatering as a man and was the only woman who had ever made Buck’s heart beat double-time.
Buck and Jonah have many parallels in their characters and response to love. Both men reach for happiness where it exists and only question their actions in regards to how the other man is affected. This selflessness is an essential part of both Buck and Jonah. Whereas Buck leaps headfirst into the relationship with Oliver, Jonah has several moments questioning if he is on the rebound and will ultimately hurt the shy, questioning Liam. Jonah experiences frustration with Liam’s actions but eventually comes to understand Liam, his soft heart, and inability to communicate very well. Jonah instinctively understands the other man, eliminating Liam’s awkwardness and replacing it with an attractive confidence. Jonah’s curiosity and sensuality are an inherent part of his personality and add a wonderful texture to the character.
Liam is perhaps the least interesting of the four men, but not by much. His love of ghosts and desire to live a secret life as a ghost hunter on TAPS is hilarious and adds a quirky charm to the sometimes tongue tied young man. His competency and confidence emerge just as often creating a dynamic, multifaceted character. Liam parallels Oliver in a lot of ways, but perhaps less so than Buck and Jonah. The couples are clearly drawn to show their connections, with each other and with each couple, yet there are inherent differences and unique attributes that define the men as individuals.
The tale is engrossing and absorbing, even as the mystery is predictable. The mystery itself and the question of what happened to Oliver and Buck is not meant to be surprising and shocking, although whether the two run away together or something more sinister is a question to the very end. The journey and relationship of both couples is really the main element, and strength, of the story. It’s not so much of a who-dun-it or even a question of why, but the depth of emotion, the progression of both relationships and the exploration of the characters which shine and engage the reader. Both stories are incredibly romantic and sensual without adding explicit sex, instead allowing the men and their emotional connection to entice and tantalize. The combination produces a lovely story of four men, set half a century apart, and still modern.
Wonderfully written and instantly engaging, this story will appeal to romance fans and especially those who love a glimpse at old Hollywood. The dual settings are well crafted and although they are more for atmosphere, the texture and detail add to the fuller picture. The clever twist on the classic idea show how homage can shine while creating a story standing easily on its own without too much comparison. Be sure to pick up this book, you won’t be disappointed.
September 17, 2009
I don't even know where to start on this review because there's so much I want to say and so much I want to divulge but this is one of those books that you go back to and say, "holy shit, it's like I was there!"
What I liked about this book: First of all, this is NOT your typical romance and though all of the elements of a truly erotic romance are there, it's truly a "whodunit" book that sucks you into the lives of these two couples separated only by time. Aedin takes you on a journey that spans 2 months separated by 50 years. This is CSI meets QAF meets M. JULES AEDIN
After reading this one, I desperately needed a break because I knew any other book that followed this read would pale in comparison to this book. If you've read Ally Blue's Bay City Paranormal Investigations Series, you'll see a shout-out to her in this book and her influence is felt in the medical aspects of the book but Aedin's "haunting" scenes are all her own and amazing!
Oh and let's not forget the cross-dressing character in the 1950s that you completely fall in love with! What's NOT to love about this book? Don't think about it, just go buy this book. Right now!
Summary: Fate added injury to insult when Jonah Sellers’s live-in boyfriend left him: while moving out his ex’s belongings, Jonah fell down the stairs and broke his leg. Now his house is a prison, and he's working from home while his sister checks up on him. The only diversion in Jonah’s routine is catching the odd glimpse of a man in the apartment across the way taking off his clothes in front of the window.
But then Jonah is distracted by Liam Brooks, the nurse his sister sends over when she goes on vacation. As they dance around their growing attraction, Jonah and Liam begin to wonder about the man in the window. Why is he always dressed in the same clothes? Why is he there one minute and not the next? How is it that he lives in an old woman's apartment? It's while trying to answer these questions that they stumble across a fifty-year-old missing persons case they can't resist trying to solve.
What I liked about this book: First of all, this is NOT your typical romance and though all of the elements of a truly erotic romance are there, it's truly a "whodunit" book that sucks you into the lives of these two couples separated only by time. Aedin takes you on a journey that spans 2 months separated by 50 years. This is CSI meets QAF meets M. JULES AEDIN
After reading this one, I desperately needed a break because I knew any other book that followed this read would pale in comparison to this book. If you've read Ally Blue's Bay City Paranormal Investigations Series, you'll see a shout-out to her in this book and her influence is felt in the medical aspects of the book but Aedin's "haunting" scenes are all her own and amazing!
Oh and let's not forget the cross-dressing character in the 1950s that you completely fall in love with! What's NOT to love about this book? Don't think about it, just go buy this book. Right now!
Excerpt: “Shh,” Buck murmured, bending down and trailing his lips from the nape of Oliver‟s neck down his spine until he found the zipper of the dress. He caught the piece of metal in his teeth and tugged, the metallic click of each inch loud in his ears. When he finished, he was kneeling behind Oliver, his nose pressed into the
smooth skin of Oliver‟s lower back and the soft fabric of the dress
cool against his face.
Oliver trembled, and Buck held his hips, steadying him.
“Buck….” Oliver‟s hand came back, fumbling for him, and landed in his hair; his fingers tightened, pulling, tugging Buck closer. Buck let his tongue flick out, painting long, wide stripes across Oliver‟s back. “Buck, please.”
“You taste so good,” Buck whispered, nipping the swell of Oliver‟s hip. “I want to eat you alive.”
Oliver groaned, and Buck sank his teeth into the soft flesh again, worrying the hard knob of bone beneath the skin and muscle. Oliver‟s fingers tightened again, tugging with purpose this time, trying to force Buck back up his body.
“Come here,” Oliver demanded breathlessly. Buck rocked back on his heels and looked up at his lover. Oliver‟s dress hung open, the dark wig askew and the natural gold of Oliver‟s hair showing above one ear. His pale skin was flushed in shades of rose, starting in his face and neck and spreading down his shoulders and back.
Buck stood, feeling his knees protest, and molded himself to Oliver‟s back.
“So beautiful,” he murmured, his lips brushing Oliver‟s ear.
Oliver wriggled, breaking Buck‟s grip so he could turn to face him. A small smile claimed Buck‟s mouth; he forgot how strong Oliver was until moments like that, when Oliver challenged him. The dress slipped as Oliver pressed against him, shifting to reveal a flushed chest and erect nipples. Hardness pressed into Buck‟s hip, matching and mirroring Buck‟s arousal.
“Make love to me,” Oliver sighed, mouth pressed to Buck‟s so that each word vibrated through him. Buck pursed his lips, turning it into a kiss, and nudged Oliver toward the bed.
October 19, 2009
This book has, to my embarrassment, been sitting in my TBR for a couple, or perhaps even more, months. And now I'm kicking myself because this story is out-and-out fabulous and a book that I would have already re-read.
Windows in Time is a story so rich in detail, characters, scenes... just everything, that you would always discover another nugget of gold, another delicious tidbit of knowledge, something that would make a re-read almost as fresh as the first time. Of course this would probably work better for people who really enjoy re-reading, but even so....
There are just so many parts of the book about which I could rave; I could also go on ad infinitum... but I won't. Instead I'll mention just how fascinating I found the basic premise, the mystery of who, what and where. Windows in Time is an amalgamation of two separate, by 50 years!, but also closely related, stories. How M. Jules Aedin did this in such a seamless and compelling manner leaves me in awe of her talent.
Then there are the subtle connections between the past and the present that really give me a good case of goosebumps... over and over again.
The gradual, or perhaps not-so-gradual, development of the relationships between the men.
Truly spell-binding this is a ghost story, a fantastic mystery and a beautiful romance, or two, all entwined to create a tale that will live on in my mind for a long time to come.
At least until I read it again... or get an opportunity to buy a print version.
Fabulous, truly fabulous...and I hope that there are many more stories from the pen of M. Jules Aedin. I'll be there!
Windows in Time is a story so rich in detail, characters, scenes... just everything, that you would always discover another nugget of gold, another delicious tidbit of knowledge, something that would make a re-read almost as fresh as the first time. Of course this would probably work better for people who really enjoy re-reading, but even so....
There are just so many parts of the book about which I could rave; I could also go on ad infinitum... but I won't. Instead I'll mention just how fascinating I found the basic premise, the mystery of who, what and where. Windows in Time is an amalgamation of two separate, by 50 years!, but also closely related, stories. How M. Jules Aedin did this in such a seamless and compelling manner leaves me in awe of her talent.
Then there are the subtle connections between the past and the present that really give me a good case of goosebumps... over and over again.
The gradual, or perhaps not-so-gradual, development of the relationships between the men.
Truly spell-binding this is a ghost story, a fantastic mystery and a beautiful romance, or two, all entwined to create a tale that will live on in my mind for a long time to come.
At least until I read it again... or get an opportunity to buy a print version.
Fabulous, truly fabulous...and I hope that there are many more stories from the pen of M. Jules Aedin. I'll be there!
October 22, 2012
This book had an interesting structure to it, there are two parallel stories: one in the present day and one in 1957.
Present day we have Jonah Seller, a writer, who has a severely broken leg that he got after a fall when he and his live in lover broke up. Liam Brooks is a nurse who works for Jonah's sister and he's checking up on the injured man while the sister is out of town.
In the past we have another writer, Buck Addison and Oliver Caldwell, the wealthy son of an industrialist family who lives a secret life.
I was much more attracted to the second story line and the characters in it. I found them more compelling and their trials more poignant than the contemporary story.
The contemporary story has some interesting parts as the men tried to solve the mystery but the romance didn't really work for me. I did like Jonah but I had a hard time connecting with Liam. I found myself more confused by his reactions to situations and the brief glimpse we saw of his previous romantic history just seemed so out of place to me in the book.
I really, really enjoyed the story of Buck and Oliver though. Their romance just worked so beautifully. I read the book to find out what happened to them because I cared about them and their story. I wish we had gotten more about them but in the end it was a good mystery that had very different storylines that were just a bit too unbalanced.
Present day we have Jonah Seller, a writer, who has a severely broken leg that he got after a fall when he and his live in lover broke up. Liam Brooks is a nurse who works for Jonah's sister and he's checking up on the injured man while the sister is out of town.
In the past we have another writer, Buck Addison and Oliver Caldwell, the wealthy son of an industrialist family who lives a secret life.
I was much more attracted to the second story line and the characters in it. I found them more compelling and their trials more poignant than the contemporary story.
The contemporary story has some interesting parts as the men tried to solve the mystery but the romance didn't really work for me. I did like Jonah but I had a hard time connecting with Liam. I found myself more confused by his reactions to situations and the brief glimpse we saw of his previous romantic history just seemed so out of place to me in the book.
I really, really enjoyed the story of Buck and Oliver though. Their romance just worked so beautifully. I read the book to find out what happened to them because I cared about them and their story. I wish we had gotten more about them but in the end it was a good mystery that had very different storylines that were just a bit too unbalanced.
January 18, 2012
After falling down the stairs in his apartment building and and breaking his leg, sheer impracticality confines Jonah to his apartment while his leg heals. Little does he know that the broken leg will lead him to solving a 50 year old mystery as well as finally finding love.
The story follows events in two timelines - the present time and 50 years earlier - and the switch between the two times is handled well by the author. While I liked the two MC's from the present, I loved the two MC's from the past. Perhaps this is due to the sense of impending doom for this couple, but I certainly felt a greater emotional connection to them compared to that of the present couple. In the end though, I felt satisfied by the story, as everything was tied up neatly... Definitely a novel to consider when in the mood for a ghost story,
The story follows events in two timelines - the present time and 50 years earlier - and the switch between the two times is handled well by the author. While I liked the two MC's from the present, I loved the two MC's from the past. Perhaps this is due to the sense of impending doom for this couple, but I certainly felt a greater emotional connection to them compared to that of the present couple. In the end though, I felt satisfied by the story, as everything was tied up neatly... Definitely a novel to consider when in the mood for a ghost story,
August 12, 2009
This is two stories running in parallel with interconnections of a ghostly nature. It serves as a useful illustration of the McCarthy era and compares those times with now. (I had to check whether Saran Wrap was around in 1957, and yes it was, invented in 1953!) It is hot in a discreet way (if that makes any sense at all) by which I mean there is not much graphic sex but the implications are fantastic and it was a great story all round. Don't worry, it is not one of those ones where there is hanky panky between ghosts and alive people, everyone keeps to their own time zone in that regard.
April 19, 2016
What a well done and enjoyable mystery. Windows in Time is actually 2 stories running side by side, one set it current time and one happening 50 years earlier. However, they also overlap each other. At first I found the flipping back and forth from the present to the past to be a little disconcerting but there really was no other way for this story to be told, so once I adjusted to the storyflow it was a nonissue for me as my mind just went with the flow and enjoyed the story being presented to me. For anyone who enjoys a good mystery with a touch of romance thrown in Windows in Time is a perfect choice.
October 3, 2015
4.5 stars rounded up
Get ready to cry. Within a few chapters, I was already getting stressed and worried, and by the end, I was bawling my head off. I don't like to cry when I read. I read for pleasure, for escape from that which makes me cry, but I still thought this was a great book. It's not one I'll read again, but I do recommend it.
It helps that the book is really funny in parts, particularly the pieces that occur in the present. For example, I loved the opening:
I absolutely loved the characters from the past. They were a beautiful couple, and I was much more invested in their story than the one in the present. But it was all about homophobia, which is the main reason I can't handle historicals. It was very clear what was in the past and what was in the present as well, so that made it easier to read.
The plot in the current time was much more predictable but there was a little bit of "What's going on?" in the beginning. Jonah made some odd assumptions about it, though. Such as, Buck seems sort of maybe interested but reluctant, then Jonah surprises him with a kiss as he's leaving. Buck rushes out. He's really interested in the mystery, though, and he comes over the next day just to some new information Jonah's found, but he doesn't want to stay for dinner. Jonah is upset and confused thinking Buck is giving him mixed messages. My assumption in his place would have been, "Oh, I moved too fast," or "Maybe I misread Buck," followed by "He's probably uncomfortable and worried I'm going to jump him. He wants to stay friends but wants to make it clear we're not dating."
A couple of nitpicks:
There were a couple of places where it was hard to picture what was happening, and some that were just impossible. For example, in the middle of penetration,
They talk about a pediatric nurse not having access to any drugs for sale with one joking, "You never know. Some ADD=plagued crack pimp somewhere might give you a good price on it." There is a street value for Ritalin because it's basically speed, so do be careful with it.
How do you peak in the windows of a penthouse?
As is so common in M/M romance books, Jonah believes that because of his "biology," he'll never have kids of his own. His biology isn't preventing that at all, nor is his sexuality. He may not be able to have biological kids that are half him and half his partner, but there are plenty of options for having kids, including biological ones. This way of thinking drives me up the freakin' wall.
Overall, this was a really good book. The mystery and romance parts were equally important, although the mystery surrounded a romance as well. It was funny in many places, heartbreaking in others, but if you can handle a good cry, then I highly recommend the book.
Get ready to cry. Within a few chapters, I was already getting stressed and worried, and by the end, I was bawling my head off. I don't like to cry when I read. I read for pleasure, for escape from that which makes me cry, but I still thought this was a great book. It's not one I'll read again, but I do recommend it.
It helps that the book is really funny in parts, particularly the pieces that occur in the present. For example, I loved the opening:
It was a dark and stormy night.The mystery was interesting. Although most of it wasn't too difficult to figure out, it was uncertain what really happened until the nail-biting end. The part in the past in particular was really interesting and propelling.
"Of course it was a dark night, you dumbass. Is night ever anything else?"
I absolutely loved the characters from the past. They were a beautiful couple, and I was much more invested in their story than the one in the present. But it was all about homophobia, which is the main reason I can't handle historicals. It was very clear what was in the past and what was in the present as well, so that made it easier to read.
The plot in the current time was much more predictable but there was a little bit of "What's going on?" in the beginning. Jonah made some odd assumptions about it, though. Such as, Buck seems sort of maybe interested but reluctant, then Jonah surprises him with a kiss as he's leaving. Buck rushes out. He's really interested in the mystery, though, and he comes over the next day just to some new information Jonah's found, but he doesn't want to stay for dinner. Jonah is upset and confused thinking Buck is giving him mixed messages. My assumption in his place would have been, "Oh, I moved too fast," or "Maybe I misread Buck," followed by "He's probably uncomfortable and worried I'm going to jump him. He wants to stay friends but wants to make it clear we're not dating."
A couple of nitpicks:
There were a couple of places where it was hard to picture what was happening, and some that were just impossible. For example, in the middle of penetration,
"Beautiful," xxx muttered, leaning forward, resting his forehead against the upper swell of yyy's ass.Unless he's a contortionist, I don't see how that's feasible.
They talk about a pediatric nurse not having access to any drugs for sale with one joking, "You never know. Some ADD=plagued crack pimp somewhere might give you a good price on it." There is a street value for Ritalin because it's basically speed, so do be careful with it.
How do you peak in the windows of a penthouse?
As is so common in M/M romance books, Jonah believes that because of his "biology," he'll never have kids of his own. His biology isn't preventing that at all, nor is his sexuality. He may not be able to have biological kids that are half him and half his partner, but there are plenty of options for having kids, including biological ones. This way of thinking drives me up the freakin' wall.
Overall, this was a really good book. The mystery and romance parts were equally important, although the mystery surrounded a romance as well. It was funny in many places, heartbreaking in others, but if you can handle a good cry, then I highly recommend the book.
June 7, 2017
Reading this book has been a unique experience for me. It's taken me out of my comfort zone, but at the same it's amused me and made me love the story and the main characters.
As you already know, this book intertwines two different stories. Although they seem unrelated at first sight, they are becoming more and more related as you read page after page. Without spoiling anything, I should add the fact that one story is dark, while the other is lovely and humorous. It's a really interesting combination in my opinion. Whenever I felt sad about an event, the other story just came up and cheered me.
In one story, we have Buck, a classically handsome journalist, and his part-time cross-dresser lover, Oliver/Minna. These two incredible characters have an interesting and thought provoking tale to tell. On the other story, we have Jonah, a classically handsome freelance writer, and Liam, a cute nurse who is looking after Jonah, because of his injury. Actually, Jonah's sister has sent Liam to do this task while she is enjoying her vacation with her family. There is a passion that slowly builds up between Jonah and Liam. It's lovely, albeit a little cliched ;) .
As story goes by, you will learn more and more about these characters, their dark past, and their secrets. While there is no detailed sex scene in this book, the fully described emotions of the characters, can trigger your every sense, sexual sense included.
So Bijan :), why not 5 stars?
I can justify it by saying that in my opinion, there were some awkward situations in this book. Although they were not many, they gave me a sense of annoyance. For example, there was a scene when This example alone can subtract one star from this book for me. But overall, it's an amazing book with lots of great moments of joy and pain.
As you already know, this book intertwines two different stories. Although they seem unrelated at first sight, they are becoming more and more related as you read page after page. Without spoiling anything, I should add the fact that one story is dark, while the other is lovely and humorous. It's a really interesting combination in my opinion. Whenever I felt sad about an event, the other story just came up and cheered me.
In one story, we have Buck, a classically handsome journalist, and his part-time cross-dresser lover, Oliver/Minna. These two incredible characters have an interesting and thought provoking tale to tell. On the other story, we have Jonah, a classically handsome freelance writer, and Liam, a cute nurse who is looking after Jonah, because of his injury. Actually, Jonah's sister has sent Liam to do this task while she is enjoying her vacation with her family. There is a passion that slowly builds up between Jonah and Liam. It's lovely, albeit a little cliched ;) .
As story goes by, you will learn more and more about these characters, their dark past, and their secrets. While there is no detailed sex scene in this book, the fully described emotions of the characters, can trigger your every sense, sexual sense included.
So Bijan :), why not 5 stars?
I can justify it by saying that in my opinion, there were some awkward situations in this book. Although they were not many, they gave me a sense of annoyance. For example, there was a scene when This example alone can subtract one star from this book for me. But overall, it's an amazing book with lots of great moments of joy and pain.
June 17, 2011
This story read like watching Cold Case. I loved the series so this was a joy for me. It was very emotionally poignant, sucking me in. I could mentally see myself in that era, wanting what other’s said I couldn’t have and not having the heart to let it go. At first I couldn’t make the connection with Liam and Jonah but that was a point the author was making. The connection with Oliver and Buck was fast in furious because it had to be. In that time there was no stopping to get to know each other, the fact that they did get to know each other any way is proof to the love inside that igniting passion. Liam and Jonah how ever are in another era where they’ve both had a chance to have their heart broken and are more careful, so it takes longer to get to know them. To feel that passion but that doesn’t make it any less special. This is the authors nod to the change in times and to the fact that slow love is not less special than fast burning passion. Lasting love doesn’t care how you get there, just that you do… I personally enjoyed the book for so many different reasons. Because it forced me to look at how things used to be and though I bitch and complain that things are still unfair, we have come a long way. They emotional plays were well thought out as well. The different layers to the book leaves a little bit of everything to enjoy. Though the story was short, I never felt it was too short and that the author left questions hanging because of it. I'll be reading this author again.
October 5, 2009
I liked the way the two stories, one from the past, and one from the present day, were interwoven.
The characters were great, very vivid and real. Jonah was funny in his role as suffering reconvalescent. Liam was adorbale, if somewhat inexplicably hesitant. I didn't get as close to them and their motivations as I did to Buck and Oliver. Which is probably why the ending of their story hit me harder than it should have. I kept hoping for a different outcome.
While the mystery element added a bit of spice, the ending was horrible (if predictable), and even the epilogue didn't change that for me.
The characters were great, very vivid and real. Jonah was funny in his role as suffering reconvalescent. Liam was adorbale, if somewhat inexplicably hesitant. I didn't get as close to them and their motivations as I did to Buck and Oliver. Which is probably why the ending of their story hit me harder than it should have. I kept hoping for a different outcome.
While the mystery element added a bit of spice, the ending was horrible (if predictable), and even the epilogue didn't change that for me.
July 3, 2011
4.5 stars For the GBQ3 challenged recommended by PUshubuu. This one is a little homage to Hitchcock's Rear Window. Jonah is injured and basically housebound & passes the time looking out the window at his neighbor. One day he spies an interesting sight... This one also features two couples leading somewhat parallel lives; one in 1957 & the other 2007. The 1957 couple is more fleshed out than the more current one. There is a feeling of tension reading their stories as you know there's only a couple of ways it can end. This is a good romantic suspense story.
February 4, 2012
How much do I love Buck and Oliver! Their story kept me absolutely fan girl fawning over their old Hollywood love story. This is the second ghost related book where the ghost pair has me so much more enraptured than the living couple. Although, I really do love Jonah and Liam as well.
The author did a great job of bringing out the personalities of all these characters and had me completely riveted to understanding how the mystery of Buck and Oliver ends, even when you know there won't be an HEA for them (or maybe?). Such a great read!
The author did a great job of bringing out the personalities of all these characters and had me completely riveted to understanding how the mystery of Buck and Oliver ends, even when you know there won't be an HEA for them (or maybe?). Such a great read!
April 24, 2012
This was a very enjoyable read. The author deftly alternates two parallel plotlines--one contemporary and the other taking place in the 1950s--which come together by the end of the book. Likable characters, each with nicely delineated characteristics. The secrecy of being gay in the 1950s is effectively contrasted with the more open acceptance of the modern-day world. Without getting specific, this book incorporates some interesting plot elements that don't occur often in m/m fiction.
November 11, 2009
Very Hitchcock. A lovely romance, not too suspenseful a mystery - moves between 2 stories - but kept my interest due to the well-balanced and engaging characterisation. No explicit sex, but still sensual.
Would give 4½ if possible.
Would give 4½ if possible.
February 16, 2010
There are two romance interwined together in this story. It's a nice twist of a story clearly inspired by Rear Window. I thoroughly enjoyed the book, but I wish the main character's romance is as engrossing and fleshed out as the old one that he "witnessed" through his window.
June 7, 2012
Really enjoyed the characters, and the love stories set 5o years apart.
February 16, 2015
O-M-G! TEARJERKER alert! T______T
Read
March 21, 2017No rating because I skimmed most of the past chapters. I only continued because I wanted to know what had happened in the past, but then the ghost revealed them all, so the MCs didn't really solve the mystery. The MCs were kind of interchangeable, and I didn't care about their romance.
August 19, 2011
Jonah Sellers is stuck inside his house, a prisoner thanks to a broken leg. To add insult to injury, Jonah was hurt tripping over his ex-boyfriend's stuff while the man moved out of their apartment. Due to his serious lack of mobility, Jonah’s sister Stephanie has been stopping by frequently to bring him groceries and check in on him. When his sister goes on vacation with her family, she hires a nurse to look in on Jonah while she’s away. The last person Jonah expected is Liam Brooks, who is young and gorgeous and peaks Jonah's interest immediately.
Jonah’s sentence of being trapped in his house gets quite a bit more exciting when he sees a man, a very attractive man, undressing in the window of the apartment across from his. But just as quickly as the man appears, he disappears. When the man appears in the window again, in exactly the same clothes and a mirror of his previous movements, Jonah knows something odd is going on. With ghost enthusiast Liam’s help, they start to investigate the man in the window, which leads them to a fifty-year old unsolved disappearance.
Windows in Time is a phenomenal book and once I started reading I couldn’t put it down for even a minute. I was completely engrossed in the lives of the characters from the very first page and was constantly wondering what would happen next. The writing is smooth and easy to read, and I practically flew through the book. There is romance and mystery mixed together and the story is emotional and gripping from beginning to end.
As the title suggests, the story is based on windows in time, and it is based on two sets of characters separated by fifty years. Their stories of meeting and falling in love are interwoven together, with constant parallels between the couples and chapters alternating between 2007 and 1957. 2007 is the story of Jonah and Liam, while 1957 focuses on newspaper reporter Buck Addison in a time when being gay was decidedly not openly discussed. As a social reporter, Buck spent a lot of time with Hollywood stars, a group where a preference for the same-sex was more common and accepted.
When Buck sees a woman in a red dress he is slightly shocked at the intense attraction he feels for her, until he finds out that Minna is actually Oliver Caldwell. Buck’s attraction only intensifies and the two quickly become inseparable, although they have to be careful not to raise the suspicions of others who might deduce that Minna and Oliver are the same person. The two men are deeply in love until they disappear suddenly, and no one since has been able to solve the mystery of what happen to Buck, Oliver, or Minna. My favorite lines in the book are written by Buck as he reflects on his relationship with Oliver.
”Maybe, fifty years in the future, someone will care more about the fact that we were in love than the face that we are both men. Maybe someone will care that Oliver is a clever, intelligent, caring man and not that he likes to wear dresses on occasion.”
This story is very much inspired by Hitchcock's Rear Window, and reading it actually made me a bit anxious to watch the movie again. I first discovered Aedin through her short stories, and when I heard she was releasing a novel I was anxious to read it, hoping that the exceptional quality of the shorts would translate into a longer tale. In no way was I disappointed, and I’m happy to say that this stands up to, and even bypasses, the high quality of the shorter stories. I very highly recommend this story for anyone who enjoys romantic stories filled with well-developed characters and a beautifully engaging story. I am definitely looking forward to more from Aedin!
Jonah’s sentence of being trapped in his house gets quite a bit more exciting when he sees a man, a very attractive man, undressing in the window of the apartment across from his. But just as quickly as the man appears, he disappears. When the man appears in the window again, in exactly the same clothes and a mirror of his previous movements, Jonah knows something odd is going on. With ghost enthusiast Liam’s help, they start to investigate the man in the window, which leads them to a fifty-year old unsolved disappearance.
Windows in Time is a phenomenal book and once I started reading I couldn’t put it down for even a minute. I was completely engrossed in the lives of the characters from the very first page and was constantly wondering what would happen next. The writing is smooth and easy to read, and I practically flew through the book. There is romance and mystery mixed together and the story is emotional and gripping from beginning to end.
As the title suggests, the story is based on windows in time, and it is based on two sets of characters separated by fifty years. Their stories of meeting and falling in love are interwoven together, with constant parallels between the couples and chapters alternating between 2007 and 1957. 2007 is the story of Jonah and Liam, while 1957 focuses on newspaper reporter Buck Addison in a time when being gay was decidedly not openly discussed. As a social reporter, Buck spent a lot of time with Hollywood stars, a group where a preference for the same-sex was more common and accepted.
When Buck sees a woman in a red dress he is slightly shocked at the intense attraction he feels for her, until he finds out that Minna is actually Oliver Caldwell. Buck’s attraction only intensifies and the two quickly become inseparable, although they have to be careful not to raise the suspicions of others who might deduce that Minna and Oliver are the same person. The two men are deeply in love until they disappear suddenly, and no one since has been able to solve the mystery of what happen to Buck, Oliver, or Minna. My favorite lines in the book are written by Buck as he reflects on his relationship with Oliver.
”Maybe, fifty years in the future, someone will care more about the fact that we were in love than the face that we are both men. Maybe someone will care that Oliver is a clever, intelligent, caring man and not that he likes to wear dresses on occasion.”
This story is very much inspired by Hitchcock's Rear Window, and reading it actually made me a bit anxious to watch the movie again. I first discovered Aedin through her short stories, and when I heard she was releasing a novel I was anxious to read it, hoping that the exceptional quality of the shorts would translate into a longer tale. In no way was I disappointed, and I’m happy to say that this stands up to, and even bypasses, the high quality of the shorter stories. I very highly recommend this story for anyone who enjoys romantic stories filled with well-developed characters and a beautifully engaging story. I am definitely looking forward to more from Aedin!
August 26, 2014
I've been quite drawn to ghost stories and time-slip tales ever since I was quite young, but I haven't found very many gay-themed books in this vein. So, it was a given that I'd be intrigued by this story, and I have to say that for the most part I was quite pleased with the tale.
The bulk of the novel alternates between the stories of two pairs of men, with chapters set in the late 1950's interspersed with those set in the present day. (Only toward the end of the book does the focus shift entirely to what is happening in the present---though as the reader will see, what has happened in the past is still very much having an effect on the present.) As I was reading, I did slightly prefer the modern-day material, if only because ----and this isn't really a spoiler----I could easily guess that the period relationship would not end well. Because if it did, why would the time slip exist in the first place? And so I suppose I did enjoy seeing where the modern relationship would lead.
I enjoyed the book---couldn't put it down because I simply had to know how things turned out. I didn't really have any idea for certain how the vintage material would pan out until fairly near the end of the book, but it all came together very well.
Just a couple of tiny nit-picks---the 1950's material contains a reference concerning the on-screen chemistry of Rock Hudson and Doris Day (despite Hudson being gay---and yes, plenty of people in the business did know about him at the time). However, this part of the story took place two years BEFORE the first on-screen pairing of these two stars. Also, there's a plot point that seemed more than a little contrived, which of course served to wind things up neatly at the end. But----I did like the story, so I'm willing to overlook this.
Recommended if you're looking for a hint of the supernatural! I just wish I could find more gay lit in this vein. I liked the book well enough that I've just ordered another by the author ( Every Good Thing ). Boy, I'm having a terrible time sticking to a strict book-buying budget here---hmmm, maybe I won't start being frugal until the first of the new year. Heh.
The cover, though---well, it's a bit on the cheesy side I'd say, and not really accurate to the text. I'd chalk it up as being an example of the style of covers popular in the infancy of e-books---but unfortunately you'll still find covers in this vein that aren't as professionally-done as one may wish. Does get one's attention, though.
The bulk of the novel alternates between the stories of two pairs of men, with chapters set in the late 1950's interspersed with those set in the present day. (Only toward the end of the book does the focus shift entirely to what is happening in the present---though as the reader will see, what has happened in the past is still very much having an effect on the present.) As I was reading, I did slightly prefer the modern-day material, if only because ----and this isn't really a spoiler----I could easily guess that the period relationship would not end well. Because if it did, why would the time slip exist in the first place? And so I suppose I did enjoy seeing where the modern relationship would lead.
I enjoyed the book---couldn't put it down because I simply had to know how things turned out. I didn't really have any idea for certain how the vintage material would pan out until fairly near the end of the book, but it all came together very well.
Just a couple of tiny nit-picks---the 1950's material contains a reference concerning the on-screen chemistry of Rock Hudson and Doris Day (despite Hudson being gay---and yes, plenty of people in the business did know about him at the time). However, this part of the story took place two years BEFORE the first on-screen pairing of these two stars. Also, there's a plot point that seemed more than a little contrived, which of course served to wind things up neatly at the end. But----I did like the story, so I'm willing to overlook this.
Recommended if you're looking for a hint of the supernatural! I just wish I could find more gay lit in this vein. I liked the book well enough that I've just ordered another by the author ( Every Good Thing ). Boy, I'm having a terrible time sticking to a strict book-buying budget here---hmmm, maybe I won't start being frugal until the first of the new year. Heh.
The cover, though---well, it's a bit on the cheesy side I'd say, and not really accurate to the text. I'd chalk it up as being an example of the style of covers popular in the infancy of e-books---but unfortunately you'll still find covers in this vein that aren't as professionally-done as one may wish. Does get one's attention, though.
August 7, 2016
A lovely book; I really liked it a lot. Well, I LOVED some parts of it, and others - not so much.
I loved Buck and Oliver's story, I can't even describe how much. They both were such darling characters, and it was breathtakingly beautiful when they had their good times. I actually loved them so much that for a while I refused to think about
But all in all, I enjoyed it a lot. The cover, too - a really cool one.
I loved Buck and Oliver's story, I can't even describe how much. They both were such darling characters, and it was breathtakingly beautiful when they had their good times. I actually loved them so much that for a while I refused to think about
But all in all, I enjoyed it a lot. The cover, too - a really cool one.
April 28, 2010
After breaking his leg falling down the stairs, Jonah needs help so is sister arranges for a nurse she works with to help him out while she’s out of town. Nurse Liam turns out to be a hot younger guy. Meanwhile Jonah discovers a ghost in the window across from his apartment and the two of them go about figuring out who he is. The book then splits off with one chapter in present day with Liam and Jonah and one chapter about Buck and Oliver (the ghost and his lover). They are set 50 years ago, where Oliver, a cross dresser and Buck meet up (Oliver lived in Jonah’s apartment) and follows their relationship to their death while Jonah and Liam figure out the crime and work on their own relationship which is erratic at best.
So did I like it? I did. Did I love it? Umm. No. Why? I really have zero interest in historicals set in the “golden age of Hollywood”. The time period just doesn’t grab me and I really don’t get the whole crossdressing thing. I don’t find it hot. *shrug* Different strokes. So I found myself kind of zipping through those chapters to get back to Jonah and Liam. Also you know that Buck and Oliver end badly (otherwise they wouldn’t be ghosts) so it’s difficult to know there is no HEA for them, at least on this earthly plane. So I thought it was a very interesting mechanism, to do chapter by chapter in different time periods, the writing was well done, the characters likable but it just didn’t suck me in as much as some perhaps. Still, I think a worthy read and it’s well loved by many.
So did I like it? I did. Did I love it? Umm. No. Why? I really have zero interest in historicals set in the “golden age of Hollywood”. The time period just doesn’t grab me and I really don’t get the whole crossdressing thing. I don’t find it hot. *shrug* Different strokes. So I found myself kind of zipping through those chapters to get back to Jonah and Liam. Also you know that Buck and Oliver end badly (otherwise they wouldn’t be ghosts) so it’s difficult to know there is no HEA for them, at least on this earthly plane. So I thought it was a very interesting mechanism, to do chapter by chapter in different time periods, the writing was well done, the characters likable but it just didn’t suck me in as much as some perhaps. Still, I think a worthy read and it’s well loved by many.
August 8, 2012
A moving ghost story/mystery/love story told in simultaneously in 1957 and 2007. Jonah is laid up after two bad breaks-- one a long term relationship that has fallen apart and the other a broken leg after a nasty spill down a flight of stairs. He spots a sexy neighbor across the alley stripping for him, and he's intrigued. But the neighbor turns out to be nothing like he thinks. And then there's the sexy Liam, sent to help take care of him while his leg heals.
In the past, Buck Addison, famous Hollywood gossip columnist, meets Minna and Oliver, who share a dangerous secret. Buck loves both Minna and Oliver, but they all have enemies looking for a chance to hurt them.
In the present, Jonah and Liam stumble over a mystery. Buck Addison, his beautiful lover Minna, and friend Oliver all disappeared in 1957. Although there's been speculation over the years, no one ever knew what happened. Until Jonah starts seeing ghosts. What really happened to the lovers?
The story was absorbing. But there were a few problems. Several threads were picked up and dropped without going anywhere or having any impact on the story. And the romance between Jonah and Liam is a rather shaky HFN.
The outcome was pretty obvious from the start, so it was bittersweet watching Buck and Oliver fall in love. There was also hope that maybe things turned out differently than we thought. Buck and Oliver's love and the mystery of their disappearance were the heart of this story and what kept me reading to the end.
In the past, Buck Addison, famous Hollywood gossip columnist, meets Minna and Oliver, who share a dangerous secret. Buck loves both Minna and Oliver, but they all have enemies looking for a chance to hurt them.
In the present, Jonah and Liam stumble over a mystery. Buck Addison, his beautiful lover Minna, and friend Oliver all disappeared in 1957. Although there's been speculation over the years, no one ever knew what happened. Until Jonah starts seeing ghosts. What really happened to the lovers?
The story was absorbing. But there were a few problems. Several threads were picked up and dropped without going anywhere or having any impact on the story. And the romance between Jonah and Liam is a rather shaky HFN.
The outcome was pretty obvious from the start, so it was bittersweet watching Buck and Oliver fall in love. There was also hope that maybe things turned out differently than we thought. Buck and Oliver's love and the mystery of their disappearance were the heart of this story and what kept me reading to the end.
March 5, 2015
No sé muy bien que decir sobre este libro. Me ha gustado mucho y al mismo tiempo no ha terminado de convencerme.
Para empezar yo esperaba una historia, la de la pareja principal investigando al fantasma; no esperaba dos historias mezcladas y, sobre todo, no esperaba que la mayor parte del libro fuese "la otra historia". Esto no me gustó demasiado, sobre todo sabiendo como iba a terminar (poco misterio, si se ve a su fantasma obviamente murieron) No me gustan los dramas, soy demasiado sensible :P por eso no me gustó conocer a los personajes y encariñarme de ellos (y hubiera sido imposible no encariñarse) sabiendo que no iban a tener un final feliz .
Después está la otra historia, que fue la que me llamó la atención realmente y lo que yo pensaba que iba a leer. Se queda corta, no hay mucho que decir de ella porque se la "come" la otra. Los personajes no están desarrollados del todo y esto provoca que la relación que mantienen sea extraña y tensa, sin ningún motivo aparente. Parece que tienen los sentimientos a flor de piel, se ofenden con facilidad, se echan atrás y se asustan con facilidad y se les pasa todo con la misma facilidad (esto está bien, porque tampoco es que les pase nada para que reaccionen como lo hacen en primer lugar).
Y esos son mis problemas:
La historia de los fantasmas, muy bonita, pero sin final feliz.
La historia de los personajes principales, con final feliz y no es que no sea bonita, pero está poco desarrollada y se queda corta.
Para empezar yo esperaba una historia, la de la pareja principal investigando al fantasma; no esperaba dos historias mezcladas y, sobre todo, no esperaba que la mayor parte del libro fuese "la otra historia". Esto no me gustó demasiado, sobre todo sabiendo como iba a terminar (poco misterio, si se ve a su fantasma obviamente murieron) No me gustan los dramas, soy demasiado sensible :P por eso no me gustó conocer a los personajes y encariñarme de ellos (y hubiera sido imposible no encariñarse) sabiendo que no iban a tener un final feliz .
Después está la otra historia, que fue la que me llamó la atención realmente y lo que yo pensaba que iba a leer. Se queda corta, no hay mucho que decir de ella porque se la "come" la otra. Los personajes no están desarrollados del todo y esto provoca que la relación que mantienen sea extraña y tensa, sin ningún motivo aparente. Parece que tienen los sentimientos a flor de piel, se ofenden con facilidad, se echan atrás y se asustan con facilidad y se les pasa todo con la misma facilidad (esto está bien, porque tampoco es que les pase nada para que reaccionen como lo hacen en primer lugar).
Y esos son mis problemas:
La historia de los fantasmas, muy bonita, pero sin final feliz.
La historia de los personajes principales, con final feliz y no es que no sea bonita, pero está poco desarrollada y se queda corta.
August 11, 2011
O.M.G.
Don't mean to sound so dramatic, but that is exactly how I felt after I finished this crazy, amazing book. I was reluctant to pick it up because of the paranormal factor (ghosts), but thank goodness I have read a book by this author before, so I trusted her name enough to try this book out. Soooo glad I did!!!! It is officially one of my favorite books even though, as I was reading, I wished that the author had just written 2 different books since both story lines were soooo good.
There were 2 separate stories here: the present day Jonah and Liam and the cold case mystery they got caught up in: the tragic story of Buck and Oliver/Minna. I would get caught up in the story of Jonah and his blossoming romance with Liam, and then get jolted out of the story in the next chapter to Buck and Oliver's story. I would then be totally engrossed in their story and then the next chapter would be back to Jonah and Liam. It was back and forth like this the whole way and while that may sound disconcerting, it totally rocked. I knew this book was a winner when I was totally shocked by what ended up happening. And then the epilogue made me cry like a baby. It was great! Everyone, read this book!!
Don't mean to sound so dramatic, but that is exactly how I felt after I finished this crazy, amazing book. I was reluctant to pick it up because of the paranormal factor (ghosts), but thank goodness I have read a book by this author before, so I trusted her name enough to try this book out. Soooo glad I did!!!! It is officially one of my favorite books even though, as I was reading, I wished that the author had just written 2 different books since both story lines were soooo good.
There were 2 separate stories here: the present day Jonah and Liam and the cold case mystery they got caught up in: the tragic story of Buck and Oliver/Minna. I would get caught up in the story of Jonah and his blossoming romance with Liam, and then get jolted out of the story in the next chapter to Buck and Oliver's story. I would then be totally engrossed in their story and then the next chapter would be back to Jonah and Liam. It was back and forth like this the whole way and while that may sound disconcerting, it totally rocked. I knew this book was a winner when I was totally shocked by what ended up happening. And then the epilogue made me cry like a baby. It was great! Everyone, read this book!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews