I liked this installment of the Mrs. Murphy mystery series, but I did not love it as I have the others in the series. What was the difference?
Well, I noted in one of my status updates that this one seemed a bit preachy. The preaching didn't stop. I'd be reading along, submersed in activities of the characters, then suddenly one would make a statement about the state of the world or how we should do such and such to save energy or comment on the state of the economy, etc. When these situations arose, the action and dialogue went from smooth to stilted and choppy.
It is understandable that an author would want to convey their thoughts and ideas about a topic through their work. It is a perfect place to do it. However, it must be handled more subtly than was accomplished here. The diatribes became so annoying I had no desire to read the notes from the author about why she chose the setting she did. I skipped it went right to Sneaky Pie's notes.
Also strange was the scene where Mrs. Murphy told the Exodus story (from Passover to the Red Sea)to the barn crew. Okay, the story took place in the changing seasons from winter to spring over Easter (and Easter or Resurrection Day is one of my favorite holidays), but this was really out of character for a cat to be teaching an Easter lesson.
On thing Mrs. Murphy said did strike a chord with me...Tally and Inez were discussing why people have to be so nasty to each other and not get along as the animals do...Mrs. Murphy notes that animal minds are not filled with ideologies. That being said, this installment was filled with ideologies.
On the upside, I LOVED Tally, Inez, Doodles, and Erno. They are welcome additions to the usual cast of characters in Crozet, VA.
Harry, as always, is strong, caring, curious, and generous. Fair...I am sooooo happy they got back together...is wonderful. His buying Harry a shiny, silver Volvo station wagon made me laugh a bit. [Note: this book was released April 6, 2010.] Cooper was supportive. After that the rest of the regular characters were in the background, some really far in the background.
Mrs. Murphy, Pewter, Tea Tucker, Doodles, Erno, Simon, Flatface, et al were wonderful. I love how they interact with each other fully aware that their humans don't really understand them as they'd like. I also love how the human characters react to these little interactions.
Looking forward to reading another in the future. The best part of these novels is that there is a cast of characters in the beginning, so that if you (like I) read them out of order, you know who is who and what is what.
The premise itself was quite interesting. As I graduated from a small college, the idea of celebrating an alumna's or alumnus' 100th birthday as a fundraiser is quite plausible. Not sure how many would be as active and vociferous as Tally (loved her speech, so right on top of things) he or she would be. The unrest on the alumni board is also quite plausible.