There are not many books on college ministry so, as a college pastor, I was very excited to read this one when I saw it.
The first chapter reveals why college ministry is so important. He shows that one of the biggest problems in the church is a loss of young people and that what churches are doing to stop this is not working. Then he argues that college students are not yet adults nor are they children. For these reasons it is essential for churches to focus ministry specifically on this age group. This ministry is not simply another service for students, rather it must be rooted in relationships.
The second part of the book deals with who college students are. There are chapters on identity (chs. 2-3), the search for meaning and purpose (ch. 4), intimacy (ch. 5), social life (ch. 6) and truth (ch. 7). This section provides information that is right on the mark and was the strength of the book.
The third section focuses on practical issues: leadership (ch. 8), teaching and discipleship (ch. 9), the gathering (ch. 10), volunteers (ch. 11), and assimilation (ch. 12). This section was also strong and I found myself noticing things I already do and things I should do, for which I am grateful.
The book ends with a number of appendices on various topics. Bomar writes from the perspective of someone who works for a church as a college minister. But that is only one way that college ministry is done. He ignores campus-based ministries (such as Intervarsity, Campus Crusade for Christ, and others) even though probably more ministry to college students happens through these than in churches. It also leaves one huge question unanswered. Bomar's main point is that college ministry must assimilate people into the church by picking up students as they leave the youth group and move them towards being in the church as adults. But he writes this from the standpoint of all these movements being in the same local church. What about students who leave the area for college? When he does mention such students (appendix c) he seems to assume they will come back after college, so the assimilation goal is still the same local church. What about the many students who move away to college and then move somewhere else afterwards? This is why campus-based ministries are so important. He does say some positive things about campus based ministries (appendix B). But he also states (in appendix e) that campus ministries do "virtually nothing" to assimilate students back into congregations. Again, he is assuming the students from the church who get involved in these ministries are returning to the same town (and thus church) after graduation). In my experience, campus-based ministries help prepare students for service in the church upon graduation, whether it be a return to their home church or a church in a new town (though, to be fair, I am pretty sure Bomar would agree...he is speaking more about an ideal situation I think).
So overall this is a good book that I would recommend to those who work with college aged students. Bomar's insights into the mind of college students and how to minister to them ring true. Yet his complete focus on church-based college ministry and the absence of campus-based college ministry, along with missions, makes the book uneven in the end. I should note that what he says about church-based and campus-based ministries working together, where both exist in college towns, is true. But again, his failure to illustrate the positives and importance of campus based ministry is sorely missed.
*After a comment from the author and re-reading the review, I realize it comes off a bit harsh and I have amended the review. I feel I broke a rule of book reviewing - taking issues for things the author never intended to say. The book's target is church-based college ministry and while I wish there was more time on campus-based ministry, I can't fault an author for not talking about what I want! Perhaps I need to re-read the introduction; I don't remember this target being made explicit, which is why the absence struck me, but perhaps I missed it. At any rate, I just want to re-affirm that this book is great and really helpful, especially for church-based ministers but even for campus-based ministers. The difference is, we might have to think a little harder to apply it to our context.