3.5 stars, rounded up to 4 stars because I was never bored.
I am not going to lie, I bought this book for the following reasons: the beautiful cover art, the would-be-author protagonist, and it was a super-cheap Daily Deal; otherwise, I never would have chosen this book on my own. Did Booked for Murder exceed my expectations? Absolutely!
I normally don't have good luck with cozy mysteries, They are often too long and too dull to hold my interest, Booked for Murder, on the other hand, zips along at a quick speed. The book is full of charm from cover-to-cover and often made me laugh and smile. It is also the perfect length. It does not overstay its welcome, and there is an art to that. I also got a good feel for the San Fransisco setting,
So if I enjoyed Booked for Murder so much, then why a 4 star rating instead of a 5? There are several reasons why this book fell short of becoming a new favorite. One, I did not really connect with any of the characters, There was no depth to them. They felt more caricature than human, but I think that is often true of the cozy mystery subgenre, which is why I have a hard time falling in love with cozy mysteries Two, it was, as others said, a bit far-fetched. No one asks to see Ophelia's credentials, and people are totally willing to talk to the prime suspect in a murder without any sort of reservations? Come on, now! Also, some of the methods for gathering evidence would not hold up in court, even in California. Three, not enough bread crumbs were sprinkled our before revealing the killer except towards the end, so the reveal is hardly satisfying.
One note of caution: there is a lot of social commentary throughout the novel. I do appreciate that the author takes the time to at least criticize fake activists or activists with misguided methods, but she is otherwise firmly taking shots at Elon Musk, crony capitalism, the patriarchy, bro culture, etc. I am here for it, because she is speaking my language, but her views might turn off more conservative-leaning readers.
Overall, I enjoyed my time with Booked for Murder, but I doubt that I will ever feel the need to go on Poppy Perkins' next adventure.