What do you think?
Rate this book
A Song in the Dark: The Birth of the Musical Film
Drawing on meticulous research, sharp wit, and insightful analysis, Richard Barrios illuminates the origins of the movie musical in this extensively revised and updated edition of his highly acclaimed A Song in the Dark . From Warner Bros. and Jolson, to the Oscar-winning Broadway Melody and beyond, here is the whole funny and peculiar history of these films, their creators, and their audiences. Ranging from the smash hits of The Singing Fool and Sunny Side Up to bizarre flops like Golden Dawn and Cecil B. DeMille's Madam Satan , they form a body of work unlike anything else in the history of popular entertainment. Here too are legendary performers, directors, and from Fannie Brice, James Cagney, and Mae West, to Busby Berkeley, George and Ira Gershwin, Richard Rodgers, Oscar Hammerstein, and countless others. With many new rare photographs, some not published in nearly 80 years, this new edition traces the rise and fall, and rise again, of this quintessential piece of
the American experience.
the American experience.
496 pages, Paperback
First published July 13, 1995
4 people are currently reading
133 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
November 18, 2013
Richard Barrios' most meticulously researched and readable book
is a perfect companion to "The First Hollywood Musicals" in what
is, to me, the most fascinating era in movies. Who would have
imagined that in the same year (1928) as Harold Lloyd's "Speedy"
and Lillian Gish's "The Wind", a tin pot film with mediocre
stars and amateurish direction would pave the way for the death
of silent films. The movie was "Lights of New York", the first
all talking feature film, the dialogue was laughable but it
combined two plots that were to become important in those early
talkie days - the underworld and back stage life.
Although Warners was first on the scene with "The Jazz Singer"
and "Lights of New York", in Barrios' opinion the studio continued
to fumble it's baton and didn't really gauge what the public
wanted until it was too late. They made "The Desert Song" but
shelved it for 5 months and by the time it was released other
studios had gone ahead by leaps and bounds and Warner's film
looked static and staged compared to MGM's "The Broadway Melody"
which had queues around the block.
Barrios delves into every film that carried a song or two in those
early years (which was almost every other film). The dreaded theme
song - "Woman Disputed, I Love You" from "Woman Disputed" to
"Dynamite Blow My Sweetie Back to Me" from "Dynamite" (I am not
joking)!!! He also had me on his side by his obvious admiration
of Nancy Carroll, an actress who was "Queen of the Screen" in 1930
but within a couple of years was being woefully mismanaged by
Paramount. She was just a terrific actress who was equally at home
in musicals ("Honey") and dramas ("Stolen Heaven"), should have
won an Academy Award for "The Devil's Holiday" and should have had
a long, steady career. Maybe it was her beauty (as well as her
temper) that stood in her way. Barrios describes her best as a
"sexy valentine for the waning Jazz Age".
Even though there were things I don't agree with - his inexplicable
liking for "On With the Show" and his questioning of just how Alice
White became a star, his book is compelling to read. I always
maintain Alice White gave it all she had. By dying her hair blonde
she became an instant Jazz baby in films like "Hot Stuff", "Naughty
Baby" and "Broadway Babies". No, she couldn't sing, her dancing
was strictly amateur night stuff but considering she didn't have
a showbiz background (she was Josef von Sternberg's secretary) I
thought she did pretty good. With her cute looks and big eyes who
cared if her acting wasn't up to scratch - she also kept the
fan magazines intrigued with a series of sex scandals!!
There is also the downside. Barrios tells of a fire at Pathe's New
York studio in December 1929 - 10 dead, 18 injured. It was found
to be a fire trap and Pathe executives were blamed. The fire
department looked carefully at a lot of the studios operating in
the New York area and found that in the eagerness to supply the
public with musicals (especially shorts) corners and safety measures
were being cut.
Instead of finishing at the dawn of a new musical era "42nd Street",
Barrios does a post-mortem and closes at 1935 and shows how the
other studios regrouped. Fox found it's forte in bright and breezy
musicals and struck gold with Shirley Temple, RKO were set for the
decade with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, even lowly Columbia
went highbrow with Grace Moore and Warners, after the grittiness
of "42nd Street" and "Footlight Parade" promoted Ruby Keeler and
Dick Powell to musicals were the depression was just an idle rumour.
Me, I still love Winnie Lightner singing "Pingo Pongo".
is a perfect companion to "The First Hollywood Musicals" in what
is, to me, the most fascinating era in movies. Who would have
imagined that in the same year (1928) as Harold Lloyd's "Speedy"
and Lillian Gish's "The Wind", a tin pot film with mediocre
stars and amateurish direction would pave the way for the death
of silent films. The movie was "Lights of New York", the first
all talking feature film, the dialogue was laughable but it
combined two plots that were to become important in those early
talkie days - the underworld and back stage life.
Although Warners was first on the scene with "The Jazz Singer"
and "Lights of New York", in Barrios' opinion the studio continued
to fumble it's baton and didn't really gauge what the public
wanted until it was too late. They made "The Desert Song" but
shelved it for 5 months and by the time it was released other
studios had gone ahead by leaps and bounds and Warner's film
looked static and staged compared to MGM's "The Broadway Melody"
which had queues around the block.
Barrios delves into every film that carried a song or two in those
early years (which was almost every other film). The dreaded theme
song - "Woman Disputed, I Love You" from "Woman Disputed" to
"Dynamite Blow My Sweetie Back to Me" from "Dynamite" (I am not
joking)!!! He also had me on his side by his obvious admiration
of Nancy Carroll, an actress who was "Queen of the Screen" in 1930
but within a couple of years was being woefully mismanaged by
Paramount. She was just a terrific actress who was equally at home
in musicals ("Honey") and dramas ("Stolen Heaven"), should have
won an Academy Award for "The Devil's Holiday" and should have had
a long, steady career. Maybe it was her beauty (as well as her
temper) that stood in her way. Barrios describes her best as a
"sexy valentine for the waning Jazz Age".
Even though there were things I don't agree with - his inexplicable
liking for "On With the Show" and his questioning of just how Alice
White became a star, his book is compelling to read. I always
maintain Alice White gave it all she had. By dying her hair blonde
she became an instant Jazz baby in films like "Hot Stuff", "Naughty
Baby" and "Broadway Babies". No, she couldn't sing, her dancing
was strictly amateur night stuff but considering she didn't have
a showbiz background (she was Josef von Sternberg's secretary) I
thought she did pretty good. With her cute looks and big eyes who
cared if her acting wasn't up to scratch - she also kept the
fan magazines intrigued with a series of sex scandals!!
There is also the downside. Barrios tells of a fire at Pathe's New
York studio in December 1929 - 10 dead, 18 injured. It was found
to be a fire trap and Pathe executives were blamed. The fire
department looked carefully at a lot of the studios operating in
the New York area and found that in the eagerness to supply the
public with musicals (especially shorts) corners and safety measures
were being cut.
Instead of finishing at the dawn of a new musical era "42nd Street",
Barrios does a post-mortem and closes at 1935 and shows how the
other studios regrouped. Fox found it's forte in bright and breezy
musicals and struck gold with Shirley Temple, RKO were set for the
decade with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, even lowly Columbia
went highbrow with Grace Moore and Warners, after the grittiness
of "42nd Street" and "Footlight Parade" promoted Ruby Keeler and
Dick Powell to musicals were the depression was just an idle rumour.
Me, I still love Winnie Lightner singing "Pingo Pongo".
August 26, 2021
This is an academic book that analyzes musical film from 1926 to 1934. It is interesting, thorough but slow reading. (It took me a month to read the book, and I stayed with it diligently.) Barrios writes well, but his subject matter is esoteric. Having said all that, the book is full of interesting stuff, fascinating anecdotes of people, cultural trends, technological issues that have disappeared into the mists of time. Barrios argues that all this virtually forgotten historical detail is important. I'm not so sure, but it is interesting.
July 22, 2018
A good read focusing on a little-examined period of Hollywood history: the rise of the musical film in the earliest days of the talkies, followed by its near-extinction. Lots and lots of detail, a readable style, and welcome touches of humor.
March 30, 2023
I have read the second edition of "A Song in the Dark: the Birth of the Musical Film", and enjoyed it a great deal. Offhand I believe I would try to find the second edition as there are updates within, chiefly, I believe, at the book's end which deals with the last great wave of musical films of the late 1960s-early 1970s (the road show era).
Mr. Barrios' book is an essential one as it deals with films that, for the most part, most of his readers may have never seen. Perhaps to avoid an academic tone on occasion the writer adds editorializing to the book which can be both amusing and somewhat irritating but I would admit that at times the editorializing is understandable. Ultimately if readers wish to track down specific films described here they can find them (often) on Turner Classic Movies or You Tube so they can judge for themselves.
Given the size and content of this book I wish it were available as a downloadable one, but to my knowledge it is not.
As there is no equivalent book about this motion picture making era that I am aware of, "A Song in the Dark: the Birth of the Musical Film" is essential reading.
Mr. Barrios' book is an essential one as it deals with films that, for the most part, most of his readers may have never seen. Perhaps to avoid an academic tone on occasion the writer adds editorializing to the book which can be both amusing and somewhat irritating but I would admit that at times the editorializing is understandable. Ultimately if readers wish to track down specific films described here they can find them (often) on Turner Classic Movies or You Tube so they can judge for themselves.
Given the size and content of this book I wish it were available as a downloadable one, but to my knowledge it is not.
As there is no equivalent book about this motion picture making era that I am aware of, "A Song in the Dark: the Birth of the Musical Film" is essential reading.
March 9, 2009
A great summary of how musicals took the screen by storm. Barrios is an entertaining writer and keeps the content fresh, but after a while, your head will start aching at all of the names of unknown films and actors until you can't keep them straight.
I was glad to add a couple of early musicals on my Netflix list and was also saddened to learn about how many of these pieces of early film heritage, although not that old, are lost.
I was glad to add a couple of early musicals on my Netflix list and was also saddened to learn about how many of these pieces of early film heritage, although not that old, are lost.
July 15, 2007
This is my favorite non-fiction book. I love film musicals and older films. This combines both- it's all about early film musicals. Barrios is frequently witty and wise, and his footnotes are fantastic!
Reading this book makes you want to see each film he describes. It's definitely a keeper, and one that I keep going back to for fun and reference.
Reading this book makes you want to see each film he describes. It's definitely a keeper, and one that I keep going back to for fun and reference.
July 15, 2013
A Song in the Dark is an essential guide for anyone with a keen interest in film history and musicals. There is a lot of information here and I feel like it was delivered effectively. The author is very opinionated and that takes some getting used to. Read my full review here: http://www.outofthepastblog.com/2013/...
Currently reading
February 17, 2011Probably one of the most thoroughly researched books on early film musicals I've ever seen.
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews