When I picked this book up, I knew it was going to be different. Both good different, and bad different. And I was right.
I wanted to read this because of its popularity. This was written in 1888, and people actually learned Hindi to read this novel. That's amazing, right?
So,
Does the novel age well?
No. There is sexism, there is religionism, and there are stereotypes. But funnily enough, it's still better than current news TV channels. So that's a win?
Do I regret reading it?
No, not at all. I am glad I finally read (actually listened to) it. It was very interesting to see how people talked and perceived things at that time, and how so much of that is same as today.
What I liked:
1) I liked how the language is very similar to the current one. Of course, there are more Urdu words used in the dialogues than today's real life, and some words, even some easy ones seem to be just lost today, which is kinda sad. I pride myself on my Hindi and still, I heard them for the first time in it.
2) I like how it has many brave, fighter (literal fighters) female characters. While the novel does have enough sexism to make you cringe, not all women are portrayed as helpless people, which I really liked.
3) I listened to it on Storytel, the audio version by K.C. Shankar. And I have to say it was such a treat to listen to a voice that reminded me of our childhood shows. If I find more books in this narrator's voice, I am going to listen to those too. The narration was a very strong part of my experience with this book.
What I didn't like:
1) As I said, the novel does not age well on many parts. Despite some very brave women characters, the frequent usage of degrading words for women like "laundi", and a few uncomfortable scenes are there.
2) The story does not seem epic or anything to me, now, as it is often claimed about this book. But then we have to remember that it was written in 1888. A time when the authors probably didn't have access to much fiction to improve their writing. The writing clearly had potential. It is not just another novel, and I am sure in 1888, it must have been an epic story. The tilism is quite interesting, I can totally see why this was adapted into TV series.
I don't remember much about its TV show other than the fact that I liked it as a child. But I have heard lots of things were changed in the adaptation. If you read the book, you will know the reasons yourself. In the book, prince Virendra Singh often comes across as a weak, love-struck boy, and his best friend and 'Ayyar' Tej Singh is the one who actually saves the day most of the time.
All said and done, I am glad I read it. It helped me understand the culture of that time, and the fiction of that time.