In this rich collection of philosophical writings, Stanley Rosen addresses a wide range of topics―from eros, poetry, and freedom to problems like negation and the epistemological status of sense perception. Though diverse in subject, Rosen’s essays share two unifying there can be no legitimate separation of textual hermeneutics from philosophical analysis, and philosophical investigation must be oriented in terms of everyday language and experience, although it cannot simply remain within these confines. Ordinary experience provides a minimal criterion for the assessment of extraordinary discourses, Rosen argues, and without such a criterion we would have no basis for evaluating conflicting philosophy would give way to poetry.
Philosophical problems are not so deeply embedded in a specific historical context that they cannot be restated in terms as valid for us today as they were for those who formulated them, the author maintains. Rosen shows that the history of philosophy―a story of conflicting interpretations of human life and the structure of intelligibility―is a story that comes to life only when it is rethought in terms of the philosophical problems of our own personal and historical situation.
Stanley Rosen was Borden Parker Bowne Professor of Philosophy and Professor Emeritus at Boston University. His research and teaching focused on the fundamental questions of philosophy and on the most important figures of its history, from Plato to Heidegger.
Short and blunt: Metaphysics in Ordinary Language is a great idea buried under too many pages. What worked: the central argument is fresh and the first few chapters crackle. What didn't: it keeps circling back to the same three examples. Recommend for curious readers who don't mind skimming, skip for anyone who wants every chapter to earn its spot.
Metaphysics in Ordinary Language proves Rosen, Stanley isn't afraid to challenge the sacred cows of modern culture, showing how they often serve as shields for authority.