Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Pie Promises

Rate this book
I’m spending Thanksgiving with my friend and her three husbands. THREE! Shake My Damn Head!!

The woman is either certifiable, or a saint. Personally, I don’t have the time, energy or patience to deal with one man, let alone several. I love my single life, and I’ve never met a D or a relationship that made me trust long-term commitments.

But when not one but three retired Navy Seals set their sights on me, all bets are off!

Chase McCoy, Asher Grant, and Luca Santoro are tall, broad, deliciously masculine, and they won’t quit till they make me theirs!

This is a steamy, RH romance between three possessive alphas and an independent woman once bitten by love. But miracles are known to happen during this time of year, right?

Tag along to read all about how our three hunks will seduce their woman. Because all is fair in love and wars of the heart ;-)

This is a safe read, with no cheating, no cliffhanger, and HEA, swoony and sexy times guaranteed. Enjoy!!

The small college town of Hopeton is gaining attention for its number of menage and poly relationships. A flurry of businesses hosting and celebrating alternative weddings is growing. As the town enjoys pies from the new Thankful Cafe for Thanksgiving, many singles discover that they, too, are finding happiness with two or more partners… Welcome to Hopeton!

77 pages, Kindle Edition

Published December 16, 2022

112 people are currently reading
65 people want to read

About the author

Imani Jay

170 books473 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
139 (40%)
4 stars
105 (30%)
3 stars
65 (19%)
2 stars
29 (8%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews
Profile Image for DeeReads.
2,284 reviews
January 8, 2023
This story had potential but the ending was so abrupt....
Profile Image for LaTosha Webber.
1,166 reviews71 followers
December 30, 2022
rough but

This really needs to be cleaned up, there are a annoying amount of typos. It was the visual of the guys they kept me going and that it’s a quick read
Profile Image for Ciru.
1,724 reviews
December 19, 2022
I get that it is meant to be a serial release but it felt like 3 main scenes, then filler in between. The initial meeting/lift scene, the coffee shop scene, the date/sit down conversation scene. Hyping up the interactions between the 4, but I just wasn't feeling it.

The start felt more organic. The guys and their inner rambling thoughts, brisk macho man Navy movements just wasn't cutting it.
Profile Image for BookKraves.
491 reviews100 followers
February 15, 2023
I'm feeling it

I want more. Ms. Imani Jay us one hell of a spicy read, but I wanted more bantering, and I wanted to get to know the characters more. The story was cut short.
Profile Image for IRLover.
166 reviews17 followers
January 22, 2023
How do I get to Hopeton🥰🥰🥰

I swear Ms Imani Jay never disappoints with her quick, short and steamy romances. This reverse harem story is super hot and have me looking for a town like Hopeton🥵

Yasin’s Thanksgiving wknd turned out way better than expected all thanks to her friend still on her honeymoon high and having to postpone her BFF time for a few hours. Luca, Asher and Chase didn’t waste anytime, when they saw her they knew she would be theirs😊. Although the men exuded BDE Yasin was able to match their once she made up her mind on what was to come of their night together and boy was it freaking sexy, hot and kinky😈🥵🔥. There was no way Yasin would be able to walk away from these men, they wouldn’t allow it and made sure she knew it🥰
Profile Image for RomanceIsMyJam.
516 reviews
April 14, 2023
First of the cover pic is kinda weirdly hilarious for some reason.
Alright I DNF’d this story. I got bored. My attention was grabbed when Yasmin bolted away from these guys. I was into where this may be going. Well it was resolved in fifteen minutes (their time) and then the boredom set in for me. Lots of internal dialogue from each character stating same things over and over. I couldn’t keep reading it, very tedious.
Sidenote - Elizabeth was a shizzy hostess. Come on girl keep things respectful and PG/more discrete when you have a guest you invited. Rude.
Elizabeth and her dude bros are from Three Santa’s and I. Yasmin used to work with this group. Yasmin is briefly in Elizabeth’s story.
Profile Image for T Nelson.
1,879 reviews28 followers
April 6, 2023
HEA
Standalone, interconnected characters
*over 18 readers only *

RH, veterans, insta-love

Trigger warnings
MFMM

She gets in the elevator with them, almost overcome by their hotness, only for the elevator to stop working right before her exit.
After some hot kisses, she flees as soon as the elevator doors open. They track her down and convince her to go home with them after stopping at her friend's house. What follows is the single hottest experience of her life. But how will they get her to stay?

There are a few typos. I liked this one better than Ellie's story.
Profile Image for BooksChaosandTea.
147 reviews4 followers
December 21, 2022
Sooooo.....

I really enjoyed the second ending. It was weird the story abruptly ended. I rated the book, then closed out of it. When I reopened it, it was no longer at the end of the book. It was now in the middle. The story continued and had a complete ending. I think this is an Amazon issue and not the fault of the author. I gave the story a better rating due to the more complete ending. I hope Amazon fixes this issue.
Profile Image for Katherine Dougherty.
204 reviews9 followers
December 30, 2025
Love at Thanksgiving

This was short but steamy love story. Yasin never thought she would find that all consuming love until she visits her best friend for thanksgiving. While at the mall she meets three incredible men who change her life forever. They cherish and protect their girl. Luca, Asher and Chase knew she was the one to complete their family and keeping her is their only option.
786 reviews3 followers
December 22, 2022
Thanksgiving

Basin met Luca, Asher and Chase in an elevator that was stuck in the mall! She was instantly drawn to the trio, not realizing how her life was about to change for the better! The three men took care of her needs and refused to let her leave. She was in heaven in more ways then one..
Profile Image for Robin.
2,531 reviews20 followers
December 28, 2022
Thanksgiving Romance

Talk about hot and steamy! Yasin and her men met and became more very quickly. They just clicked and had that instant connection. I love that their relationship happened in a place that is very accepting of non-traditional relationships. Short and sweet and very steamy!
Profile Image for Antoinette Jones.
930 reviews7 followers
February 7, 2023
Three men and their Lady!!

Wow! Yasin tried hard to deny her feelings for Chase, Asher and Luca. But those ex Navy Seals weren't having it! They pulled out all the stops to make her theirs. And wow was it 🔥🔥🔥. RH romances aren't my thing. But I do know a good book when I read one. And Imani Jay delivered! I highly recommend this book. Alright Ms Jay you are boss!!
27 reviews
February 19, 2023
I loved this story

I corpus this book down. I loved this story. Working in the corporate world myself I know how hard it is to surrender to a man or men in thus case. I love the way her men should her how cherished she could be and how to let go of control to find a meaningful live. Thank you for this journey.
Profile Image for Kassie.
1,377 reviews4 followers
March 11, 2024
Story 1.5⭐️ Why do I keep trying to read this author and hope that things will magically get better?!?! The typos are so hard to get through and there is little to no plot or character development and the ending just slaps you in the face with how abruptly it comes about. No thank you, I have learned my lesson. Never again.
357 reviews1 follower
December 6, 2024
Yasin was well loved

I do love a good reverse harem. it was so sexy. it started with Yasin looking at her friend and judging her relationship with her three husbands until she fell into the arms of three strangers. three strangers that immediately fell in love with her and was planning to make her theirs. and they did just that.

Profile Image for Insomniac Reviews.
181 reviews1 follower
February 7, 2025
globes. lots of globes

Aside from the massive amount of typos and the author’s inability to flesh out characters and the actual plot, the story itself was kind of cute. A quick read so I don’t feel like I wasted a bunch of my time but I forced myself to see it through. The amount of times FMC’s bum and boobs were referred to as “globes” drove me nuts
77 reviews1 follower
April 26, 2025
Nice short story but ..

This was a nice simple sexy short story. I really hate how the last half of this book has a billion confusing typos and just plain ol' wrong words that made no sense. It was as if the writer or editor waited til the last minute to finish his or her book report that was due in ten minutes.
Profile Image for Victoria Seale.
44 reviews2 followers
November 19, 2025
This book really had nothing to do with Thanksgiving, other than the fact that it took place over the Thanksgiving holiday.
I was annoyed that the book was 65pgs but NOTHING (sexy) happened till pg 40, which was already 59% of the way through the book. I also hated the way the book ended. Twice. Both the story and the epilogue. Only the smut made this book 2⭐️’s
Profile Image for Shawn Pinzon.
883 reviews6 followers
December 21, 2022
Holiday Romance

Yasin came to Hopeton to visit her best friend. She meets Asher, Luca and Chase in the elevator at the mall. And that's when things get spicy. I loved the story!! If your looking for a quick steamy read this is it.
Profile Image for Ty.
363 reviews1 follower
December 24, 2022
Good read 📚

Good short straight to the point read. I have a love ❤️ hate relationship with short stories. The end to soon but you don't have to wait to long to see how the book ends. So I'll read 📚 more but love hate the short books 📚 🙃
1,063 reviews2 followers
January 1, 2023
Accepting Love

This reverse harem book has fantastic characters who are loving and caring. I liked that the men are tender giants who are open and honest with the people they love. These alphas are a fun group to read about, enjoy.
Profile Image for Michelle Frater.
1,699 reviews18 followers
May 14, 2023
Do I like ménage? Oh yeah! What’s better than being worshipped by one hot hunk? How about two, or in this case three. I loved how Imani gave each of the three guys a different persona, which made them stand out individually. Their meet cute was adorable and the steam just picks up from there. Yes, its OTT, yes, it’s pure fantasy, but what a way to go!
79 reviews
October 1, 2023
To short

I now understand the mixed reviews because it was so great and had so much potential but its an hour read tops. It’s like a prequel or snippet that’s how short it is. I liked it don’t get me wrong but had a paid attention to the length I wouldn’t have read it.
130 reviews
November 20, 2023
Different Can Be Good

A quick spicy read embracing an unconventional way of life and love. Relationships don’t always have to fit in the box. I recommend this novella. It may open a door to greater possibilities!
Profile Image for ChristiLovesBooks_smut.
1,795 reviews43 followers
December 17, 2023
Good!

Theirs, by Imani Jay @uthor.amani.jay. I've enjoyed Imani’s books in the past & this book was no different. It was a short instalove book. Ash, Chase & Luca take one look at Yasim & fall hard.
Profile Image for AJ_1234.
277 reviews
December 12, 2025
I am not the biggest fan of instalove and this has not changed that BUT in defense of this novella, I finished it and just wanted more background and development of the characters and this magical poly-land of Hopeton.
Profile Image for Victoria Ziglor-smith.
777 reviews5 followers
December 22, 2022
Short & Sexy

This is a hot wet dream in a story, gets you excited page after page. It’s good but sexy dirty thriller.
1,124 reviews3 followers
December 24, 2022
Just what I needed

Loved this book. Imani slayed with the smexy! I always love her take on #whychoose books!

Giluys were bomb, semxy scenes were fire, and who didn't love the fmc?
829 reviews
December 27, 2022
Nice spice

Nice spice that I read during the festive break. Enjoyed it as it was a quick read that you Disney have to think too much about.
Profile Image for Boo.
3,677 reviews14 followers
February 10, 2023
enjoyed

I lm the mood for a quick steamy read? This is insta love, no drama and no plot. After they meet, f*€k it jumps to the end. A good fast read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 41 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.