Off The Record by Jennifer O’Connell has been on my shelves for quite a long time. It was published in 2005, but I bought it used sometime later.
I would say this book is more women’s fiction or chick lit. The story focuses mostly on a woman reexamining her life and deciding to possibly take a different path.
Jane Marlow is an estates/trusts attorney who is working hard to make partner at a Chicago law firm. She’s a serious person who stepped in as a teen when her father unexpectedly died to make sure her family didn’t fall apart. Since then, her mother has remarried but her younger brother is still the goofball he’s always been, working at a bar owned by an old friend of their father’s. One of Jane’s biggest clients, an older woman who runs her family’s lucrative foundation, is being sued by her granddaughter for mismanagement of their money. As a result a hotshot trial attorney, who used to work in their Chicago offices, is called in from New York City. Jane is immediately wary of what this means for her partnership as any slip-up in her legal oversight might mean she won’t make partner.
In the meantime, Jane’s irresponsible brother contacts Jane after watching a TV show called, Off the Record, which features updates and “where are they now” stories on pop and rock stars. Growing up, a kid that lived in their neighborhood became a big rockstar thirteen years previously, with a breakout hit called, Janey 245. No one has ever been able to figure out who the song is based on. However, the fact that Jane and Andy knew this kid - now named Teddy Rock - and that they lived at 245 on the same street, Jane’s brother, Andy, thinks the girl Teddy based the song on is her, despite the fact that they were mere tweens at the time, and the song is quite sexy.
Initially, Jane thinks Andy’s supposition is preposterous, although the thought becomes more and more appealing to her in contrast to her buttoned-up lifestyle. Unbeknownst to her, Andy reaches out to a local radio station about his sister, especially since the bar he works at is losing money and needs a boost. He proposes that they come to the bar and feature Janey on their broadcast. Andy tricks Jane into coming to the bar and being on the radio, and soon fans of Teddy’s as well as Teddy’s new PR Agent is focused on how this revelation might benefit him and reinvigorate his flagging career.
Just reviewing this plot makes my head spin. Jane was right to think it silly that she was the subject of Teddy’s song. Since she’s allegedly a smart, level-headed lawyer, you would’ve thought she would’ve quickly dispensed with the whole thing. But, that would make this story very short indeed. Instead, she lets herself fantasize about it and goes along with Teddy and Teddy’s agent’s promo plans. The book also follows Jane’s interactions with Drew, the New York attorney, who seems interested in her. The reader might be expecting a story where Jane chooses between the two men, but nothing much happens romantically with either of them through most of the book, other then some dates. This story is more about how Jane sees herself and the person she’s become. Although Drew is the more appealing option for her, Teddy stays in the mix for quite a while despite his motives and intentions being suspect. I think I would’ve given this a higher grade if Jane had been more skeptical all along. Instead, things drag out and only at the very end do we see her finally confronting Teddy and making the changes in her life she clearly wanted all along. Loose ends were tied up very quickly. I would give this a B-.