I picked up this book at a library sale earlier this year and since I love Christmas anthologies, I decided to give it a read, even though it came out 18 years ago (geez, where has the time gone?!?).
"Merry, Merry Mischief" by Lisa Plumley ⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was the first novella in the book and I found it very cute and funny. Katie and Jack really did make a great couple. Katie was the bubbly Christmas spirit social butterfly and Jack was the workaholic grinch. They had apparently hooked up before this book started, but then decided to call it quits and avoided each other for 7 months. So when Jack is stuck babysitting his little cousin, Katie decides to help the clueless man out (they were both clueless though). What we get is a pretty hilarious but adorable short romance of Katie & Jack learning how to care for a baby while finally admitting their love for one another.
This was the first book I've read by Lisa Plumley so I went to see what else she's written but her other books just get mediocre reviews, so was this one just the exception? I'll still give her a chance though with something she's written recently.
"Holiday Stud" by Kylie Adams ⭐️
I was not a fan of this novella. It was pretty terrible. I mean if you like self-centered, high maintenance and shallow female characters, then this story is for you. We get a lifestyles of the rich and famous in L.A. rundown with a lot of names dropped, spa trips, private planes, etc. I mean I knew whenever Audra agreed with the snotty Stephanie and Renee (?) that she would be someone I didn't like. Her new 'friend' pays an escort to have sex with her, yet she's married. And she saw absolutely nothing wrong with that. Instead, she wanted the guy's number so that she could use him to impress her family and show them she's not a lesbian, or single, as her mom would like to think. After meeting her family, Audra was a totally different person it seemed. She was no longer 'better than you' but down to earth. But of course she ruins it by going back to L.A. and becoming that same snooty person. I liked Colby, but we didn't get very much of him. He didn't have a lot of depth in the story, but had potential, we just needed more time to get to know him. Not sure what he saw in Audra, but given he only really saw her around her family and not out where she could be herself, I find it hard to believe they'd last in the future.
"Under the Mistletoe" by Elaine Coffman⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
This was probably my favorite novella of the book, at least until those final 2 chapters. I enjoyed the broody Stanley. I mean he certainly had the patience of a saint when it came to the kids. And Holly was a lovely southern lady who seemed to be a little overwhelmed trying to raise 7 kids (4 of her own, 3 her dead sister's). But at least she had the help of a nanny and housekeeper (wondering how she made enough money illustrating books to have 2 helpers and stay at home to raise her kids).
Now, what I didn't like were her little rugrats. Yeah, I said it. I am born and raised in NC where your parents teach you to respect your elders, always be polite and mind your manners. Even though Holly called herself a southern belle, she certainly did not raise her kids the way a southern mama would. I mean her kids played in Stanley's driveway, broke multiple windows, stole his milk and newspaper, entered his home without permission, crushed his flowers, etc. Don't even get me started on their creepy peeping into his windows. And what does Holly do? Until Stanley gets injured, absolutely nothing. If she did warn them, we really don't hear of it. Instead, her paid staff yell at him and give him the evil eye anytime he complains. How can someone who claims to be a good Southern mama let her kids be that rude and disrespectful to someone else. Like I said, he had way more patience than I would have. My mama would have spanked me if I had acted that way as a kid.
OK, so overlooking the kids and their bratty behavior (they could actually be sweet at times), the rest of the book was good. The last two chapters seemed incredibly rushed. Stanley and Holly go from only speaking on occasion as neighbors to him proposing marriage after one kiss? Yeah, didn't see believable at all!
But in the end, I did think this was the better of the stories since I found myself rushing back to finish the novella.
"A Baby for Christmas" by Lisa Jackson⭐️⭐️
I wasn't a fan of this novella. It was way too far-fetched and didn't fit the genre of the rest of the books. It was more of a crime drama mixed with a tiny bit of romance (in a weird sort of way) instead of straight romance or romantic comedy. There's A LOT of drama too revolving around Annie's sister and Liam. It was just all a bit too much. And somehow we're supposed to believe that Annie falls for Liam after only a day? And during that day she did nothing but argue with him really, so again, not believable. The I love you's didn't seem realistic. I could believe the sexual tension to a certain extent, but it ramped up way too quickly for me to think it was a wise decision or a natural progression. There's a twist that I didn't see coming, but I really didn't find it necessary. The epilogue was cute though and I'm glad they at least found happiness and a little family. I started reading this and saw that the story takes place in 1995/96, but if this book was published in 2002, I'm now wondering if this novella wasn't part of another book before. It was pretty obvious it took place prior to 2000, although Liam did mention having a 'cellular' device at one point that didn't' have signal.