The most successful reader of its kind, A World of Ideas introduces first-year writing students to the thinkers and writers whose ideas have shaped for example, Niccolò Machiavelli on government, Elizabeth Cady Stanton on justice, and Sigmund Freud on the mind. Because students perceive these writers as important, they take the writing course they learn to read more attentively, think more critically, and write more effectively. No other composition reader offers a comparable collection of important readings along with the supportive apparatus students need to understand, analyze, and respond to them.
If you are an English prof., this is a great book for your classes. If you are teaching an intro. to philosophy course, likewise, it's a great book. Students will engage with Machiavelli, Rousseau, Jefferson, Montaigne, Plato, Aristotle, MLK Jr., DeBeauvoir, Galbraith, and so many other thinkers of all time periods. It's challenging and fun for classes. I'm using it currently in a composition class and have used it in the past as well.
Some of these essays are worth revisiting on a regular basis.
- Henry David Thoreau: Civil Disobedience - Martin Luther King Jr.: Letter from Birmingham Jail - Ralph Waldo Emerson: Self-Reliance - Erich Fromm: The Individual in the Chains of Illusion - Carl Marx: The Communist Manifesto - Andrew Carnegie: The Gospel of Wealth - Robert B. Reich: Why the Rich Are Getting Richer and the Poor, Poorer - Plato: The Allegory of the Cave - Steven Pinker: Thinking Machines - Friedrich Nietzsche: Morality as Anti-Nature - Peter Singer and Jim Mason: The Ethics of Eating Meat - John Stuart Mill: The Subjection of Women - Germaine Greer: Masculinity
This book is hard to rate because it is what it is. As an introduction to various rhetorical techniques it does a good job; every writing style there is more or less us represented here. But 8 didn't read it for technique; I read it for content. I don't think that's an odd thing to do either; when one studies the writing techniques one can't help but be influenced by the writing itself. As a college textbook I was not expecting it to be entertaining. What I would have liked though was some better content. How can you rate the content of a book where Adam Smith and Karl Marx literally share space back to back? Well there were 1 or 2 good essays I'll give the book that. But the essays by smith and Aristotle were super weak sauce. The later was apparently a big fan of slavery and the farmer's definition of capitalism was owning land and having people work it for you like some kind of medieval lord. Whereas Plato came off as a great intellectual and any idea that promoted socialism was elevated to tremendous height. Ouch. No wonder it took me over 2 years to read the thing!! I seriously want to rename this book A World of Bad Ideas.
Excellent book thus far. The selections are great, the areas covered are broad, and the ideas always intriguing. Even if writing is not your thing, I would still recommend this for the ideas and writers presented. I was far too lucky to find this at the public library bookstore for only a couple of dollars...
When I first received this reader as part of my duties on SIUE's Textbook Review Community, I was incredibly excited by the promising array of readings in this book, but I felt somewhat taken aback by the altogether absence of African American women in A World of Ideas [what does this absence suggest about the book before even reading it?]. In fact, only one woman of color appears in this book at all, the former Paksitani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, and the altogether marginal presence women of color have in the book proves even more dubious when considering that this is the 10th edition of this collection. Equally unsettling is a remark Jacobus makes in the introduction to the Thomas Jefferson section when Jacobus writes, “Historians have pointed out that Jefferson probably had an affair with Sally Hemmings, a mixed race slave, and fathered children with her” (116). There are plenty of excellent texts in here, Bhutto's, Michio Kaku's, Lao-Tzu's. and others, for example, but the name of this book is less A World of Ideas, and is more so A Western World of Ideas with a Tiny Amount of Non-Western Ideas so that Universities will Adopt This as a Textbook. I admire Jacobus's vision to make these ideas more accessible to students. I just wish that these ideas better reflected ongoing intersectional conversations in First-Year Writing.
Wow! I was completely impressed on how much I was able to take from these texts! The 8th edition has a wonderful range of ancient to contemporary texts. From Plato to Lao-Tzu, Virginia Woolf, Jim Mason and Pete Singer. Though, I did use this book for a class, what I learned will take me through many walks of life. This book contains enough texts to address (maybe not answer but address) all the complex issues of humanity. This is a great book for extreme annotation, with critical thinking questions from the author at the end of each piece! Awesome!
it was a college book for one of my daughters. I found it really interesting for the essays. I did not answer the questions or write the papers, but i did learn something by reading all the essays and thinking about critical thinking.
Eventhough, I read this book for school and would not pick it to read on my own accord, I did find a few essays worth the read. I really enjoyed Martin Luther King Jr.'s Letter to Birmingham Jail, Frederick Douglass' From the Narrative, and Rachel Carson's The Sunless Sea. I personally found the information the author provided before each new section and touching on the writing style very helpful and informative.
Once started off as a required textbook from college soon became a book I would often refer back to. I feel like this book introduced me to so many of the literary greats and taught me to think even more creatively. I didn't like the instructor for this course (still don't) but grateful to have this book on my shelf.
Work is done, class is complete. There is only so far a classroom can offer to inspire a perpetual reader but the authors are notable and the writing is...influential... it was just a little too much of a structured reading though, not for the entertainment.
Some of the pieces in here are not quite applicable as this is, I'm sure, likely a college text, but there are some pieces that are applicable to everyday life. I broke out a highlighter and enjoyed lining some pieces of text.