What do you think?
Rate this book
The Huntresses #.5
The Best-Laid Plans
Newton Hughes has long dreamed of pursuing a career in law, an acceptable choice for a gentleman of status and wealth. His parents, however, disapprove of his ambition, urging him instead to take his rightful place as a gentleman of leisure—with a suitable wife of their choosing, of course.
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love.
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love.
5 pages, Audiobook
First published January 1, 2021
365 people are currently reading
2828 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 538 reviews
January 2, 2021
This book was the best and worst sort of tease for Charlie’s and Artemis’ book(s) which I will forever be anticipating until their stories are in print, and in my hands. No, I don’t know if those two will actually get together, but you better believe I’m crossing my fingers for it!
I love the title for this book! It is so well stated and I knew right from the first time I saw the title that this would be my kind of story! I loved the scheming and plotting from some of my favorite characters in Sarah’s previous Jonquil and Lancaster series! I felt like this gave me such great insight into Artemis and Charlie, and I felt some major foreshadowing happening throughout Ellie and Newton’s story! It was hard for me to separate this into Ellie and Newton’s story because I’ve been dreaming of Charlie and Artemis for so long.
As always Sarah can write such a fun, page-turning story that keeps me staying up all night to finish. I loved seeing Ellie’s and Newton’s characters develop and grow. I loved the friends that showed up along the way. I think we all want friends (and quite honestly, family) to champion us and help us believe in ourselves, and in turn be that way for them. This book was the perfect way to start off the New Year and it was worth every minute staying up past midnight to read it!
I love the title for this book! It is so well stated and I knew right from the first time I saw the title that this would be my kind of story! I loved the scheming and plotting from some of my favorite characters in Sarah’s previous Jonquil and Lancaster series! I felt like this gave me such great insight into Artemis and Charlie, and I felt some major foreshadowing happening throughout Ellie and Newton’s story! It was hard for me to separate this into Ellie and Newton’s story because I’ve been dreaming of Charlie and Artemis for so long.
As always Sarah can write such a fun, page-turning story that keeps me staying up all night to finish. I loved seeing Ellie’s and Newton’s characters develop and grow. I loved the friends that showed up along the way. I think we all want friends (and quite honestly, family) to champion us and help us believe in ourselves, and in turn be that way for them. This book was the perfect way to start off the New Year and it was worth every minute staying up past midnight to read it!
May 3, 2022
I can still remember when I saw Sarah M. Eden's book Seeking Persephone being advertised for the first time. I was soooo excited! I couldn't wait to get a copy of it. And I have been a fan ever since I opened that first book up and devoured it. I can't tell you how many times I read Seeking Persephone, Courting Miss Lancaster and Kiss of a Stranger. I lived where my local library wasn't very big and I wasn't able to get a lot of the books that I wanted to read. So I reread the copies of my books in my personal library many times. These books will always have a special place in my heart. They were there when I was a tired momma needing a break. Now my kiddos have also fallen in love with this author's books and devour them like I do. After being immersed in the Lancaster and Jonquil families' stories for years, this book was so fun to see more of them as side characters. I loved it! And I love the new characters that were introduced.
Ellie and Newton are just darling. They are two fabulous characters. They're kind of the quiet, underdogs in their families. Told what to do and not feeling like their desires and hopes are acceptable. But I loved how they found ways for themselves. And I especially love that Ellie learned to trust her heart and to not believe what her family said to her.
I love Sarah M. Eden's writing. Her characters shine. Their struggles and sorrows and hopes and dreams. Their growth. Their friendships (I really love the interconnections and friendships that are throughout her books and series). Their joy. Their humor. Their love stories. I just love it all!
There were some fun little tidbits of explanation scattered throughout that referenced something that had happened to characters from previous books. I had some good chuckles over one of those. I know that's vague and especially not helpful if you haven't read any of this author's books. But I just can't spoil it. Whether you've read her books or not, you could read this as a stand alone novel. And a bonus to that, you'll be introduced to some characters that you'll just love and want to know their stories. You'll possibly be drawn into them like I was all those years ago. Sarah M. Eden has a fan for life in this reader.
Sit back and enjoy a charming and delightful story filled with friends and family and intrigue and plans that go awry. Watch out for the sweet love story as well. *Happy Sigh*
Content: Clean. One character deals with emotional abuse from her family.
My own personal copy.
Happy Reading!!!
Ellie and Newton are just darling. They are two fabulous characters. They're kind of the quiet, underdogs in their families. Told what to do and not feeling like their desires and hopes are acceptable. But I loved how they found ways for themselves. And I especially love that Ellie learned to trust her heart and to not believe what her family said to her.
I love Sarah M. Eden's writing. Her characters shine. Their struggles and sorrows and hopes and dreams. Their growth. Their friendships (I really love the interconnections and friendships that are throughout her books and series). Their joy. Their humor. Their love stories. I just love it all!
There were some fun little tidbits of explanation scattered throughout that referenced something that had happened to characters from previous books. I had some good chuckles over one of those. I know that's vague and especially not helpful if you haven't read any of this author's books. But I just can't spoil it. Whether you've read her books or not, you could read this as a stand alone novel. And a bonus to that, you'll be introduced to some characters that you'll just love and want to know their stories. You'll possibly be drawn into them like I was all those years ago. Sarah M. Eden has a fan for life in this reader.
Sit back and enjoy a charming and delightful story filled with friends and family and intrigue and plans that go awry. Watch out for the sweet love story as well. *Happy Sigh*
Content: Clean. One character deals with emotional abuse from her family.
My own personal copy.
Happy Reading!!!
January 3, 2021
There are books that I don't want to put down. The Best Laid Plans falls on that category.
A scheme hatched to keep marriage-minded mama's at bay produced unexpected consequences. This is a friends to lovers story. I loved the dialog and the characters.
I hope there will be more stories that stem from this one and that it is an introduction. It gave me more reason to hope for an Artemis and Charlie romance. (Crossing my fingers and toes.)
A scheme hatched to keep marriage-minded mama's at bay produced unexpected consequences. This is a friends to lovers story. I loved the dialog and the characters.
I hope there will be more stories that stem from this one and that it is an introduction. It gave me more reason to hope for an Artemis and Charlie romance. (Crossing my fingers and toes.)
January 3, 2021
I thought it would be a great idea to start my 2021 reading year with a new Sarah Eden book!
This was a nice novella, a glimpse into the life of Ellie Napper. Ellie is not treated well by her family at all, they're actually rather rude to her. But, her new friendship with Artemisia Lancaster, has given her the courage to stand up to her family. Along with Artemisia, she becomes friends with Charlie Jonquil and Newton Hughes. I loved seeing them take Ellie under their wing and accept her for who she is.
I thought the story was nice, it was fun reading about the Lancaster and Jonquil families again. It did feel like it was a set-up for Charlie and Artemisia's upcoming story and to be honest, I wasn't loving the ending. But overall, an enjoyable read. It made me want to go back and read my favorite Jonquil & Lancaster books.
Content: Very clean romance, no language, no violence
This was a nice novella, a glimpse into the life of Ellie Napper. Ellie is not treated well by her family at all, they're actually rather rude to her. But, her new friendship with Artemisia Lancaster, has given her the courage to stand up to her family. Along with Artemisia, she becomes friends with Charlie Jonquil and Newton Hughes. I loved seeing them take Ellie under their wing and accept her for who she is.
I thought the story was nice, it was fun reading about the Lancaster and Jonquil families again. It did feel like it was a set-up for Charlie and Artemisia's upcoming story and to be honest, I wasn't loving the ending. But overall, an enjoyable read. It made me want to go back and read my favorite Jonquil & Lancaster books.
Content: Very clean romance, no language, no violence
June 20, 2021
Clean Regency.
This featured Newton & Ellie who became friends,
carried on a faux courtship, and then fell in love.
Ellie was subjected to hyper-criticism & animosity
by her parents and sister. This became oppressive.
I wish authors would create conflict in a book other
than heroine vs family. Or at least let them have a
temporary truce?
Ellie befriended Artemis, (sister of a retired Royal
Navy man & SIL of a duke) who taught Ellie to be
more assertive. Newton wanted to be a solicitor &
found a way to convince his folks he had more than
a casual interest in this.
This had a happy for now ending. Sarah has written
better stories.
This featured Newton & Ellie who became friends,
carried on a faux courtship, and then fell in love.
Ellie was subjected to hyper-criticism & animosity
by her parents and sister. This became oppressive.
I wish authors would create conflict in a book other
than heroine vs family. Or at least let them have a
temporary truce?
Ellie befriended Artemis, (sister of a retired Royal
Navy man & SIL of a duke) who taught Ellie to be
more assertive. Newton wanted to be a solicitor &
found a way to convince his folks he had more than
a casual interest in this.
This had a happy for now ending. Sarah has written
better stories.
February 19, 2021
'Newton Hughes has long dreamed of pursuing a career in law, an acceptable choice for a gentleman of status and wealth. His parents, however, disapprove of his ambition, urging him instead to take his rightful place as a gentleman of leisure—with a suitable wife of their choosing, of course.
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love'
__________________________
The Best-Laid Plans is a novella in Sarah M. Eden's The Lancaster Family series.
I've really enjoyed books in the past by this author and there was nothing really wrong with this novella, but I'm overall pretty ambivalent about it. I honestly had a hard time starting my review for this novella because I don't really have much to say about it. Ellie and Newton are sweet characters and it was nice to see characters I have loved from the Jonquil series, but the plot wasn't very original. It felt like something I had read before, like it was following a predetermined script. That sounds really negative, but I did enjoy it. Perhaps it just wasn't what I expected based on what I have read by this author before.
So overall it was a sweet novella and enjoyable, especially if you have read the related books and know the other characters, but it is also fairly predictable.
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love'
__________________________
The Best-Laid Plans is a novella in Sarah M. Eden's The Lancaster Family series.
I've really enjoyed books in the past by this author and there was nothing really wrong with this novella, but I'm overall pretty ambivalent about it. I honestly had a hard time starting my review for this novella because I don't really have much to say about it. Ellie and Newton are sweet characters and it was nice to see characters I have loved from the Jonquil series, but the plot wasn't very original. It felt like something I had read before, like it was following a predetermined script. That sounds really negative, but I did enjoy it. Perhaps it just wasn't what I expected based on what I have read by this author before.
So overall it was a sweet novella and enjoyable, especially if you have read the related books and know the other characters, but it is also fairly predictable.
January 3, 2021
Oh man this was a joy to read. It has the Lancaster's and the Jonquils:} Made my heart happy. Eden knows how to write a sweet love story. Simple and profound and so lovely to read. Very perfect to the time period this story flows and has such a good lighthearted feel. A proper romance with no religion.
December 28, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed this story and can't wait to read Charlie and Artimis's story!!! Miss Eden is always a go-to author for me.
May 24, 2021
Enjoyed this little gem!
What a teaser! I loved the mash-up of the Lancasters and the Jonquils and when Newton and Ellie were thrown into the mix of an entertaining way to avoid marriage, I was hooked. Eden always writes delightfully charming characters and Artemis and her Huntresses opened up all kinds of possibilities for future stories.
Ellie is mistreated by those who should love her best and I was so happy when Artemis took Ellie under her wing. Newton is such a wonderfully kind gentleman and the plan they came up with was full of thrills and swoon, especially as this group became tight-knit. These characters are endearing.
You'd better believe I'm counting down the days to the match of a lifetime and it all sparked with this adorable novella!
Content: mild romance; mild mistreatment
What a teaser! I loved the mash-up of the Lancasters and the Jonquils and when Newton and Ellie were thrown into the mix of an entertaining way to avoid marriage, I was hooked. Eden always writes delightfully charming characters and Artemis and her Huntresses opened up all kinds of possibilities for future stories.
Ellie is mistreated by those who should love her best and I was so happy when Artemis took Ellie under her wing. Newton is such a wonderfully kind gentleman and the plan they came up with was full of thrills and swoon, especially as this group became tight-knit. These characters are endearing.
You'd better believe I'm counting down the days to the match of a lifetime and it all sparked with this adorable novella!
Content: mild romance; mild mistreatment
Want to read
January 6, 2021Nominated for a 2021 Swoony Award, to vote click here: https://tinyurl.com/y593ce67
January 6, 2021
Sarah Eden always writes such beautiful Regencies, ones that contain more depth than just a simple love story, though her love stories are always lovely and romantic. The Best-Laid Plans was no exception.
The premise immediately drew me in—two well meaning people coming together to fake a relationship in hopes of staving off the meddling from their families. Of course, things never go according to plan, and soon their charade creates feelings between them that are real.
I really enjoyed both Ellie and Newton as characters—Ellie is unconventional and witty, Newton is unassuming but has a really kind heart. They had a lovely friendship that quickly developed into something more. I loved watching them come together. It was also so much fun seeing more of Charlie and Artemis, as well as Linus and Arabella. In some ways Charlie and Artemis overshadowed Ellie and Newton, paving the way for their stories, but overall I didn’t mind since I like both characters and hope that they eventually get together.
Though this is a romance at heart, much of the falling in love takes place in the background, as does the premise that initially brings our characters together. Instead the focus is on Ellie’s home life and the mistreatment she faces from her family, and how through the help of her new friends, she’s able to gain the confidence to not only stand up for herself, but be true to herself in all circumstances. This character growth was lovely to experience.
Overall this was a lovely story and a wonderful way to start the new year.
The premise immediately drew me in—two well meaning people coming together to fake a relationship in hopes of staving off the meddling from their families. Of course, things never go according to plan, and soon their charade creates feelings between them that are real.
I really enjoyed both Ellie and Newton as characters—Ellie is unconventional and witty, Newton is unassuming but has a really kind heart. They had a lovely friendship that quickly developed into something more. I loved watching them come together. It was also so much fun seeing more of Charlie and Artemis, as well as Linus and Arabella. In some ways Charlie and Artemis overshadowed Ellie and Newton, paving the way for their stories, but overall I didn’t mind since I like both characters and hope that they eventually get together.
Though this is a romance at heart, much of the falling in love takes place in the background, as does the premise that initially brings our characters together. Instead the focus is on Ellie’s home life and the mistreatment she faces from her family, and how through the help of her new friends, she’s able to gain the confidence to not only stand up for herself, but be true to herself in all circumstances. This character growth was lovely to experience.
Overall this was a lovely story and a wonderful way to start the new year.
March 17, 2021
First off, I listened the audible edition narrated by Luone Ingram and I loved it! Especially the zippy dialogue. There's something about listening to it (rather than reading the words) that made me feel like I was right there hearing everything first hand. Ellie and Newton's romance develops in the most delightful of ways. Both have domineering parents trying to push them in directions they don't want to go, they find a kinship that slowly blossoms into something so much more. Delectable to the very last syllable!
February 17, 2021
This was okay but nothing out of the ordinary. I'm a bit tired of the terrible parents and/or sibling who make life miserable for the protagonist plot device. The best part of the story was the interaction between Charlie Jonquil and Artemis Lancaster.
January 2, 2021
I am a big Sarah Eden fan and really loved this novella. A great way to start off my new reading year! Full review to come.
January 19, 2022
Newton Hughes wants little to do with Society. He doesn't fit in and would prefer to study the law. Unfortunately, his parents do not see the law as suitable for a gentleman, especially one whose father's estate can easily support him. He enlists the aid of his school days partner-in-crime, Charlie Jonquil, to come help explain. (If you're new to the series, Charlie's older brother Jason is a barrister in London). While his parents believe Charlie will be a good influence bringing Newton into Society. Ellie Napper has come to Bath with her family in a near last ditch effort to find suitable, wealthy, well-connected husbands for Ellie's older sister and a less illustrious husband for herself. While Lillian happily falls in line with their parents' plans, Ellie dreams of true love. As the ugly duckling of the family, she knows that will never happen but to choose a husband in such a mercenary manner is not to her liking. While her mother forces Ellie to conform to a mold while pursuing Charlie Jonquil, it's Charlie's friend Newt Ellie is more drawn to. He's quiet and seems to appreciate her wit, when her mother isn't watching. Through the young gentlemen, Ellie gets to know her former neighbor, Artemis Lancaster, Charlie's nemesis. Artemis takes a shine to Ellie but not so much to Newt, whose parents want him to pursue her. The new friends cook up a scheme for a sham courtship between Ellie and Newt and Charlie and Artemis. Will the plan succeed in getting their parents off their backs? What happens if the plan succeeds TOO well?
AWW!! This is another winner from Sarah M. Eden! It's lighter in tone than some of her others, has an unusual and slightly unsatisfying ending but still left me with a big smile on my face before shutting off my light and going to sleep for the night. That's exactly the feeling I want from my Regency romances. The tone of the story reads very young adult. Ellie is only 17 and not quite out yet. Newt is also young, just finished school and as they're both intellectual introverts, they aren't as polished as the older characters. That was fine by me because it made the story sweeter and the characters easier for me to relate to.
Ellie is a regular Cinderella but instead of a wicked stepmother and ugly stepsister, she has a horrid mother and equally horrible sister, plus a father who doesn't often interfere but sides with her mother and sister when he does. Ellie has been emotionally and verbally abused her whole life. She's second fiddle to her sister who is content to play the part her mother expects. Ellie is wise beyond her years and sees her mother's mandates as a mask. Ellie hides her light under a bushel and tries to conform. I felt so bad for her and in some ways I can relate to being unconventional in a conventional family. Ellie's character growth is great and I really love her with Newt. Newt is sweet, kind and smart. He doesn't want to be trapped in marriage to a social climbing, greedy harpy like Ellie's sister. He doesn't even want to get married right now. All he wants is to be free to pursue his passion. They both find it's easier to stay silent and give in sometimes than fight their parents. I can relate to that a lot. Newton is not your average Regency hero being neither a rake nor a Corinthian nor a dandy. He's also not as socially awkward as Corbin Jonquil, just introverted and thoughtful. Newton quietly stands up for his principles and for Ellie throughout the novel. He's sweet and I like him very much. I love his passion, his kindness and his principles. At one point I was a little worried for him thinking he might be TOO nice. He's nice but not stupid, plus he has great friends.
Hooray for Charlie! He's grown up now, studying at Cambridge and pursuing an intellectual path. He's still high spirited and his imitations of his older brothers are hilarious. I'm not sure why his relationship with them is so complicated and fraught. Perhaps because they'll always see him as their baby brother, the mischief maker? Charlie is a good friend though. He goes through great lengths to help Newton even though he doesn't really want to be around Aretemis for some reason. Charlie also does something really nice for Newton at the end that shows how thoughtful and kind Charlie actually is.
I don't get why Charlie doesn't like Artemis and why he thinks she's playing a role/wearing a mask. I only met her when she was little. In the meantime, I gather her father died since it's mentioned several times she lives at Falstone Castle and is the ward of the Duke of Kielder. (Adam has come a long way!) Artemis is determined to be in control of her own destiny. She's brave, bold, and an excellent friend. Artemis doesn't fit in like Newt. She longs for a more equal society where women and men and people from different countries are all treated with respect. I see lots of kindness and compassion in Artemis. While she shows Charlie a silly, flirtatious side, he seems to know she isn't really like that and hates it but isn't that what Society expects of young ladies? Does she really have a choice? Her brother-in-law's name gives her some protection to step out of line and be a little mischievous but if she really steps out of bounds, I know he'd be on her like a hound on a fox. Far be it for Adam to preach propriety but it would reflect badly on his beloved wife if people thought she raised Artemis to be a hoyden or worse. I really need to read Charlie and Artemis's story soon to find out what's going on there!
Ellie's mother is AWFUL! She won't win any mother of the year awards, that's for sure. She's bullying and abusive towards her own younger daughter. Ellie's body doesn't fit the conventional mold so her mother automatically writes her off as hopeless. Then she verbally abuses her own daughter, putting Ellie down every chance she gets. It's no wonder Ellie appears silent and gauche! I would be too. Ellie's sister Lillian is a chip off the old block. She's purposefully mean to her sister and the more Ellie blossoms, the more Lillian puts her down. Lillian is single-minded in her goal and even states a truth about gentlemen in order to put her sister down but it is a truth univerally acknowledged that gentlemen don't like ladies who are obvious in their pursuit and isn't that just what Lillian is? How can she say that about Ellie but not recognize her own forward and obvious behavior? I predict she'll remain a spinster or her parents will find some elderly nabob to marry her off to. She's worse than Caroline Bingley!
Artemis has two friends with her in Bath to form a posse of gal pals that are determined to live life on their own terms. It's sweet how they automatically accept Ellie and don't bully her like her horrid mother and sister. Miss Gillian Phelps is more quiet than her friends but she has a mischievous streak. Miss Daria Mullins is more like Artemis, bold and fierce and fun. She seems to enjoy thwarting Lillian's plans. They seem like good, loyal friends. There are two more in London!
My only major complaint about this novella is that the end is rushed. I wanted to see more true courtship and falling deeper into love. The conclusion was a bit unsatisfactory but I think exactly right for the characters. They're introverted and thoughtful. He has a goal he wants to pursue and she's still very young. She's never had a Season so she's essentially not yet out. I hate it when these romance novels marry off teen girls right away. Waiting is better. I'm sure it will all turn out for the best but please, please Ms. Eden, don't put them through the wringer!
I hope this is just a teaser and we get Ellie's happy ever after in one of the forthcoming Huntress books. I'm eager to see what's in store for those ladies as well. I have Charming Artemis in my pile already! (It unfortunately has to quarantine or I would be reading it right now!)
If you're new to Sarah M. Eden, don't start here. This is an in-between to bridge the Lancaster series and the Jonquils. Plus you'll want to read all about the charming Jonquil brothers (Flip is my very favorite!), especially Philip, Earl of Lampton. Friends and Foes. I don't know the Lancasters as well and I think it would help to read Loving Lieutenant Lancaster at the very least.
AWW!! This is another winner from Sarah M. Eden! It's lighter in tone than some of her others, has an unusual and slightly unsatisfying ending but still left me with a big smile on my face before shutting off my light and going to sleep for the night. That's exactly the feeling I want from my Regency romances. The tone of the story reads very young adult. Ellie is only 17 and not quite out yet. Newt is also young, just finished school and as they're both intellectual introverts, they aren't as polished as the older characters. That was fine by me because it made the story sweeter and the characters easier for me to relate to.
Ellie is a regular Cinderella but instead of a wicked stepmother and ugly stepsister, she has a horrid mother and equally horrible sister, plus a father who doesn't often interfere but sides with her mother and sister when he does. Ellie has been emotionally and verbally abused her whole life. She's second fiddle to her sister who is content to play the part her mother expects. Ellie is wise beyond her years and sees her mother's mandates as a mask. Ellie hides her light under a bushel and tries to conform. I felt so bad for her and in some ways I can relate to being unconventional in a conventional family. Ellie's character growth is great and I really love her with Newt. Newt is sweet, kind and smart. He doesn't want to be trapped in marriage to a social climbing, greedy harpy like Ellie's sister. He doesn't even want to get married right now. All he wants is to be free to pursue his passion. They both find it's easier to stay silent and give in sometimes than fight their parents. I can relate to that a lot. Newton is not your average Regency hero being neither a rake nor a Corinthian nor a dandy. He's also not as socially awkward as Corbin Jonquil, just introverted and thoughtful. Newton quietly stands up for his principles and for Ellie throughout the novel. He's sweet and I like him very much. I love his passion, his kindness and his principles. At one point I was a little worried for him thinking he might be TOO nice. He's nice but not stupid, plus he has great friends.
Hooray for Charlie! He's grown up now, studying at Cambridge and pursuing an intellectual path. He's still high spirited and his imitations of his older brothers are hilarious. I'm not sure why his relationship with them is so complicated and fraught. Perhaps because they'll always see him as their baby brother, the mischief maker? Charlie is a good friend though. He goes through great lengths to help Newton even though he doesn't really want to be around Aretemis for some reason. Charlie also does something really nice for Newton at the end that shows how thoughtful and kind Charlie actually is.
I don't get why Charlie doesn't like Artemis and why he thinks she's playing a role/wearing a mask. I only met her when she was little. In the meantime, I gather her father died since it's mentioned several times she lives at Falstone Castle and is the ward of the Duke of Kielder. (Adam has come a long way!) Artemis is determined to be in control of her own destiny. She's brave, bold, and an excellent friend. Artemis doesn't fit in like Newt. She longs for a more equal society where women and men and people from different countries are all treated with respect. I see lots of kindness and compassion in Artemis. While she shows Charlie a silly, flirtatious side, he seems to know she isn't really like that and hates it but isn't that what Society expects of young ladies? Does she really have a choice? Her brother-in-law's name gives her some protection to step out of line and be a little mischievous but if she really steps out of bounds, I know he'd be on her like a hound on a fox. Far be it for Adam to preach propriety but it would reflect badly on his beloved wife if people thought she raised Artemis to be a hoyden or worse. I really need to read Charlie and Artemis's story soon to find out what's going on there!
Ellie's mother is AWFUL! She won't win any mother of the year awards, that's for sure. She's bullying and abusive towards her own younger daughter. Ellie's body doesn't fit the conventional mold so her mother automatically writes her off as hopeless. Then she verbally abuses her own daughter, putting Ellie down every chance she gets. It's no wonder Ellie appears silent and gauche! I would be too. Ellie's sister Lillian is a chip off the old block. She's purposefully mean to her sister and the more Ellie blossoms, the more Lillian puts her down. Lillian is single-minded in her goal and even states a truth about gentlemen in order to put her sister down but it is a truth univerally acknowledged that gentlemen don't like ladies who are obvious in their pursuit and isn't that just what Lillian is? How can she say that about Ellie but not recognize her own forward and obvious behavior? I predict she'll remain a spinster or her parents will find some elderly nabob to marry her off to. She's worse than Caroline Bingley!
Artemis has two friends with her in Bath to form a posse of gal pals that are determined to live life on their own terms. It's sweet how they automatically accept Ellie and don't bully her like her horrid mother and sister. Miss Gillian Phelps is more quiet than her friends but she has a mischievous streak. Miss Daria Mullins is more like Artemis, bold and fierce and fun. She seems to enjoy thwarting Lillian's plans. They seem like good, loyal friends. There are two more in London!
My only major complaint about this novella is that the end is rushed. I wanted to see more true courtship and falling deeper into love. The conclusion was a bit unsatisfactory but I think exactly right for the characters. They're introverted and thoughtful. He has a goal he wants to pursue and she's still very young. She's never had a Season so she's essentially not yet out. I hate it when these romance novels marry off teen girls right away. Waiting is better. I'm sure it will all turn out for the best but please, please Ms. Eden, don't put them through the wringer!
I hope this is just a teaser and we get Ellie's happy ever after in one of the forthcoming Huntress books. I'm eager to see what's in store for those ladies as well. I have Charming Artemis in my pile already! (It unfortunately has to quarantine or I would be reading it right now!)
If you're new to Sarah M. Eden, don't start here. This is an in-between to bridge the Lancaster series and the Jonquils. Plus you'll want to read all about the charming Jonquil brothers (Flip is my very favorite!), especially Philip, Earl of Lampton. Friends and Foes. I don't know the Lancasters as well and I think it would help to read Loving Lieutenant Lancaster at the very least.
February 3, 2021
A new book by Sarah Eden is a great way to start off the new year. I can't tell you how much I absolutely loved Ellie and Newton's story and hope we'll get little glimpses of them in future books. Ellie Napper is treated terribly by her family--especially her mother. She doesn't want to pretend she's featherbrained to get the attention of suitors. Why should she pretend to be something she's not?
Newton Hughes wants to be a barrister, which his parents greatly disapprove of. They want him to enter society and marry a suitable young lady of their choice. The problem is Newton doesn't find any of the young ladies interesting at all. When he meets Ellie through a mutual friend, they decide to get their parents off of their backs by pretending to be interested in one another. You know what they say about best laid plans...
Ellie and Newton were perfect for each other. I wouldn't say they were introverts but they were both kind of quiet and would rather not attend big social gatherings. I loved that Newton realized that Ellie acted differently when they weren't around her family and encouraged her to be herself. She was interested in listening to him discuss the law--what a great support she'll be to him while he's in school to become a barrister. I loved how Artemis became friends with Ellie and taught her how to stand up to those who put her down or tried to make her feel less than. Those are the kind of friends a girl needs.
This was such a sweet story, I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it.
Newton Hughes wants to be a barrister, which his parents greatly disapprove of. They want him to enter society and marry a suitable young lady of their choice. The problem is Newton doesn't find any of the young ladies interesting at all. When he meets Ellie through a mutual friend, they decide to get their parents off of their backs by pretending to be interested in one another. You know what they say about best laid plans...
Ellie and Newton were perfect for each other. I wouldn't say they were introverts but they were both kind of quiet and would rather not attend big social gatherings. I loved that Newton realized that Ellie acted differently when they weren't around her family and encouraged her to be herself. She was interested in listening to him discuss the law--what a great support she'll be to him while he's in school to become a barrister. I loved how Artemis became friends with Ellie and taught her how to stand up to those who put her down or tried to make her feel less than. Those are the kind of friends a girl needs.
This was such a sweet story, I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it.
January 1, 2021
Sarah M Eden continues to bring beloved characters to life, even the ones that have yet to be fully met by readers. Just as life is intertwined with people we know and love-and sometimes those we can not stand-so too are the characters in her novels.
Perhaps best of all is the different sizes, shapes, looks, and circumstances of each of her heroines. A beautiful reminder of the unique beauty of womanhood and that each is deserving of love and compassion. I was brought to tears in seeing myself in Miss Ellie. Reading her story gave confidence in me to live mine.
Perhaps best of all is the different sizes, shapes, looks, and circumstances of each of her heroines. A beautiful reminder of the unique beauty of womanhood and that each is deserving of love and compassion. I was brought to tears in seeing myself in Miss Ellie. Reading her story gave confidence in me to live mine.
January 5, 2024
I really enjoyed this novella, which begins the Huntresses series. It contains a handful of the characters from the author's beloved Jonquil Brothers and Lancaster Family series, as well. I have actually already read the book that comes after this one, but that did not diminish my enjoyment of this introduction.
Poor Ellie was treated horrendously by her family, especially her mother and sister. It was so delightful to see Artemis and her friends step in and offer her their friendship and even their protection. Newton and Charlie were great characters, as well, and I liked seeing the bond grow between Newton and Ellie.
I listened to this novella as an audio book and it was excellently read. It was a sweet story that I enjoyed from start to finish.
(4.5 stars)
Poor Ellie was treated horrendously by her family, especially her mother and sister. It was so delightful to see Artemis and her friends step in and offer her their friendship and even their protection. Newton and Charlie were great characters, as well, and I liked seeing the bond grow between Newton and Ellie.
I listened to this novella as an audio book and it was excellently read. It was a sweet story that I enjoyed from start to finish.
(4.5 stars)
Read
January 17, 2021Another delightful read! Review to come.
January 1, 2021
Wonderful Regency romance!
Loved this sweet Regency Novella! Wonderful story about one of Charlie Jonquil’s friends and his love. I loved how the couple fell in love and how they are perfect for each other!
Loved this sweet Regency Novella! Wonderful story about one of Charlie Jonquil’s friends and his love. I loved how the couple fell in love and how they are perfect for each other!
February 8, 2021
Feb.2021 reread audiobook
This stand alone is the perfect teaser for Charlies story. Sarah said it's in the works but we don't have an official date yet.
The Best-Laid Plans
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sweet story about two people who want to be together. Short read about 120 pages and fast paced plot. This one takes place in the Jonquil and Lancaster world and is considered a stand alone. Artemis Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil both play a big part in the story.
I really hope they end up together in the next one ❤🤞🏼
Book Synopsis:
"When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love."
This stand alone is the perfect teaser for Charlies story. Sarah said it's in the works but we don't have an official date yet.
The Best-Laid Plans
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Sweet story about two people who want to be together. Short read about 120 pages and fast paced plot. This one takes place in the Jonquil and Lancaster world and is considered a stand alone. Artemis Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil both play a big part in the story.
I really hope they end up together in the next one ❤🤞🏼
Book Synopsis:
"When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love."
September 2, 2022
A new book by Sarah Eden is a great way to start off the new year. I can't tell you how much I absolutely loved Ellie and Newton's story and hope we'll get little glimpses of them in future books. Ellie Napper is treated terribly by her family--especially her mother. She doesn't want to pretend she's featherbrained to get the attention of suitors. Why should she pretend to be something she's not?
Newton Hughes wants to be a barrister, which his parents greatly disapprove of. They want him to enter society and marry a suitable young lady of their choice. The problem is Newton doesn't find any of the young ladies interesting at all. When he meets Ellie through a mutual friend, they decide to get their parents off of their backs by pretending to be interested in one another. You know what they say about best laid plans...
Ellie and Newton were perfect for each other. I wouldn't say they were introverts but they were both kind of quiet and would rather not attend big social gatherings. I loved that Newton realized that Ellie acted differently when they weren't around her family and encouraged her to be herself. She was interested in listening to him discuss the law--what a great support she'll be to him while he's in school to become a barrister. I loved how Artemis became friends with Ellie and taught her how to stand up to those who put her down or tried to make her feel less than. Those are the kind of friends a girl needs.
This was such a sweet story, I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it.
Newton Hughes wants to be a barrister, which his parents greatly disapprove of. They want him to enter society and marry a suitable young lady of their choice. The problem is Newton doesn't find any of the young ladies interesting at all. When he meets Ellie through a mutual friend, they decide to get their parents off of their backs by pretending to be interested in one another. You know what they say about best laid plans...
Ellie and Newton were perfect for each other. I wouldn't say they were introverts but they were both kind of quiet and would rather not attend big social gatherings. I loved that Newton realized that Ellie acted differently when they weren't around her family and encouraged her to be herself. She was interested in listening to him discuss the law--what a great support she'll be to him while he's in school to become a barrister. I loved how Artemis became friends with Ellie and taught her how to stand up to those who put her down or tried to make her feel less than. Those are the kind of friends a girl needs.
This was such a sweet story, I thoroughly enjoyed every minute of it.
February 2, 2021
Sweet Regency Novella
Super cute novella! It was fun to meet some new characters to start off a new series as well as seeing some favorites from other series. I finally like Artemis so I am excited for her book coming up! Ellie and Newton are both sweet and easy to like characters.
Super cute novella! It was fun to meet some new characters to start off a new series as well as seeing some favorites from other series. I finally like Artemis so I am excited for her book coming up! Ellie and Newton are both sweet and easy to like characters.
February 5, 2025
“Newton Hughes was a gentleman, which was a shame, really.”
I fully blame Sarah Eden and this book for how tired and unproductive I am today. 😂 I certainly am not to blame for being hooked at the first sentence (above) and not being able to put this down once I started reading it, right? 😉
I loved this novella! Ellie is so sweet and kind, and it was fun to get a glimpse of life in Bath in this fictional world. It’s always fun when characters from Sarah’s other books make appearances, too. Linus Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil are some of my favorites (as many of her characters are!), and I loved seeing another side to Artemis Lancaster, and I hope to see more of the Huntresses. I still hope for Artemis and Charlie to end up together, but I also know that in Greek mythology, Artemis was a maiden goddess, and the Lancasters’ stories mirror their Greek counterparts, so I can’t help but wonder about that as well. 🤔 I guess we’ll find out one day!
I fully blame Sarah Eden and this book for how tired and unproductive I am today. 😂 I certainly am not to blame for being hooked at the first sentence (above) and not being able to put this down once I started reading it, right? 😉
I loved this novella! Ellie is so sweet and kind, and it was fun to get a glimpse of life in Bath in this fictional world. It’s always fun when characters from Sarah’s other books make appearances, too. Linus Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil are some of my favorites (as many of her characters are!), and I loved seeing another side to Artemis Lancaster, and I hope to see more of the Huntresses. I still hope for Artemis and Charlie to end up together, but I also know that in Greek mythology, Artemis was a maiden goddess, and the Lancasters’ stories mirror their Greek counterparts, so I can’t help but wonder about that as well. 🤔 I guess we’ll find out one day!
January 10, 2021
I've got to admit, I was a little disappointed in this read. Let me first say, I've loved works from this author before. Longing For Home is probably the series I use to compare all of her books. With that in mind, I just feel like this story didn't have a lot of plot. All the characters were likable enough and it was super great to see the Jonquil family again. But I found myself more interested in the barely mentioned subplot between Charlie and Artemis than I was in Newton and Ellie. As a matter of fact, when I went to write this review, I had trouble remembering Ellie's name. That's weird after reading an entire book about her. It was still cute and somewhat charming, just not all that exciting or apparently memorable.
August 30, 2021
Reading a Sarah Eden book feels like coming home! I love the familiarity of her writing, her dynamic characters, and that happy sigh I get when I read her happily ever afters Newton and Ellie were worthy newcomers to the Jonquil/Lancaster clan of family and friends and I loved reading their sweet romance. Keeping fingers crossed with everyone else that this is but a precursor to the love story for Charlie and Artemis. Their book, which has not even been officially announced, is already the most anticipated book of the year to those who are lucky enough to be one of Sarah's readers.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but a positive review was not required.
I received a complimentary copy of this book but a positive review was not required.
November 6, 2021
Wonderful!
Sarah M. Eden is an automatic purchase for me. This novella was the perfect read to start 2021. While the main characters have much to overcome with their families, there is a sense of hope for a joyful future. I love this quote: "Cowardice is all but guaranteed to cost a person what he truly wants.... I believe we would both do best to be brave."
This novel brings together characters from the author's Lancaster and Jonquil series. One of the characters has rather irritated me in the past. Now I adore her and can't wait for her story.
Sarah M. Eden is an automatic purchase for me. This novella was the perfect read to start 2021. While the main characters have much to overcome with their families, there is a sense of hope for a joyful future. I love this quote: "Cowardice is all but guaranteed to cost a person what he truly wants.... I believe we would both do best to be brave."
This novel brings together characters from the author's Lancaster and Jonquil series. One of the characters has rather irritated me in the past. Now I adore her and can't wait for her story.
December 2, 2022
The Best Laid-Plans is the first book that I read by Sarah M. Eden. The book is listed as a standalone novella. However, some of the characters from two of the authors other series the Lancaster Family series and Jonquil Brothers series make appearances in the book. When I first read the book, I was wondering if the side characters had books. I’d suggest maybe at least reading books 1- 4 of the Lancaster series before reading Best Laid-Plans. The author does a good job of giving a rundown of characters and connections, but I think you’ll get even more out of the reading experience if you have read some of the other books. There is stuff mentioned that happened in Loving Lieutenant Lancaster (book 4) in this novella. I just read the Lancaster series, so I decided to do a reread of Best Laid. I knew some of the side characters and some characters that were mentioned better after reading the Lancaster series. I still need to read the Jonquil series.
Before this book was released, I read the synopsis. The arrangement between Newton/Ellie reminded me of the arrangement between Daphne/Simon from Bridgerton, so I decided to read the novella. I liked the whole fake courtship trope and ended up enjoying the novella. I was curious about the side characters and if they had stories. I was glad to see that some of the side characters/characters mentioned did have books.
The book is told in dul pov and is a clean romance: just a few kisses.
Most of the story takes place in Bath the summer of 1817. This story takes place around a year after Loving Lieutenant Lancaster.
Newton Hughes (H) 21 is a recent graduate from Cambridge. For a long time Newton has dreamed of studying law and becoming a barrister. He would like to start pursuing a career in law. Unfortunately, Newton’s father does not approve of his son finding work because he views that as beneath them. Newton’s parents don’t understand why he wants to work when he can just live off of the families fortune. They want him to live a leisurely life and find a wife.
Newton’s best friend Charlie Jonquil, youngest brother of the Earl of Lampton, is on break from school so Newton’s parents suggest inviting him to Bath. They hope that Charlie will help Newton forget about pursuing this silly dream of his. Charlie has a brother that is a barrister and he would never discourage his friend from doing something that makes him happy.
Elfrida aka “Ellie” Napper (h) 19 is the youngest of three sisters. The Nappers made a few brief appearances in Loving Lieutenant Lancaster, but they were not given names. Ellie’s family is planning on going to Bath for the summer. They usually spend time in Bath because they can’t afford to go to London for the season. This will be the first year that Ellie is going to Bath with her family. It’s not going to be the leisurely trip she thought it would be. The Napper sisters don’t have much when it comes to a dowry. Ellie’s mother wants Ellie and her older sister Lillian to secure good matches while in Bath to help the family.
Mrs. Napper is still upset that the eldest daughter Beatrice married a “penniless nobody”. She doesn’t consider it a good marriage if it doesn’t socially and monetarily benefit the family. Mrs. Napper feels that Beatrice betrayed the family and will not let her other two daughters make the same mistake.
“Of course,” she said in a perfect imitation of her mother. Newton couldn’t help but laugh. “My parents have no sons. They have decided the purpose of their daughters is to improve their situation by marrying well. Of course, the definition of ‘well’ is limited to monetary gain and improvements and social standing. My older sister married a gentleman who had none of those things, but he loves her. She successfully resisted all my parents’ attempts to court someone they approved of. Lillian and I will not be so fortunate.”
The Nappers’ live in Shropshire and are neighbors to Linus Lancaster (retired from the Royal Navy, brother in law to the Duke of Kielder)and his new wife Arabella. Linus has become really close to Charlie Jonquil. In the past Mrs. Napper tried to have Lillian catch Charlie’s eye, but he wasn’t interested in her at all. Mrs. Napper finds out that Linus and Charlie will be in Bath at the same time. Also, Charlie’s good friend Newton Hughes will be there. Mrs. Napper plans to call on Mr. Lancaster as much as possible and use that connection for her daughters to get close to Charlie and Newton. Mr. Hughes is wealthy and important. Mrs. Napper, wants Ellie to try to catch Charlie’s eye and Lillian to try to catch Newton’s eye. Ellie has no interest in playing these games. Over the years, she has learned that it is easier to just keep her mouth shut and do what her parents want. Mrs. Napper warns Ellie to not mess things up for the family. Ellie’s mother is always criticizing and finding fault with her. While Ellie’s mom sees Lillian as the perfect compliant daughter. Off they go to Bath.
Linus’s youngest sister Artemis Lancaster (sister-in-law to Adam Boyce, the Duke of Kielder). happens to be in staying in Bath with Linus and his new wife. Artemis Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil play a prominent role in the story. Charlie isn’t thrilled about about Artemis being in Bath because the two haven’t gotten along ever since his mother threw a house party around a year ago. The party takes place in Loving Lieutenant Lancaster. Charlie has even taken to calling her “Miss Sham-Caster”. Newton doesn’t understand Charlie’s dislike for Artemis because he likes and gets along with her fine.
Charlie and Newton end up at Linus Lancaster’s house. Shortly after, the Nappers show up and Charlie isn’t thrilled about it. Newton and Charlie realize that Mrs. Napper is scheming.
“Any gentleman in possession of an income and familial connections learned early how to undermine unwanted matrimonial efforts without rudeness and how to tiptoe around traps and snares. Between the unexpected presence of Charlie’s sworn enemy and the pointed pursuit of the Nappers, this promised to be a most unusual sojourn in Bath.” ~Newton
Newton’s parents start hassling him to court Artemis Lancaster, but neither is interested. Ellie’s mother wants her to pursue Charlie (since her sister was unable to catch his eye), but neither are interested. Newton wants nothing to do with Lillian’s relentless pursuit. Artemis and Ellie hatch a plan for Ellie and Newton to fake a courtship. This way the parents will get off their backs. Charlie even agrees to be a part of the plan. Artemis, Charlie, Newton, and Ellie agree to spend a lot of time together in a group while in Bath. Newton and Ellie plan to show enough interest in each other to get their parents to back off, but not enough to be scandalous or cause whispers. Thus begins this interesting ruse. Newton and Ellie do develop a friendship and start to have feelings for each other, but they wonder if the other person feels the same way or if it’s just a part of the act. Together with the help of Artemis they learn to be braver and fight for the future that they want.
The story had a lot of great characters in it. I think Newton and Ellie make a good match. I feel that this story gives more insight into Artemis. Artemis is fierce. She is a force to be reckoned with and lives up to her namesake. It was nice to see Artemis take Ellie under her wing and help her to become braver. Artemis helped Newton out a lot. I liked the Huntresses that were introduced in the story. Artemis called her group of female friends the “Huntresses”.
“Huntresses?” Artemis nodded quite solemnly. “My ancient namesake had a band of huntresses, and they were absolutely everything young ladies ought to be permitted to be: fierce, strong, capable, and entirely in control of their own destinies. We mean to emulate them in every way possible.”~Artemis
Huntresses: Miss Daria Mullen sans Miss Gillian Phelps. Ellie becomes a Huntress. There are three other Huntresses that aren’t in the story. It looks like there is going to be a series about Artemis’s Huntress friends.
I liked Charlie and Newton’s friendship . The story gives a little more insight into Charlie’s issues with Artemis. I feel like they have a, “ Though doth protest too much.”dynamic. They get to see different sides to each other in this story.
Linus and Arabella are in some of the book, so it was nice to get to see a little bit of them.
I liked Linus’s new butler Henson, a young retired war veteran. He isn’t the best at his job, but he tries.
Artemis’s lady’s maid Rose was awesome in the story. She is the niece of Wilson. Wilson is the valet of Charlie’s brother Philip Jonquil, the Earl of Lampton. Apparently, Wilson is supposed to be a legendary valet.
Ellie’s family is awful. They treat her terribly. Ellie’s mother and sister are embarrassing. They don’t know when to give up and start to come off as desperate. They criticize Ellie and tell her she is ruining things for the family when they are the embarrassment. Ellie’s sister Lillian is relentless and takes things to far trying to ensnare poor Newton. Lillian is very spiteful and vindictive.
Towards the end of the story, Artemis invites Ellie to spend the winter at Falstone Castle. I really want to see Ellie’s winter visit to Falstone Castle, so I hope some of that is shown in Charming Artemis. When I first read Best Laid-Plans, I wanted more out of the ending. I didn’t know if Ellie and Newton would be in any future books. It seems like Ellie and Newton will appear be in Charming Artemis.
I shipped Artemis and Charlie together in this book and wanted them to get a story. I learned that a lot of fans have been shipping the two together for some time. I was happy when found out that Charlie and Artemis are getting a book called Charming Artemis. It comes out October, 4. 2021. I’m excited for it. It looks like there will be a Huntress series too.
Before this book was released, I read the synopsis. The arrangement between Newton/Ellie reminded me of the arrangement between Daphne/Simon from Bridgerton, so I decided to read the novella. I liked the whole fake courtship trope and ended up enjoying the novella. I was curious about the side characters and if they had stories. I was glad to see that some of the side characters/characters mentioned did have books.
The book is told in dul pov and is a clean romance: just a few kisses.
Most of the story takes place in Bath the summer of 1817. This story takes place around a year after Loving Lieutenant Lancaster.
Newton Hughes (H) 21 is a recent graduate from Cambridge. For a long time Newton has dreamed of studying law and becoming a barrister. He would like to start pursuing a career in law. Unfortunately, Newton’s father does not approve of his son finding work because he views that as beneath them. Newton’s parents don’t understand why he wants to work when he can just live off of the families fortune. They want him to live a leisurely life and find a wife.
Newton’s best friend Charlie Jonquil, youngest brother of the Earl of Lampton, is on break from school so Newton’s parents suggest inviting him to Bath. They hope that Charlie will help Newton forget about pursuing this silly dream of his. Charlie has a brother that is a barrister and he would never discourage his friend from doing something that makes him happy.
Elfrida aka “Ellie” Napper (h) 19 is the youngest of three sisters. The Nappers made a few brief appearances in Loving Lieutenant Lancaster, but they were not given names. Ellie’s family is planning on going to Bath for the summer. They usually spend time in Bath because they can’t afford to go to London for the season. This will be the first year that Ellie is going to Bath with her family. It’s not going to be the leisurely trip she thought it would be. The Napper sisters don’t have much when it comes to a dowry. Ellie’s mother wants Ellie and her older sister Lillian to secure good matches while in Bath to help the family.
Mrs. Napper is still upset that the eldest daughter Beatrice married a “penniless nobody”. She doesn’t consider it a good marriage if it doesn’t socially and monetarily benefit the family. Mrs. Napper feels that Beatrice betrayed the family and will not let her other two daughters make the same mistake.
“Of course,” she said in a perfect imitation of her mother. Newton couldn’t help but laugh. “My parents have no sons. They have decided the purpose of their daughters is to improve their situation by marrying well. Of course, the definition of ‘well’ is limited to monetary gain and improvements and social standing. My older sister married a gentleman who had none of those things, but he loves her. She successfully resisted all my parents’ attempts to court someone they approved of. Lillian and I will not be so fortunate.”
The Nappers’ live in Shropshire and are neighbors to Linus Lancaster (retired from the Royal Navy, brother in law to the Duke of Kielder)and his new wife Arabella. Linus has become really close to Charlie Jonquil. In the past Mrs. Napper tried to have Lillian catch Charlie’s eye, but he wasn’t interested in her at all. Mrs. Napper finds out that Linus and Charlie will be in Bath at the same time. Also, Charlie’s good friend Newton Hughes will be there. Mrs. Napper plans to call on Mr. Lancaster as much as possible and use that connection for her daughters to get close to Charlie and Newton. Mr. Hughes is wealthy and important. Mrs. Napper, wants Ellie to try to catch Charlie’s eye and Lillian to try to catch Newton’s eye. Ellie has no interest in playing these games. Over the years, she has learned that it is easier to just keep her mouth shut and do what her parents want. Mrs. Napper warns Ellie to not mess things up for the family. Ellie’s mother is always criticizing and finding fault with her. While Ellie’s mom sees Lillian as the perfect compliant daughter. Off they go to Bath.
Linus’s youngest sister Artemis Lancaster (sister-in-law to Adam Boyce, the Duke of Kielder). happens to be in staying in Bath with Linus and his new wife. Artemis Lancaster and Charlie Jonquil play a prominent role in the story. Charlie isn’t thrilled about about Artemis being in Bath because the two haven’t gotten along ever since his mother threw a house party around a year ago. The party takes place in Loving Lieutenant Lancaster. Charlie has even taken to calling her “Miss Sham-Caster”. Newton doesn’t understand Charlie’s dislike for Artemis because he likes and gets along with her fine.
Charlie and Newton end up at Linus Lancaster’s house. Shortly after, the Nappers show up and Charlie isn’t thrilled about it. Newton and Charlie realize that Mrs. Napper is scheming.
“Any gentleman in possession of an income and familial connections learned early how to undermine unwanted matrimonial efforts without rudeness and how to tiptoe around traps and snares. Between the unexpected presence of Charlie’s sworn enemy and the pointed pursuit of the Nappers, this promised to be a most unusual sojourn in Bath.” ~Newton
Newton’s parents start hassling him to court Artemis Lancaster, but neither is interested. Ellie’s mother wants her to pursue Charlie (since her sister was unable to catch his eye), but neither are interested. Newton wants nothing to do with Lillian’s relentless pursuit. Artemis and Ellie hatch a plan for Ellie and Newton to fake a courtship. This way the parents will get off their backs. Charlie even agrees to be a part of the plan. Artemis, Charlie, Newton, and Ellie agree to spend a lot of time together in a group while in Bath. Newton and Ellie plan to show enough interest in each other to get their parents to back off, but not enough to be scandalous or cause whispers. Thus begins this interesting ruse. Newton and Ellie do develop a friendship and start to have feelings for each other, but they wonder if the other person feels the same way or if it’s just a part of the act. Together with the help of Artemis they learn to be braver and fight for the future that they want.
The story had a lot of great characters in it. I think Newton and Ellie make a good match. I feel that this story gives more insight into Artemis. Artemis is fierce. She is a force to be reckoned with and lives up to her namesake. It was nice to see Artemis take Ellie under her wing and help her to become braver. Artemis helped Newton out a lot. I liked the Huntresses that were introduced in the story. Artemis called her group of female friends the “Huntresses”.
“Huntresses?” Artemis nodded quite solemnly. “My ancient namesake had a band of huntresses, and they were absolutely everything young ladies ought to be permitted to be: fierce, strong, capable, and entirely in control of their own destinies. We mean to emulate them in every way possible.”~Artemis
Huntresses: Miss Daria Mullen sans Miss Gillian Phelps. Ellie becomes a Huntress. There are three other Huntresses that aren’t in the story. It looks like there is going to be a series about Artemis’s Huntress friends.
I liked Charlie and Newton’s friendship . The story gives a little more insight into Charlie’s issues with Artemis. I feel like they have a, “ Though doth protest too much.”dynamic. They get to see different sides to each other in this story.
Linus and Arabella are in some of the book, so it was nice to get to see a little bit of them.
I liked Linus’s new butler Henson, a young retired war veteran. He isn’t the best at his job, but he tries.
Artemis’s lady’s maid Rose was awesome in the story. She is the niece of Wilson. Wilson is the valet of Charlie’s brother Philip Jonquil, the Earl of Lampton. Apparently, Wilson is supposed to be a legendary valet.
Ellie’s family is awful. They treat her terribly. Ellie’s mother and sister are embarrassing. They don’t know when to give up and start to come off as desperate. They criticize Ellie and tell her she is ruining things for the family when they are the embarrassment. Ellie’s sister Lillian is relentless and takes things to far trying to ensnare poor Newton. Lillian is very spiteful and vindictive.
Towards the end of the story, Artemis invites Ellie to spend the winter at Falstone Castle. I really want to see Ellie’s winter visit to Falstone Castle, so I hope some of that is shown in Charming Artemis. When I first read Best Laid-Plans, I wanted more out of the ending. I didn’t know if Ellie and Newton would be in any future books. It seems like Ellie and Newton will appear be in Charming Artemis.
I shipped Artemis and Charlie together in this book and wanted them to get a story. I learned that a lot of fans have been shipping the two together for some time. I was happy when found out that Charlie and Artemis are getting a book called Charming Artemis. It comes out October, 4. 2021. I’m excited for it. It looks like there will be a Huntress series too.
February 5, 2021
Newton Hughes has long dreamed of pursuing a career in law, an acceptable choice for a gentleman of status and wealth. His parents, however, disapprove of his ambition, urging him instead to take his rightful place as a gentleman of leisure—with a suitable wife of their choosing, of course.
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love.
I was surprised to find this little standalone book by Sarah M. Eden is actually tied to a couple of her series. The main one of interest for me is The Jonquil Brothers, but this is also tied to The Lancaster Family series as well. I've been eagerly awaiting the day that the 7th Jonquil Brothers book will be published and I wasn't finding any info on it. Then I discovered that it's actually also the 5th book in The Lancaster Family series and that's how it's listed here on Goodreads. I'm really excited to finally have found it and that it will be published this year!
So obviously these two series have been tied to each other for a long while. I've never read the Lancaster series, but I plan to get to that one eventually. That brings us to this book. This is a standalone with main characters who are not a part of either of those series, but it acts as kind of as a bridge between those two series with Charlie Jonquil and Artemis Lancaster as supporting characters. Charlie and Artemis have known each other their whole lives as their families are close, but they can't stand each other...or at least that's what they say. In this book they help out friends, Ellie and Newton who are being pushed by their families to court people they do not wish to court.
I thought this was a fun story with very likable characters. It was easy to sympathize with Ellie's plight. Her family was truly awful to her and often accused her of doing the very things they were doing. Newton was a great love interest and I enjoyed seeing their romance blossom. I would have liked an epilogue with a little more at the end, with some insight into how Newton's family receives Ellie as his betrothed, but maybe we will get more of that in the book about Charlie and Artemis.
Overall this was a great read, and I liked it better than some of Eden's longer books that are part of The Jonquil Brothers series.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
Ellie Napper would like nothing more than for her parents to abandon their incessant efforts to marry her off to the greatest possible advantage. Her lack of matrimonial enthusiasm drives her family mad, but she refuses to feign frivolity in order to make herself more palatable to potential suitors.
When Ellie and Newton are introduced through their mutual acquaintance, Charlie Jonquil, they commiserate over their shared plight. In desperation, they hatch a plan: Ellie and Newton will feign an interest in each other—enough to convince their parents not to push them toward unwanted matches but not enough to cause whispers or expectations. Their plot quickly spirals out of control, but the greatest complication is the one they didn’t see coming: their plan never included falling in love.
I was surprised to find this little standalone book by Sarah M. Eden is actually tied to a couple of her series. The main one of interest for me is The Jonquil Brothers, but this is also tied to The Lancaster Family series as well. I've been eagerly awaiting the day that the 7th Jonquil Brothers book will be published and I wasn't finding any info on it. Then I discovered that it's actually also the 5th book in The Lancaster Family series and that's how it's listed here on Goodreads. I'm really excited to finally have found it and that it will be published this year!
So obviously these two series have been tied to each other for a long while. I've never read the Lancaster series, but I plan to get to that one eventually. That brings us to this book. This is a standalone with main characters who are not a part of either of those series, but it acts as kind of as a bridge between those two series with Charlie Jonquil and Artemis Lancaster as supporting characters. Charlie and Artemis have known each other their whole lives as their families are close, but they can't stand each other...or at least that's what they say. In this book they help out friends, Ellie and Newton who are being pushed by their families to court people they do not wish to court.
I thought this was a fun story with very likable characters. It was easy to sympathize with Ellie's plight. Her family was truly awful to her and often accused her of doing the very things they were doing. Newton was a great love interest and I enjoyed seeing their romance blossom. I would have liked an epilogue with a little more at the end, with some insight into how Newton's family receives Ellie as his betrothed, but maybe we will get more of that in the book about Charlie and Artemis.
Overall this was a great read, and I liked it better than some of Eden's longer books that are part of The Jonquil Brothers series.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
April 8, 2025
I started to read this book for a book club with my friends and it's not something I probably would have picked out myself, but I'm so glad that I had a reason to read it!! I'm not generally one to read romances, but I loved this one! I think I might have to start reading more regency romance like this one!! It reminded me a lot of pride and prejudice (which I love) and all of the relationships, plots, and planning were just so light hearted and cute. I love to see books that just feel wholesome! It was so good and I recommend it to anyone who wants a quick happy read. :)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 538 reviews