Irish teenager Barry O’Neill is journeying to New York on the Titanic’s fateful maiden voyage. He’s homesick and worried about the Flynn boys traveling in steerage, who have threatened to throw him overboard. Little does Barry know that a struggle with the Flynns is the least of the dangers that await him. This suspenseful story is based on the true and terrible events that occurred as the Titanic sank one hundred years ago.
Anne Evelyn Bunting, better known as Eve Bunting, is an author with more than 250 books. Her books are diverse in age groups, from picture books to chapter books, and topic, ranging from Thanksgiving to riots in Los Angeles. Eve Bunting has won several awards for her works.
Bunting went to school in Ireland and grew up with storytelling. In Ireland, “There used to be Shanachies… the shanachie was a storyteller who went from house to house telling his tales of ghosts and fairies, of old Irish heroes and battles still to be won. Maybe I’m a bit of a Shanchie myself, telling stories to anyone who will listen.” This storytelling began as an inspiration for Bunting and continues with her work.
In 1958, Bunting moved to the United States with her husband and three children. A few years later, Bunting enrolled in a community college writing course. She felt the desire to write about her heritage. Bunting has taught writing classes at UCLA. She now lives in Pasadena, California.
3 stars. I had this book on my TBR for a while, found it for sale at my local library, and started reading it to see if I enjoyed it enough to purchase it. I was invested enough by 40% to buy it. In the end, though, I was somewhat disappointed…
Let’s start at the beginning. I was super intrigued with the very Irish setting, highlighting the poor Irish vs rich Irish (aka English-with-Irish-blood and full-blooded Irish). Although this is a Titanic story, it’s really only Titanic in that it HAPPENS to take place on the Titanic. The focus of the story is not the sinking of the Titanic but the troubles of Ireland, represented in the Flynn siblings and Barry O’Neill.
The characters were not my favourite. Barry struck me as extremely immature and weak for a 15-year-old boy in 1914. He was also a little bit dumb and very superstitious. On the other hand, he had a kind heart and honestly faced the truth. I did like the girls—they were very decent. The Flynn boys I didn’t feel much for one way or another but I did like their parents somehow, and Barry’s grandparents. Col. Sapper started out awful and ended up with me saluting him tearfully because he was a gentleman who knew how to die like a Britisher. Mrs. Adair I couldn’t either like or hate but I felt sorry for her little girl. And I was NOT impressed with how they presented Capt. Smith. It just didn’t ring true to who he is reported to have been. Finally, the Englishman in charge of Barry whose name escapes me was a snobby pipsqueak and the steward was cool but obviously touched in the head. Frankly, the only likeable people on board were the Irish girls. That’s it.
Okay, and then the plot. There were issues. 1. It was a constant refrain of Barry being scared of the Flynn boys but still sneaking down to third class anyways. (Did I mention he was dumb??) So I’m glad he got his glove but after he got it why did he go back?? And yeah he had to warn Pegrine or whatever her name was but he could have written a note, as he admits himself. That whole romance was super silly and unneeded and immature. Strike one. 2. The walkthrough with Capt. Smith would have been cool if Capt. Smith had been well done—which he wasn’t. Strike two. 3. I know this is a Titanic book but the whole point of Titanic is that the tragedy was unexpected and sudden. That is what is generally expected of Titanic novels—not the over-foreshadowing so strong that it’s almost a “well duh, obviously” when the ship actually does sink. The foreshadowing would have been cool if it had stopped with Howard but the steward went way overboard and just got weird and creepy. Strike three. 4. For bonus points, Mrs. Adair. I thought she was a real person because of how strongly her situation was presented and was very irritated to discover she wasn’t and I had gone through all that drama and the struggle between deciding if she was good or bad, for nothing. And we only ever got HER side of the story. I needed her husband's and daughter's side too for an educated decision! Extra strike.
There was no emotion from me when the ship actually sank because I had been expecting it so hard for so long. Instead of falling in love with the characters and grieving for their humanity I looked forwards to getting rid of them, which effectively destroys the point of a Titanic novel.
Finally, to finish in style, the story ends very abruptly with zero resolution. Now, after all the trauma they put us through, Titanic stories are basically obligated to have a LITTLE bit of a happy ending. Not so here. I was so irritated I physically tossed the book aside.
The redeeming part of this novel and what made me give it three stars, was the Irish and lower class part which I spoke of in the beginning, because that was very unique. It was hard, of course, to see how they were mistreated. The scene where P. interacts with the Colonel actually hurt me, and Johnny’s story was difficult to accept because it was painful. But it was definitely true and I appreciate the POV being presented to me.
Also, as much as the story and characters bugged me, I was left with the reminder that there MAY have been people like them aboard the Titanic. Stories are based on real life, book characters draw inspiration from living souls. There may have been a Barry, a Flynn family, a Colonel Sapper lost when the Titanic sank that fateful April night.
So, overall… was it epic? No. It was arguably one of the worst Titanic novels I’ve read. Even I Survived the Sinking of the Titanic was better. In fact, I kept comparing this story, to its great detriment, with Titanic Crossing, which I found myself liking more and more in contrast. However, it does have value as an Irish story, if not a Titanic one, and I mean to reread it sometime and see if I like it better.
*updated review + content list to come upon reread*
I picked up this novel along with The Dressmaker in the gift shop in the Titanic Museum in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. Having just seen so many artifacts and hearing about all the different people whose lives were devastated by the sinking of Titanic I wanted to hear more. This book was as emotional for me as it was walking through the museum.
I am Irish and my extended family is quite large, so I knew I would enjoy reading about Irish kids aboard the Titanic. It felt as if they could be my kin. Barry's story brought me aboard the Titanic as a first-class passenger as he left Ireland and his grandparents behind to go live with his parents, who had virtually no relationship with. His homesickness brought him to speak with only other passages from his hometown, the Flynn's . As he fought the brothers and sought after Pegeen I felt as I was inside the story myself.
When they didn't let him aboard a lifeboat I found myself yelling "he's only 15!" Iwith tears coming down my face. This book is more of a middle school /young adult read, but I believe people of all ages would be touched by this story of tragedy.
Worst Titanic book I ever read: the very little plot that there was, had superstitions and rude underhanded behaviours and was only about the boat. And despite the author's assurance of research of history...there was very little of interest to be had in this book. :P Besides that, I'm not sure if the storyteller took poetic licence with the actual historical characters in the book but it made me hate them entirely. Captain Smith was an idiot and Mrs. Adair was made at least in this story to be a vile woman in appearances (there may be some truth to both parts but I was disgusted with the way they were portrayed).
I hated the superstitions...a fortune teller steward, premonitions and comparisons of the ship Titan to Titanic...I believe for the most part historians believe most all the world thought this boat unsinkable and the slight hint of "premonitions" to only took away from the story.
The "main plot" is about a young boy, Barry and a young man who is his companion taking him to see Barry's parents whom he's never met in America (Barry has spent his life in boarding schools and spending his holiday's in Ireland with his grandparents). Travelling on the boat are 2 scallywag boys and their sister from Barry's hometown - they are in steerage while Barry travels first class. This was the only bit of interest in the entire book, in my opinion, was that of the class differences.
The little bit of romance included was ridiculous and unrealistic - first you think they are enemies then all of a sudden they are "in love" ...and only because they are on a ship that is going down. :/ No emotions or reasoning other than that. In my opinion that is friendship not love.
Besides that the boy is rude and calls one of the gentleman "Sapp" in a disrespctful manner, carries a knife to ward against the scallywag boys on board to defend himself, and sneaks away all the time from his companion. There were a few things that were good but this book had no action whatsoever and no real plot...I've read far better Titanic books and cannot believe this book was awarded best of 1996...there must not have been very many good books written that year. :P
I recommend no one waste their time bothering with this uninformative, unexciting read.
This book has put me off from ever reading another book about the Titanic, I think. I realized that I will always know the ending for these - the boat always goes down in the end and people will live and die according the the author's tastes. :/ I know enough about this experience and am tired of author's romanticizing something so tragic.
Overall, great book. It was interesting and I couldn't stop reading. Few problems. Only two to three chapters were actually talking about the Titanic sinking, it was very fast paced. The ending was a little rough too. I ended weirdly, leaving me with a lot of questions, but still an enjoyable story.
I liked it a little because it was about the Titanic and I enjoy reading about that ship. The characters weren't anything special. I really did not like how there was an underlying "something bad is going to happen to the ship" pretty much the whole time, right from the very beginning. Unrealistic and a bit obnoxious. If the characters and every move they made weren't foreshadowing the sinking every other sentence then it would have been better.
Content: a couple fights between characters, the sinking of the Titanic, and a couple uses of g*sh and d*mn.
I went through a stage in elementary school where I was obsessed with all things related to the Titanic. I read every book I could find, both fiction and non-fiction. I don't remember tons about this book other than wanting to own it, and not being able to get it through the book order. It was a sad day for me... When I finally got a chance to read it, I remember really liking it, but now I don't remember if that was because the book was any good, or if I was just in love with it because it talked about the Titanic.
SOS Titanic is a fictional account of the sinking of Titanic, with some factual information and characters included. I mostly enjoyed the book. I had to reread some portions as there were lots of sentence fragments which took me out of the story to try to figure out the meanings. There were two swear words near the end of the book, which honestly could have been left out. The point could have been made in a different way, especially considering this book is marketed for children.
This is probably one of the worst books I have ever read. The author took a genuinley interesting subject and added elements that ruined it. Titanic and witch craft do not go together. Plus the ship sinking was forshadowed so much that a five year old wou,d pick up on it. Not a good book, I don't reccommend the agony of this story to anyone.
The stories of the Titanic always grab my attention,so when I saw this in my library sale, I decided to read it. To my surprise, it really was a story about the class differences in Ireland with the setting moving from Ireland and continuing aboard the doomed ship. Everything about the Titanic reinforced place of a person's station in life. The more money,the higher social status, the much much better rooms, food, freedom of movement, service and servants,right down to the number of lifeboats for upper class.The people in steerage were barely considered worthy of saving. The drama on ship was depicted in a horrifying way, the ending was both implausible and unsettled. yet, I found this book interesting. many of the characters were entertaining and sprang to life within the pages.
This has become my favorite guilty pleasure in terms of a book I could read over and over again without it ever getting boring. The plot is simple and one typically used when representing the Titanic in books and movies (friends and lovers being torn apart due to the sinking of the Titanic... @leonardodicaprio). But what really makes this book something I could continuously read out of pleasure is the characters. The ending is one that has left me heartbroken, just as many sad books have done in the past, but this book tears the characters apart, turning all of the characters into heroes in the end and then tearing them apart, making it harder to let them go. Its a touching story about the separation between social classes and them coming together when they know the end if near, showing their true selves with one another and just trying to save each other, but as the story shows, not everyone can be saved.
Fifteen-year-old Barry O'Neil is traveling from Ireland to America on the maiden voyage of the Titanic. Barry is accompanied by an adult chaperon, Mr. Scollins, who has a very weak stomach for sea traveling, which allows Barry some freedom to explore the ship where he meets many interesting people. Two other young people from Barry’s small Irish village, brother and sister Frank and Peegan Flynn, have also boarded the Titanic, although they are not as privileged of passengers as Barry. Frank and Peegan are “Third Class” while Barry is a “First Class” passenger. On this voyage Barry becomes aware of the separations between the classes and struggles to accept the rules regarding them. When the iceberg hits, will Barry be able to save Frank and Peegan despite their differences?
SOS Titanic is an excellent historical resource. Bunting did a lot of research about what the Titanic looked like, who was on board, and exactly how and why it sank. It would be great social studies or research project resource.
The book follows the story of fifteen year old, first class passenger Barry and his developing relationship with steerage passenger and developing love interest Pegeen. The two teens must face the social confines that affect them both while trying to survive the horrific sinking of the "unsinkable" Titanic. Foreshadowing is heavy in this book, and the social themes could be further developed in the larger classroom.
Decent book. The characters were pretty fun. Watley's story was... unhinged, but I enjoyed it, personally. Not 100% sure what happened at the end there, though- did he die or not?
Anyway *picks up a stack of papers* I've got notes. On historical accuracy, that is, because God forbid I don't get unnecessarily in depth about every historical detail.
It does mention the whole speed issue (trying to get to NYC by Tuesday) but it doesn't dwell on it too much. So I appreciate that.
It's very fun that it brings up Futility (and Howard is an entertaining character overall, even if he is largely a plot device).
Bride and Phillips!! They were incredible. Bride calling Phillips "Sparks" was fun. And I'm so glad we got to see Bride at the end there.
It slipped in the bit about the binoculars in the crow's nest, which I enjoyed. It did give an incorrect explanation (I guess it didn't want to go through all the stuff about Wilde coming in last minute and changing the whole officers lineup), but it is a children's book, so I won't be too picky.
Apparently the main kid (I've already forgotten his name, apologies) could hear the watertight compartments closing? I'm honestly not sure whether that's accurate, but it was an interesting detail.
The last bit was crammed with cameos of my favorite historical figures, haha. We got Hartley and his band (and they played "Autumn"! which was a hymn in this one), Murdoch was there for a minute (I love the detail that he let some men into the lifeboats, and it DIDN'T have the thing with him maybe-maybe not shooting himself!), Andrews was mentioned, the Californian (albeit not by name) made an appearance. The main kid also saw a man throwing chairs overboard- Joughin, perhaps? Or it was accidental.
"The cold was like a thousand knives," fiction books' favorite way to refer to the cold of the water. If memory serves, we have Lightoller to thank for that quote. Speaking of, we got to see Lights instructing them all to lean back and forth on Collapsible B! That was cool.
Fun book. I came for my favorite historical figures, but couldn't help but be entertained by the characters created by Bunting. Frank's moment at the end was especially heart wrenching. Well done.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
*S.O.S. Titanic* is a touching historical fiction story based on the sinking of the Titanic that occurred over one hundred years ago. Barry, an Irish teenager, travels to New York feeling homesick but is worried about the Flynn boys traveling with him. However, it would appear later on that this was the least of the dangers ahead. This story highlights the themes of community and human connection during a crisis, courage and resilience, and explores the separation and differences of social classes in a unique and truthful way. This book resonates with those who are interested or curious about the tragedy that is the sinking of this shop and the loss of several people who were on it as it sank.
The book accurately shows how much suffering many people had to go through as the Titanic gradually sank, leading the the death of many others. The characters demonstrate great determination to survive, a display of the human spirit in unfavorable situations, and emphasize how bonding with one another can be crucial for survival and coping with hardships; and the book does a great job portraying how the sinking impacted people from different social statuses. Although, the writing may have a few flaws, if you're curious about how much of an impact the Titanic's sinking was and how much it affected many people, then I would gladly recommend reading this book. I believe many people out there would be entertained or touched by this narrative.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Story of a young boy named Barry, who's from Ireland and traveling to New York on the maiden voyage of the RMS Titanic. I read this because I'm interested in all things Titanic, but this story was sadly so-so. All the foreshadowing was a bit over the top, especially with the fortune teller steward, the comparisons to the Titan so by the second half it's so obvious what was going to happen. So, I think anyone who is reading this book and doesn't know the story would want to be at least a little shocked by the unexpected and sudden turn of events. The characters were okay at best, none of them really likeable except maybe for Barry, the writing too choppy and didn't flow well and the ending rather abrupt. I'm sure there are plenty of good books out there that are about the Titanic with fictional characters, but this isn't one of them.
If possible, I would rate this book 0.1 stars. This book, the S.O.S. Titanic was monotonous. To start, my favorite part was when the main character, Barry, buys a knife, then gets jumped and beat up, but doesn't even use the knife he bought because he was scared. This book was very predictable and boring. Honestly, this is a waste of money and pure junk. I feel bad honestly for Eve Bunting and her friends for her lack of excitement and talent. This is not for kids because it teaches them lying skills, how to kill yourself, and cusses. If you want your child to grow up like Barry and cuss, let your child read this book.
Barry O'Neill is leaving his grandparents in Ireland to go to America to join his parents. He is traveling in first class with Mr. Scollins, hired to accompany Barry on the trip. As he is boarding, he spots the Flynn boys, the neighborhood bullies who have terrorized him, boarding the ship with their sister, Pegeen. Barry is assured that because he's in first class, he'll never see the steerage passengers. But he is drawn to their lively world and soon finds himself attracted to Pegeen. When the ship begins to sink, Barry desperately tries to reach her, though the injustices of class preference are everywhere.
S.O.S. Titanic is the story of an Irish boy traveling across the Atlantic Ocean on the RMS Titanic. Here he meets up with old friends and enemies aboard the biggest vessel of their time. But all things go wrong when the ship collides with an iceberg. S.O.S. Titanic is a great read for fans of historical fiction, including many elements of history along with several additional story points to keep the story interesting all the way through. Overall, it was a good book
Pretty heavy on the “foreshadowing”, the Titanic sank about 80 years prior to the book, we knew it was going to happen. We didn’t need the main character worried, and a creepy fortune-telling steward, and someone who read about the Titan, AND a bunch of discarded iceberg messages…. We got it. We knew it was coming.
OH MY GOODNESS! I was so tense throughout the book and I loved this book! It was SO good! You should definitely read this if you like learning about the Titanic. It definitely puts a different look on the story.
An interesting enough book for upper elementary students. The story moves fast enough but takes a while to get to the actual sinking. Would have liked to have seen more detail about the sinking and struggle for survival.
I liked the heterosexual romance in this book. Throughout the whole book, it was really interesting. Also, since I read a lot of books for my English class, my teacher said that I could read for fun. I am very excited.
I liked that it was a quick read, easy to follow. It was, of course, sad because it was the Titanic. There were a couple unbelievable parts. And there were some parts I wish had more of a description. But I liked it.