I've read two of Iain Pears's doughtier historical novels, An Instance of the Fingerpost and The Dream of Scipio, and liked them very much indeed; I was a whole lot less enamored of his novel The Portrait but, hey, that's the way these things work. His Stone's Fall is a novel I'm planning to read soon.
Whatsoever, I thought it might be fun to try one of his lighthearted Jonathan Argyll mysteries set in the art-dealing and -collecting world. And now, to be honest, I wish I hadn't.
To start with the positive: I loved the bitchy art-world milieu. Almost without exception, the professional artists and art dealers whom I know are quite delightful people who, far from backstabbing each other, go out of their way to help each other. At the same time, while nattering with them, it's been perfectly evident to me that there is an undercurrent of nastiness in the art-dealer world. Pears captures, I think, this ambience very well -- and why shouldn't he, since this is his professional field?
Where the novel fell down, I felt, was in that happy lightheartedness. There was, for this particular reader, something immensely selfconscious about all the breezy flippancy. Yes, there were some great bons mots. But far, far too often I was wishing that Pears would stop assuming he was a genius who could toss off a mystery novel jus' like that and start realizing that there's just as much skill and application required to write a good tec as when you're writing something more momentous, like one of his historical novels. To say the writing in The Bernini Bust is slapdash is to be a tad charitable. Most of the characters are straight out of central casting, defined by one or at most two characteristics -- like the main LA cop, who's defined by his gum disease and his designer stubble.
Just to annoy, the solution to the murder mystery is achieved not through yer standard ratiocination, as per the Golden Age, but through the setting of a trap in order to snare the guilty party.
I'm absolutely certain that a billion or more Goodreaders do sincerely love the Jonathan Argyll series, but for me this just did not work. If you've had a happier experience with the Jonathan Argyll series, please by all means tell me so in the comments.