This was a hard book for me to rate. I vacillated between four and five stars with every poem and it’s “commentary” I read. 85 of them. There are some great poems here. I guess the hard part was the “commentary”, following each. I don’t want to use the word boring, but perhaps overdone were some of them, which tends to make five stars only four point two.
This is an amazing book! One has the pleasure of being introduced to a wide range of contemporary American poetry and of being gifted with detailed analysis by each respective poet re his process for each poem. I read first for the pleasure of the diction, then re-read each poem to see where and how the nuts and bolts were holding the thing together, as per the poet's explanation. Very instructive, not crazily academic - a fun read!