I gave this an above average rating because its one of the few biographies of one of USA's most important military leaders in WW 2. Not much has been written about him, and all we get from the other WW 2 books is that he was an "anglophobe" or "Tough as Nails" or hard to get along with. This book provides some much needed detail and personal background.
Buell gives us some surprising facts, like:
1) George Marshall forced King to circle the airfield on the way to Casablanca in Jan 1943, so Marshall could land first. It seems Marshall "out-ranked" King, and Marshall insisted that his airplane land first.
2) Henry Stimson and King both disliked each other intensely.
3) King wasn't really sold on Sledgehammer in 1942, but loyally supported Marshall in July 1942, because he wanted the Army's help in the upcoming Guadalcanal invasion.
4) Although King was grateful to FDR for promoting him, he regarded FDR as a "slippery customer" who couldn't be counted on to tell the truth.
5) King thought the USSR would do 9/10 of the fighting against Germany, and focused on the Pacific War after the Invasion of North Africa.
6) The lack of convoys on the US Coast in 1942 was due to a lack of destroyers and was directly traceable to FDR's refusal to build DE's prior to Pearl Harbor. In fact, even in 1942, FDR gave shipping and Landing craft priority. The result is only 50 DE's were laid down before Nov 1st, 1942.
7) King didn't think the invasion of Japan was necessary and dubious about the A-Bomb. In his opinion Blockade and conventional bombing were enough.
8) FDR's Unconditional Surrender policy was idiotic - per King. But he didn't consider it his place to push the matter.
So, the book has plenty to chew on. Strangely, King's hatred of MacArthur is never explained or discussed. His dislike for the General was so uncontrollable, that Marshall had to rebuke him in JSC meetings several times. Yet Buell says nothing. Nor does he go into King's so-called "anglo-phobia".