As I mentioned in my previous review of Mr. Hicks' work and opinion of him, I believe he is the modern-day American Homer. I can't say enough how I felt this story sent me back to my reading of the literary work depicting the Trojan war and 10 year journey afterwards of Odysseus.
The plot is almost flawless except for the lack of foresight on Military technology. For example we use robotics now to explore underground caves, in a thousand years are we really sending live humans into god-knows-what? I had an issue reading of the Marine company rushing into a perceived alien stronghold, when we have drones that can do that now.
*SPOILER ALERT*
The real fundamental issue I personally had with this story at it's conclusion was, it didn't seem as though all the villains got their just desserts. Not just the Kreelans, whom I perceived as nothing more than Blue-skinned alien nazi-women, but the megalomaniac human antagonist also. Thorella got off easy if you ask me. For now I will concentrate on the Kreelans as to me they represented a futuristic version of one of Mankind's greatest enemies, the Nazis from World War II.
To make my case, I came up with this analogy. It was as if a futuristic male Anne Frank was captured by the futuristic Nazis. The Nazis decide to allow him to prove his worth. So under the cruel tutelage of let's say the futuristic version of Gille, for those of you that don't know was a SS commander, proves that he's not a dog.
Now keep in mind this SS commander equivalent is the same being that killed Reza's (Futuristic Anne Frank) family. Not only did this individual do it once but years later when he has a surrogate mother and father type does it again.
So years later Anne Frank's male equivalent proves to the Nazis he's human or not an animal thus having a soul and is released by Hitler because he refuses to kill his own kind. He (Frank) returns to the allies and enlists in the Marines. Is years later branded as a traitor, finds out he has a child with the female version of Joseph Goebels, who is laying on her death bed and if dies ends the existence of this self-righteous but genocidal empire. Note also it mentions in the story how this empire extinguished countless numbers of sentient races. So Reza (Anne Frank counterpart) saves the Kreelans (nazis) from doom because he fell in love with the niece of the Woman who butchered his mother, father, surrogate mother and surrogate father. In saving the Kreelans (alien Nazis) they are ascended into another dimension or heaven itself, the author never elaborates, as the best I can interpret, Angels.
That about summarizes my fundamental discrepancy with the outcome of this story. However it is the author's prerogative to write what he wants and write it pretty damn well, I might add. I just came away from this story feeling like the lowly humans fighting for their right to exist against a superior, brutal and really there's no tap-dancing around it evil empire, didn't get real justice. Real justice would have been the Kreelans actually getting wiped out because they were murderous, genocidal maniacs in their own right not receiving what is interpreted as eternal salvation. To say they, not the humans deserved some sort of "ascension" into heaven or somewhere glorious goes against a lot more than what I consider right or wrong. Not only that but the main character having a serious case of Stockholm syndrome, with not just captors but murderers of billions, especially his family. Also I'd like to add, at anytime writing this did the author maybe think that to put the Kreelans in a better light, have the Kreelans offer aid to the humans whom they utterly decimated worlds upon end? He had Reza and the empress appear to Nicole, could they not offer something more than a necklace for her to remember them by. I guess it was too much to ask of an advanced race to at least admit they were wrong and offer some atonement. It wasn't like they broke a trade agreement and embezzled money from the humans. They waged a century long holocaust against them. But I guess even an apology was below them as well.
I will continue to read and follow Hicks as even though I disagree with what he did, I believe there was no agenda in his work just that, it left me empty and confused. As a father and veteran I couldn't accept this as right. Then again, what is right isn't always how things go I get that. Just in my personal beliefs, if we're going to toy with the notion of there being a supreme being, then I have to believe no matter what denomination you are, that there is a special place in hell for what these Kreelans represent. However I was enthralled for the majority of the ride and if anything, the ending was at least somewhat original even if I didn't agree.