What do you think?
Rate this book
Romance in the Rockies #1
A Lady in Defiance
HIS TOWN. HER GOD. LET THE BATTLE BEGIN.
Charles McIntyre owns everything and everyone in the lawless, godless mining town of Defiance. When three good, Christian sisters from his beloved South show up stranded, alone, and offering to open a "nice" hotel, he is intrigued enough to let them stay...especially since he sees feisty middle sister Naomi as a possible conquest. But Naomi, angry with God for widowing her, wants no part of Defiance or the saloon-owning, prostitute-keeping Mr. McIntyre. It would seem, however, that God has gone to elaborate lengths to bring them together. The question is, "Why?" Does God really have a plan for each and every life?
Written with gritty, but not gratuitous, realism uncharacteristic of historical Christian fiction, A Lady in Defiance gives a nod to both Pride and Prejudice and Redeeming Love. Based on true events, it is also an ensemble piece that deftly weaves together the relationships of the three sisters and the rowdy residents of Defiance.
Book One of the best-selling Romance in the Rockies series, A Lady in Defiance is written reminiscent of longstanding western fiction classics.
"Heather Blanton is blessed with a natural storytelling ability, an "old soul" wisdom, and wide expansive heart. Her characters are vividly drawn, and in the western settings where life can be hard, over quickly, and seemingly without meaning, she reveals Larger Hands holding everyone and everything together." MARK RICHARD, EXECUTIVE PRODUCER, AMC'S HELL ON WHEELS, and PEN/ERNEST HEMINGWAY AWARD WINNER ...
Charles McIntyre owns everything and everyone in the lawless, godless mining town of Defiance. When three good, Christian sisters from his beloved South show up stranded, alone, and offering to open a "nice" hotel, he is intrigued enough to let them stay...especially since he sees feisty middle sister Naomi as a possible conquest. But Naomi, angry with God for widowing her, wants no part of Defiance or the saloon-owning, prostitute-keeping Mr. McIntyre. It would seem, however, that God has gone to elaborate lengths to bring them together. The question is, "Why?" Does God really have a plan for each and every life?
Written with gritty, but not gratuitous, realism uncharacteristic of historical Christian fiction, A Lady in Defiance gives a nod to both Pride and Prejudice and Redeeming Love. Based on true events, it is also an ensemble piece that deftly weaves together the relationships of the three sisters and the rowdy residents of Defiance.
Book One of the best-selling Romance in the Rockies series, A Lady in Defiance is written reminiscent of longstanding western fiction classics.
"Heather Blanton is blessed with a natural storytelling ability, an "old soul" wisdom, and wide expansive heart. Her characters are vividly drawn, and in the western settings where life can be hard, over quickly, and seemingly without meaning, she reveals Larger Hands holding everyone and everything together." MARK RICHARD, EXECUTIVE PRODUCER, AMC'S HELL ON WHEELS, and PEN/ERNEST HEMINGWAY AWARD WINNER ...
376 pages, Paperback
First published March 10, 2012
266 people are currently reading
1196 people want to read
About the author
Heather Blanton
74 books299 followers“Heather Blanton is blessed with a natural storytelling ability, an ‘old soul’ wisdom, and wide expansive heart. Her characters are vividly drawn, and in the western settings where life can be hard, over quickly, and seemingly without meaning, she reveals Larger Hands holding everyone and everything together.”
MARK RICHARD, EXECUTIVE PRODUCER, AMC’S HELL ON WHEELS, and PEN/ERNEST HEMINGWAY AWARD WINNER
I write Christian Historical Western Romance. Yes, that often entails the use of firearms in a threatening manner. Sometimes there are fistfights. There may even be politically incorrect but historically accurate language. But also, there is always an inspirational message and strong allusions (at least) to the gospel.
A former journalist, I am an avid researcher and endeavor to skillfully weave truth in among fictional story lines. I love exploring the American West, especially ghost towns and museums. I have walked parts of the Oregon Trail, ridden horses through the Rockies, climbed to the top of Independence Rock, and even held an outlaw's note in my hand.
I grew up in the mountains of Western North Carolina on a steady diet of Bonanza, Gunsmoke, and John Wayne Westerns. My most fond childhood memory is of sitting next to my daddy, munching on popcorn, and watching Lucas McCain unload that Winchester! My daddy also taught me to shoot and, trust me, I can sew buttons on with my rifle.
I can be reached several different ways:
http://ladiesindefiance.com/
https://www.facebook.com/authorheathe...
https://twitter.com/heatherfblanton
https://www.pinterest.com/heatherfbla...
I am a proud member of Western Writers of America.
My novels are all Christian Western Romance because this is the genre that lets me write about strong, pioneer women and men who struggle to find God and then live out their faith in real ways. Like good old fashioned Westerns, there is always justice, a moral message, American values, lots of high adventure, unexpected plot twists, and more than a touch of suspense. Of course, romance is always a strong element in my stories because it is such a beautiful gift from God and a perfect reflection of how he loves us: sacrificially and lavishly. My stories aren’t preachy or cheesy, but I hope they are inspirational, heart-warming, realistic, illuminating, and glorifying to God.
MARK RICHARD, EXECUTIVE PRODUCER, AMC’S HELL ON WHEELS, and PEN/ERNEST HEMINGWAY AWARD WINNER
I write Christian Historical Western Romance. Yes, that often entails the use of firearms in a threatening manner. Sometimes there are fistfights. There may even be politically incorrect but historically accurate language. But also, there is always an inspirational message and strong allusions (at least) to the gospel.
A former journalist, I am an avid researcher and endeavor to skillfully weave truth in among fictional story lines. I love exploring the American West, especially ghost towns and museums. I have walked parts of the Oregon Trail, ridden horses through the Rockies, climbed to the top of Independence Rock, and even held an outlaw's note in my hand.
I grew up in the mountains of Western North Carolina on a steady diet of Bonanza, Gunsmoke, and John Wayne Westerns. My most fond childhood memory is of sitting next to my daddy, munching on popcorn, and watching Lucas McCain unload that Winchester! My daddy also taught me to shoot and, trust me, I can sew buttons on with my rifle.
I can be reached several different ways:
http://ladiesindefiance.com/
https://www.facebook.com/authorheathe...
https://twitter.com/heatherfblanton
https://www.pinterest.com/heatherfbla...
I am a proud member of Western Writers of America.
My novels are all Christian Western Romance because this is the genre that lets me write about strong, pioneer women and men who struggle to find God and then live out their faith in real ways. Like good old fashioned Westerns, there is always justice, a moral message, American values, lots of high adventure, unexpected plot twists, and more than a touch of suspense. Of course, romance is always a strong element in my stories because it is such a beautiful gift from God and a perfect reflection of how he loves us: sacrificially and lavishly. My stories aren’t preachy or cheesy, but I hope they are inspirational, heart-warming, realistic, illuminating, and glorifying to God.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 169 reviews
March 11, 2016
Not a typical review, but my thoughts...
I have heard numerous people NOT want to read this book because of the inclusion of prostitution, gambling, alcohol, etc. that is woven into this story. I would counter that yes, it is included into the plot to further the story and not to be gratuitous in any way. I would also say, that for as much as this "negative" element is in this book, there is twice as much of a Christian message involved as well. There are Bible verses quoted, and nearly every chapter has prayer, God, and the salvation message as well. There is more of a Christian message in this book than in any traditionally published book that I've read, through one of the big Christian book publishers. I believe one of the reasons the author self-published this book was so she could include as much "God stuff" as she wanted to and not be restricted.
I shared this book with my 83 year old Catholic aunt and she can not wait to read books two and three in this series. She was not offended by it in any way and I know she received much more out of it than just a good story.
I have heard numerous people NOT want to read this book because of the inclusion of prostitution, gambling, alcohol, etc. that is woven into this story. I would counter that yes, it is included into the plot to further the story and not to be gratuitous in any way. I would also say, that for as much as this "negative" element is in this book, there is twice as much of a Christian message involved as well. There are Bible verses quoted, and nearly every chapter has prayer, God, and the salvation message as well. There is more of a Christian message in this book than in any traditionally published book that I've read, through one of the big Christian book publishers. I believe one of the reasons the author self-published this book was so she could include as much "God stuff" as she wanted to and not be restricted.
I shared this book with my 83 year old Catholic aunt and she can not wait to read books two and three in this series. She was not offended by it in any way and I know she received much more out of it than just a good story.
March 22, 2016
Love in Defiance was a really touching and exciting book. I loved Naomi, Rebecca and Hannah. With problems in their past, the sisters and Naomi's husband John decided that they needed to leave North Carolina and head to California. While they were on the trip there were dangers that changed Naomi's life. It changed all of their lives. When they arrived in Defiance, they were treated with disrespect and potential danger. The family had to keep their faith in order to move on with their lives.
I loved that they followed the path that the lord placed on their hearts. Without understanding the trials they faced they went into a rough, untamed gold mining town and dealt with prostitutes, miners and arrogant men. They did it all with grace and humility.
The side characters were just as important to the story and Heather Blanton allowed the reader to get to know these women and men really well. Filled with charming moments, hopeful moments and heartbreaking events the story was alive from the first pages. Ian and Mr. McIntyre were realistic and their actions brought so many feelings to the surface. Not just for the characters but in me as well.
That the women were Christian's was obvious but it also allowed you to see into their hearts. They were fallible women just like the people they met in Defiance. There were moments where the women were wrong and they had to face their own unchristian like behavior.
This book was so well written. There was romance and strength in every page. I am so glad that the author gifted me with a book so I could read it and review it.
I loved that they followed the path that the lord placed on their hearts. Without understanding the trials they faced they went into a rough, untamed gold mining town and dealt with prostitutes, miners and arrogant men. They did it all with grace and humility.
The side characters were just as important to the story and Heather Blanton allowed the reader to get to know these women and men really well. Filled with charming moments, hopeful moments and heartbreaking events the story was alive from the first pages. Ian and Mr. McIntyre were realistic and their actions brought so many feelings to the surface. Not just for the characters but in me as well.
That the women were Christian's was obvious but it also allowed you to see into their hearts. They were fallible women just like the people they met in Defiance. There were moments where the women were wrong and they had to face their own unchristian like behavior.
This book was so well written. There was romance and strength in every page. I am so glad that the author gifted me with a book so I could read it and review it.
January 21, 2019
.
This series finds three sisters (Rebecca, Naomi, and Hannah) moving from North Carolina to California. When a tragedy occurs, they are stranded near the wild town of Defiance, Colorado, where they decide to start their own hotel.
It doesn't take long before they meet Mr. Charles McIntyre - a wealthy business owner in Defiance, who founded the rowdy mining town. He was satisfied in his role of ruling this devilish community over serving in heaven. This mighty character had an unexplainable pull toward one of the sisters. This installment focused on the sexually magnetic pull between Naomi and Charles, who were involved in a complicated courtship that was often flirtatious and saucy. He encouraged the sister's business venture, opening a hotel, even going so far as to offer his protection.
"It's been much harder to forgive myself. My mistake was like a pebble dropped in a pond. The ripple effect has impacted everyone I love."
Charles McIntyre had many unsavory characters in his employ, all who seemed defiant against anything Godly and good, including Mr. McIntyre. They were all in need of salvation. And these women felt summoned by God to share His love in this apparently Godless community.
I agreed with another that wrote, "I really enjoyed how scriptures were written and a very inspirational story at the same time as the ladies were learning to support themselves and depending on God no matter what comes up."
This was an entertaining historical western, with a nice variety of Christian struggles and resolutions. These books captivate the reader with imperfect characters who questioned their actions and didn't always make the right choices. They knew there was room for improvement and struggled with their purpose.
"God loves us just the way we are but he refuses to leave us that way."
Each installment is able to stand on its own, although reading them in order provides a much better understanding. Each installment also provides an H.E.A. I would recommend this series to anyone who enjoys this genre.
This series finds three sisters (Rebecca, Naomi, and Hannah) moving from North Carolina to California. When a tragedy occurs, they are stranded near the wild town of Defiance, Colorado, where they decide to start their own hotel.
It doesn't take long before they meet Mr. Charles McIntyre - a wealthy business owner in Defiance, who founded the rowdy mining town. He was satisfied in his role of ruling this devilish community over serving in heaven. This mighty character had an unexplainable pull toward one of the sisters. This installment focused on the sexually magnetic pull between Naomi and Charles, who were involved in a complicated courtship that was often flirtatious and saucy. He encouraged the sister's business venture, opening a hotel, even going so far as to offer his protection.
"It's been much harder to forgive myself. My mistake was like a pebble dropped in a pond. The ripple effect has impacted everyone I love."
Charles McIntyre had many unsavory characters in his employ, all who seemed defiant against anything Godly and good, including Mr. McIntyre. They were all in need of salvation. And these women felt summoned by God to share His love in this apparently Godless community.
I agreed with another that wrote, "I really enjoyed how scriptures were written and a very inspirational story at the same time as the ladies were learning to support themselves and depending on God no matter what comes up."
This was an entertaining historical western, with a nice variety of Christian struggles and resolutions. These books captivate the reader with imperfect characters who questioned their actions and didn't always make the right choices. They knew there was room for improvement and struggled with their purpose.
"God loves us just the way we are but he refuses to leave us that way."
Each installment is able to stand on its own, although reading them in order provides a much better understanding. Each installment also provides an H.E.A. I would recommend this series to anyone who enjoys this genre.
May 15, 2016
SUMMARY: A man who wants to rule in Hell. A woman who wants to find her faith again...
Charles McIntyre owns everything and everyone in the lawless, godless mining town of Defiance. When three good, Christian sisters from his beloved South show up stranded, alone, and offering to open a "nice" hotel, he is intrigued enough to let them stay...especially since he sees feisty middle sister Naomi as a possible conquest. But Naomi, angry with God for widowing her, wants no part of Defiance or the saloon-owning, prostitute-keeping Mr. McIntyre. It would seem however, that God has gone to elaborate lengths to bring them together. The question is, "Why?" Does God really have a plan for each and every life?
Written with gritty, but not gratuitous, realism uncharacteristic of historical Christian romances, A Lady in Defiance is edgy Christian fiction that gives a nod to both Pride and Prejudice and Redeeming Love. Based on true events, it is also an ensemble piece that deftly weaves together the relationships of the three sisters and the rowdy residents of Defiance.
REVIEW: This is my first read from Heather Blanton but it definitely will not be my last. This book made my 2016 favorites list. With a depth of storyline, complex and unique characters, a salvation thread that played perfectly throughout the story, and a beautifully described old Colorado mining town at the height of the Gold Rush, this historical fiction read was well done.
There were so many characters both major and minor to love in this novel. Naomi, Hannah and Rebbeca, three sisters, were the heroines. Filled with faith, even if Naomi's waxed and waned, these ladies came to the desperado town of Defiance, ready to face the painted ladies, gamblers, wild miners, etc and display their faith and their moral values. Their effect on so many people in Defiance from McIntyre's partner, Ian, to the painted ladies particularly Daisy/Molly, to Emilio who was struggling to find his way was extraordinary. I loved how Blanton developed the relationships between Ian and Rebecca, Charles and Naomi, and Hannah and Daisy, and the three sisters and Emilio. Each relationship helped the other grow and become more faithful.
There is some violence in it but because it was a western it was fitting for the time period and setting of the book. This historical fiction read was filled with faith, romance, wonderful characters, and was a superb read. I look forward to reading more from Ms. Blanton especially the next in this series.
FAVORITE QUOTES: (There were so many gems in this that it is hard to limit myself to just a few.)
"There's no such thing as luck, Mr. McIntyre. Like it or not, there's only the hand of God."
"Maybe, now and then, we have to give up a portion of our kingdoms--the things we hold dearest--to find what it is God wants for us."
"I'll try to turn the other cheek....But I've only got two and they're both stinging."
"We can best honor our dead by livin' well. Moving' forward dusna mean ye love them any less. It just means ye're still alive."
"It's been much harder to forgive myself. My mistake was like a pebbled dropped in a pond. The ripple effect has impacted everyone I love."
"God loves us just the way we are but he refuses to leave us that way."
Charles McIntyre owns everything and everyone in the lawless, godless mining town of Defiance. When three good, Christian sisters from his beloved South show up stranded, alone, and offering to open a "nice" hotel, he is intrigued enough to let them stay...especially since he sees feisty middle sister Naomi as a possible conquest. But Naomi, angry with God for widowing her, wants no part of Defiance or the saloon-owning, prostitute-keeping Mr. McIntyre. It would seem however, that God has gone to elaborate lengths to bring them together. The question is, "Why?" Does God really have a plan for each and every life?
Written with gritty, but not gratuitous, realism uncharacteristic of historical Christian romances, A Lady in Defiance is edgy Christian fiction that gives a nod to both Pride and Prejudice and Redeeming Love. Based on true events, it is also an ensemble piece that deftly weaves together the relationships of the three sisters and the rowdy residents of Defiance.
REVIEW: This is my first read from Heather Blanton but it definitely will not be my last. This book made my 2016 favorites list. With a depth of storyline, complex and unique characters, a salvation thread that played perfectly throughout the story, and a beautifully described old Colorado mining town at the height of the Gold Rush, this historical fiction read was well done.
There were so many characters both major and minor to love in this novel. Naomi, Hannah and Rebbeca, three sisters, were the heroines. Filled with faith, even if Naomi's waxed and waned, these ladies came to the desperado town of Defiance, ready to face the painted ladies, gamblers, wild miners, etc and display their faith and their moral values. Their effect on so many people in Defiance from McIntyre's partner, Ian, to the painted ladies particularly Daisy/Molly, to Emilio who was struggling to find his way was extraordinary. I loved how Blanton developed the relationships between Ian and Rebecca, Charles and Naomi, and Hannah and Daisy, and the three sisters and Emilio. Each relationship helped the other grow and become more faithful.
There is some violence in it but because it was a western it was fitting for the time period and setting of the book. This historical fiction read was filled with faith, romance, wonderful characters, and was a superb read. I look forward to reading more from Ms. Blanton especially the next in this series.
FAVORITE QUOTES: (There were so many gems in this that it is hard to limit myself to just a few.)
"There's no such thing as luck, Mr. McIntyre. Like it or not, there's only the hand of God."
"Maybe, now and then, we have to give up a portion of our kingdoms--the things we hold dearest--to find what it is God wants for us."
"I'll try to turn the other cheek....But I've only got two and they're both stinging."
"We can best honor our dead by livin' well. Moving' forward dusna mean ye love them any less. It just means ye're still alive."
"It's been much harder to forgive myself. My mistake was like a pebbled dropped in a pond. The ripple effect has impacted everyone I love."
"God loves us just the way we are but he refuses to leave us that way."
January 19, 2015
A Lady in Defiance by Heather Blanton is an excellent western romance where the hero and heroine mixed like oil and water. Charles McIntyre owned just about everything in Defiance. He and Ian were co-owners of the mine. They hired men to dig the mine 24 hours per day every day. It was shift work. He owned most of the saloons and bordellos in town. He called his girls his flowers. Rose, Iris, Jasmine and Daisy. He renamed them. A party of four were heading to California. John, his wife Naomi and her two sisters, Rebecca and Hannah. Hannah was pregnant. An unwed mother which in those days was a catastrophe. On the way John was killed in an accident. They met a young fellow leaving Defiance and he said it was no place for ladies. As soon as they drove their Eaton's into Defiance they were met with dirty, vile men. Mac, (Mr. McIntyre) saved them bu and t it didn't sit right with Naomi. She met with Mac and told him she wanted to make a building a hotel with a restaurant. Mac played poker for her and she won the old emporium. Ian is an architect and he'd send him over to go over blue prints with the ladies. He called Naomi her highness because she was condescending to him. He also told her he would tell the men that she and her sisters were off limits.
October 29, 2014
I thought this book was amazing! It really reminded me of Redeeming Love for some reason. I cannot wait to read the sequel! :)
November 17, 2014
I started off this book thinking I'd love it. It is exactly the kind of writing I enjoy - rich, crammed with description and witty, slightly ironic turns of phrase. The first few scenes were excellent.
By the time I was halfway through the book, I started to feel the lack of pace. I still enjoyed the descriptions, and the clever phrasing, but the narrative was slowed down by the constant explanations of what every character was thinking and feeling. I longed for some straightforward dialogue or action.
The lack of pace was compounded by the many scenes about the lewdness of the men in Defiance and the life of the prostitutes. As the book covered the stories of three sisters, it became bogged down by devoting so much time to secondary characters. Some of the scenes appeared to be just building up local colour rather than driving the story forward.
However, what really spoiled the book for me was the characters of Naomi and McIntyre.
Naomi is arrogant and unable to control her temper. She is a devout Christian, and yet she seems to have little compassion or sympathy for those less fortunate. She detests the rough, miserable miners and looks down on the prostitutes.
In the opening scenes, McIntyre comes across as a bit of a rogue but with a spark of humanity in him. Instead of letting that spark grow, he shows himself as cruel and evil.
McIntyre has a woman, Rose, who is his mistress. Rose works in his saloon, cooks for him, and has sex with him every day. When McIntyre gets annoyed with Rose, he grabs her by the throat and strangles her, almost crushing her windpipe, until she collapses from lack of air. McIntyre mulls over how he has never been violent to a woman before but something about Rose brings out the worst in him. He goes on to think how his descent into debauchery must have been brought about by his relationship with Rose.
Not only is it unpleasant for a hero to behave with such cruelty against any woman - worse, a woman who has been sharing his bed and his life - but it is totally unacceptable that he excuses his behaviour by blaming her. I don't have much experience of men abusing women in a domestic relationship, but I would guess that many of them excuse their violence by saying "she provoked me to it".
How can McIntyre blame Rose for anything he does? She is effectively his slave (the reader is told that he buys and sells the women). All the power in the relationship is his. In fact, when he decides he is tired of Rose, he sends her off to the meanest whorehouse in town, where he expects she will be beaten and starved and abused until she learns better manners.
I'm not a religious person, but I have always assumed that compassion and charity are core Christian values. However, Naomi and her sisters seem more inclined to feel contempt and disgust.
Naomi has the comfort of her sisters. She has plenty of money. She gets an expensive building given to her, and she enjoys the protection and assistance of the richest and most influential man in town. And yet she wallows in anger and self pity because her husband died.
She shows no pity towards the prostitutes who have been traded like slaves and who are used and abused every night by the rough men that Naomi and her sisters so detest. Never do we see her thinking of the misfortunes that have forced these women into prostitution. In those days in the West, it was often the only alternative to starvation or suicide when women were left without a male protector if their husbands or fathers or brothers died or could no longer support them.
Also, it puzzled me a bit how Naomi and her sisters seemed to live in some kind of vacuum. By the time I stopped reading (about 60% through) they have been in Defiance about 6 weeks. When they go to the mercantile they have run-ins with the prostitutes, and on a couple of trips they get accosted by the rough miners. For the rest of the time, the only contact they seem to have is with McIntyre and the men he sends to work for them.
What about all the other people in town? McIntyre has put out the word that these women must be left alone, but he can't own everybody. Some miners will have wives. Some will be decent men. Why isn't anyone calling on the sisters, making their acquaintance? They are planning to run a hotel and a restaurant. How can they hope to do it - work providing a service - if they feel that everyone in their potential clientele is so far beneath them they can't be tolerated for even the briefest social contact?
A couple of other niggly things that made me dislike Naomi and her sisters. The youngest, Hannah, is about to become a teenage unwed mother. In those days, families would have put great effort into finding her a husband, to save the child from an illegitimate birth. Illegitimate children were outcasts, for example many schools refused to take them. If there was no suitable husband, the custom was to make up a dead husband and pretend to be a widow.
In Hannah's case, it almost seems as if the sisters are flaunting her pregnancy, as if they feel the moral rules that apply to others don't apply to them. Naomi wears her long hair loose when she goes out. It is not something a woman would in those days do unless she wanted to be seen as a temptress.
So, all in all, to me Naomi came across as superior and arrogant and overly aggressive, and McIntyre as a cruel, abusive male who enjoyed his power over others and had no qualms about trafficking sex slaves.
Not the type of hero and heroine I want to cheer for, and certainly not something that would give me a happy glow of Christian values.
Shame, because I enjoyed the writing. There are quite a few typos, though - not enough to ruin the flow but enough to be distracting.
By the time I was halfway through the book, I started to feel the lack of pace. I still enjoyed the descriptions, and the clever phrasing, but the narrative was slowed down by the constant explanations of what every character was thinking and feeling. I longed for some straightforward dialogue or action.
The lack of pace was compounded by the many scenes about the lewdness of the men in Defiance and the life of the prostitutes. As the book covered the stories of three sisters, it became bogged down by devoting so much time to secondary characters. Some of the scenes appeared to be just building up local colour rather than driving the story forward.
However, what really spoiled the book for me was the characters of Naomi and McIntyre.
Naomi is arrogant and unable to control her temper. She is a devout Christian, and yet she seems to have little compassion or sympathy for those less fortunate. She detests the rough, miserable miners and looks down on the prostitutes.
In the opening scenes, McIntyre comes across as a bit of a rogue but with a spark of humanity in him. Instead of letting that spark grow, he shows himself as cruel and evil.
McIntyre has a woman, Rose, who is his mistress. Rose works in his saloon, cooks for him, and has sex with him every day. When McIntyre gets annoyed with Rose, he grabs her by the throat and strangles her, almost crushing her windpipe, until she collapses from lack of air. McIntyre mulls over how he has never been violent to a woman before but something about Rose brings out the worst in him. He goes on to think how his descent into debauchery must have been brought about by his relationship with Rose.
Not only is it unpleasant for a hero to behave with such cruelty against any woman - worse, a woman who has been sharing his bed and his life - but it is totally unacceptable that he excuses his behaviour by blaming her. I don't have much experience of men abusing women in a domestic relationship, but I would guess that many of them excuse their violence by saying "she provoked me to it".
How can McIntyre blame Rose for anything he does? She is effectively his slave (the reader is told that he buys and sells the women). All the power in the relationship is his. In fact, when he decides he is tired of Rose, he sends her off to the meanest whorehouse in town, where he expects she will be beaten and starved and abused until she learns better manners.
I'm not a religious person, but I have always assumed that compassion and charity are core Christian values. However, Naomi and her sisters seem more inclined to feel contempt and disgust.
Naomi has the comfort of her sisters. She has plenty of money. She gets an expensive building given to her, and she enjoys the protection and assistance of the richest and most influential man in town. And yet she wallows in anger and self pity because her husband died.
She shows no pity towards the prostitutes who have been traded like slaves and who are used and abused every night by the rough men that Naomi and her sisters so detest. Never do we see her thinking of the misfortunes that have forced these women into prostitution. In those days in the West, it was often the only alternative to starvation or suicide when women were left without a male protector if their husbands or fathers or brothers died or could no longer support them.
Also, it puzzled me a bit how Naomi and her sisters seemed to live in some kind of vacuum. By the time I stopped reading (about 60% through) they have been in Defiance about 6 weeks. When they go to the mercantile they have run-ins with the prostitutes, and on a couple of trips they get accosted by the rough miners. For the rest of the time, the only contact they seem to have is with McIntyre and the men he sends to work for them.
What about all the other people in town? McIntyre has put out the word that these women must be left alone, but he can't own everybody. Some miners will have wives. Some will be decent men. Why isn't anyone calling on the sisters, making their acquaintance? They are planning to run a hotel and a restaurant. How can they hope to do it - work providing a service - if they feel that everyone in their potential clientele is so far beneath them they can't be tolerated for even the briefest social contact?
A couple of other niggly things that made me dislike Naomi and her sisters. The youngest, Hannah, is about to become a teenage unwed mother. In those days, families would have put great effort into finding her a husband, to save the child from an illegitimate birth. Illegitimate children were outcasts, for example many schools refused to take them. If there was no suitable husband, the custom was to make up a dead husband and pretend to be a widow.
In Hannah's case, it almost seems as if the sisters are flaunting her pregnancy, as if they feel the moral rules that apply to others don't apply to them. Naomi wears her long hair loose when she goes out. It is not something a woman would in those days do unless she wanted to be seen as a temptress.
So, all in all, to me Naomi came across as superior and arrogant and overly aggressive, and McIntyre as a cruel, abusive male who enjoyed his power over others and had no qualms about trafficking sex slaves.
Not the type of hero and heroine I want to cheer for, and certainly not something that would give me a happy glow of Christian values.
Shame, because I enjoyed the writing. There are quite a few typos, though - not enough to ruin the flow but enough to be distracting.
August 25, 2015
A Lady in Defiance by Heather Blanton***
This is a story of three sisters, Rebecca, Naomi and her husband John, and Hannah who move across country to start a new life. While on the trail tragedy strikes and John is killed. Instead of traveling on further they settle in the town of Defiance. They soon find the name of the town fits it perfectly, the citizens of this lawless, roudy mining town are indeed defiant—which is probably their “best” quality.
Rebecca, Naomi and Hannah are all Christian women, alone now but plan to make a respectful living.
This proves challenging as there are not any respectful jobs for respectful women in this town. This does not stop them, however, they join together in prayer asking God to guide them and give them strength to carry our His will for them in this town.
In answer to their prayers they find a hotel for sale, which also includes living quarters. So they buy the hotel from Charles McIntyre, who owns everything and everyone in Defiance. He soon learns that these sweet, Southern Christian woman have a will of their own and will not fall under his controlling hand in business or personal lives. This is a new concept for Charles and he is determined to have his way in their hotel and with Naomi.
Although I do not enjoy reading about houses of prostitution, saloons and gambling, this is a good story. The sisters struggle to show God's love, forgiveness and grace in their encounters with those who live in Defiance. We see God working in the lives of Defiance but also in the sisters as well.
~~I received a copy of this book from the author~~
~~~Reviews posted on Goodreads.com, Barnsandnoble.com and Amazon.com~~~
This is a story of three sisters, Rebecca, Naomi and her husband John, and Hannah who move across country to start a new life. While on the trail tragedy strikes and John is killed. Instead of traveling on further they settle in the town of Defiance. They soon find the name of the town fits it perfectly, the citizens of this lawless, roudy mining town are indeed defiant—which is probably their “best” quality.
Rebecca, Naomi and Hannah are all Christian women, alone now but plan to make a respectful living.
This proves challenging as there are not any respectful jobs for respectful women in this town. This does not stop them, however, they join together in prayer asking God to guide them and give them strength to carry our His will for them in this town.
In answer to their prayers they find a hotel for sale, which also includes living quarters. So they buy the hotel from Charles McIntyre, who owns everything and everyone in Defiance. He soon learns that these sweet, Southern Christian woman have a will of their own and will not fall under his controlling hand in business or personal lives. This is a new concept for Charles and he is determined to have his way in their hotel and with Naomi.
Although I do not enjoy reading about houses of prostitution, saloons and gambling, this is a good story. The sisters struggle to show God's love, forgiveness and grace in their encounters with those who live in Defiance. We see God working in the lives of Defiance but also in the sisters as well.
~~I received a copy of this book from the author~~
~~~Reviews posted on Goodreads.com, Barnsandnoble.com and Amazon.com~~~
May 11, 2013
I'm torn on this book. I loved the plot, the idea behind the book, and the concept of three sisters starting over in a small, yet wild, mining town. I also found the relationships between the three sisters (Rebecca, Naomi and Hannah) to be endearing and heart-warming.
Unfortunately, what I really liked about this book ends there. I typically do like Christian fiction; however, this book is what I came to think of as somewhat judgmental, heavy-handed Christian fiction. The author's tone was at times condescending and, to be quite frank, rude (for example, a prostitute in the book is referred to as a "soiled dove"....not very Christian, rude, and judgmental...I'd bet my bottom dollar God doesn't think of her as "soiled"- behaviors not good, yes; but SOILED?). Also, the author has a very simplistic view of being Christian in that multiple people in the book were able to suddenly turn their lives to God, become Christian, and make miraculous life changes as easy as a walk in the park. Yes, of course this does happen; but somehow the struggles, confusion, and heart-ache in doing so and the difficulty in building a new life were quickly breezed over, if mentioned at all.
Besides disagreeing with the heavy-handed, judgmental and naive theology of the book, I did like the plot and the characters. For me, other Christian fiction authors (Tamera Alexander, Francine Rivers, etc) are better bets for good Christian fiction.
Unfortunately, what I really liked about this book ends there. I typically do like Christian fiction; however, this book is what I came to think of as somewhat judgmental, heavy-handed Christian fiction. The author's tone was at times condescending and, to be quite frank, rude (for example, a prostitute in the book is referred to as a "soiled dove"....not very Christian, rude, and judgmental...I'd bet my bottom dollar God doesn't think of her as "soiled"- behaviors not good, yes; but SOILED?). Also, the author has a very simplistic view of being Christian in that multiple people in the book were able to suddenly turn their lives to God, become Christian, and make miraculous life changes as easy as a walk in the park. Yes, of course this does happen; but somehow the struggles, confusion, and heart-ache in doing so and the difficulty in building a new life were quickly breezed over, if mentioned at all.
Besides disagreeing with the heavy-handed, judgmental and naive theology of the book, I did like the plot and the characters. For me, other Christian fiction authors (Tamera Alexander, Francine Rivers, etc) are better bets for good Christian fiction.
August 31, 2016
- "A Lady in Defiance, loosely based on true events, is set in the majestic San Juan Mountains of Colorado, the most beautiful place in the world. While a romance, it is also an "ensemble" piece that weaves together the relationships of the three sisters and the rowdy residents of Defiance. Heather has two sisters whom she loves dearly. One is still with us, the other crossed over to be with Lord in 1999 and it is she who inspired the character of Hannah." ~ from Ms. Blanton's Amazon.com author page.The above quote provides a very good description of the book. The author has done well with providing characters of strong Christian faith without making them sound holier-than-thou. And by the end of the book, I truly wanted to know what happened next. I rate the book a 4.5 stars due to a few repetitious passages.
October 8, 2012
I absolutely LOVED this book. I admit that I was a bit thrown off by the cover art... talk about "don't judge a book by its cover"! If you have had any reservations about reading this book based on the cover, I beg you to reconsider. This book will not disappoint.
It was such a beautiful story about redemption... it practically had me in tears every other chapter. I absolutely loved Heather Blanton's use of Scripture throughout the book. There were times when reading this that I felt like getting on my knees to thank the Lord for saving me. I'm so happy I read this book... it was such a surprisingly good read. I'm amazed that this has not been published by Baker, Barbour, or Tyndale.
It was such a beautiful story about redemption... it practically had me in tears every other chapter. I absolutely loved Heather Blanton's use of Scripture throughout the book. There were times when reading this that I felt like getting on my knees to thank the Lord for saving me. I'm so happy I read this book... it was such a surprisingly good read. I'm amazed that this has not been published by Baker, Barbour, or Tyndale.
June 3, 2016
A Lady in defiance is the first book I have read by Heather Blanton. It is a little darker than the usual books I read, but I really enjoyed it. Ther are themes of loss, anger at G-d, spiritual warfare, prostitution, drunkenness, violence, and restitution. The story is very engaging and I wanted to read fast so I would know their fate. But I also wanted to savor the story as it is so well written.I look forward to reading more books by Heather Blanton.
I was given this book by the author in exchange for my honest opinion.
I was given this book by the author in exchange for my honest opinion.
December 30, 2012
This is a suspenseful romance set during the late 1800's in which Naomi, her husband, and her two sisters were making their way to California in their wagon when her husband dies and she feels led to put down roots in Defiance. Defiance is a lawless town built on gold mining and the only women there are prostitutes. Needless to say, it's pretty shocking for these three upstanding women with the looks and comments they get.
Naomi strikes a deal to run a restaurant and hotel with Charles, the wealthiest local saloon and brothel owner who pretty much owns the town. The sisters try to befriend the prostitutes and show them God's love, but there is one who's incredibly hateful and threatening to Naomi. Rose is pretty unpredictable and that's where the suspense comes in because you're not sure what she'll do next. Naomi is grieving, but soon finds herself feeling attracted to Charles, a man she despises. Not only does she hate his profession, but he also has no use for God. He delights in getting a rise out of her and she has a hard time being civil to him. There's also a bit of romance for one of her sisters.
I enjoyed this story about three sisters trying to change a town with God's help. We get to see the different character's points of view and I really liked all three sisters, especially Naomi. She's a feisty character who struggles with showing God's love and not being judgmental. I liked the darker aspect to it that the Rose character lent. The story's gritty without being graphic. There were also some great humorous moments. Overall, an enjoyable story for historical fiction lovers!
This is only available as a kindle e-book.
I received the e-book free from the author in exchange for an honest review.
Naomi strikes a deal to run a restaurant and hotel with Charles, the wealthiest local saloon and brothel owner who pretty much owns the town. The sisters try to befriend the prostitutes and show them God's love, but there is one who's incredibly hateful and threatening to Naomi. Rose is pretty unpredictable and that's where the suspense comes in because you're not sure what she'll do next. Naomi is grieving, but soon finds herself feeling attracted to Charles, a man she despises. Not only does she hate his profession, but he also has no use for God. He delights in getting a rise out of her and she has a hard time being civil to him. There's also a bit of romance for one of her sisters.
I enjoyed this story about three sisters trying to change a town with God's help. We get to see the different character's points of view and I really liked all three sisters, especially Naomi. She's a feisty character who struggles with showing God's love and not being judgmental. I liked the darker aspect to it that the Rose character lent. The story's gritty without being graphic. There were also some great humorous moments. Overall, an enjoyable story for historical fiction lovers!
This is only available as a kindle e-book.
I received the e-book free from the author in exchange for an honest review.
August 11, 2014
This book tells the story of three sisters who while travelling in America to a new life are struck by tragedy and are forced to rethink their destination. They end up in a small mining town called Defiance which isn't sure what to make of refined Christian ladies being more used to the 'flowers' who 'entertain' the miners.
Along the way the realise that living a Christian life in this environment is nothing like what they have previously experienced and constantly come up against opposition, not least in the shape of McIntyre who runs the local saloon and makes money from it and his flowers.
I was greatly moved by this book which had me in tears on more than one occasion when the sisters realise how much God is working in their new-found home and how much they were destined to be there.
Defiance seems like an allegory of the world today and we as Christians must try in our own small way to be light and salt in what can be harsh times.
At times I felt it was a little simplistic but I liked that no-one including the sisters was perfect but all had flaws.
A great read and I look forward to more by the author.
Along the way the realise that living a Christian life in this environment is nothing like what they have previously experienced and constantly come up against opposition, not least in the shape of McIntyre who runs the local saloon and makes money from it and his flowers.
I was greatly moved by this book which had me in tears on more than one occasion when the sisters realise how much God is working in their new-found home and how much they were destined to be there.
Defiance seems like an allegory of the world today and we as Christians must try in our own small way to be light and salt in what can be harsh times.
At times I felt it was a little simplistic but I liked that no-one including the sisters was perfect but all had flaws.
A great read and I look forward to more by the author.
May 9, 2016
" If I speak in the tongues of man and of angels, but have not love I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal."
Why in the world God would lead three God-fearing women to this God-forsaken town, was a mystery to Naomi Miller. Defiance, Colorado with its lawlessness, debauchery, and endless improprieties was hardly suited for two lovely widows and a young compromised sister, wasn't it? Yet, here they were. Utterly grief-stricken, Naomi makes an impulsive business agreement with the man who appears to own Defiance, Mr. Charles McIntyre. After all, how hard could it be to open a respectable inn amidst noisy brothels and frequented saloons?
Charles McIntyre has never met a woman like Naomi. He cannot decide whether she will be his biggest asset, his worst nightmare or a combination of the two. After all, their personalities clash like fire and ice, but of one thing he is certain; things are going to change with this lady in Defiance.
This deeply inspirational tale of unconditional love in the middle of a wild western mining town is a satisfying beginning to an ongoing story.
Why in the world God would lead three God-fearing women to this God-forsaken town, was a mystery to Naomi Miller. Defiance, Colorado with its lawlessness, debauchery, and endless improprieties was hardly suited for two lovely widows and a young compromised sister, wasn't it? Yet, here they were. Utterly grief-stricken, Naomi makes an impulsive business agreement with the man who appears to own Defiance, Mr. Charles McIntyre. After all, how hard could it be to open a respectable inn amidst noisy brothels and frequented saloons?
Charles McIntyre has never met a woman like Naomi. He cannot decide whether she will be his biggest asset, his worst nightmare or a combination of the two. After all, their personalities clash like fire and ice, but of one thing he is certain; things are going to change with this lady in Defiance.
This deeply inspirational tale of unconditional love in the middle of a wild western mining town is a satisfying beginning to an ongoing story.
May 28, 2015
I could not put this down! It was a great read. Historical Christian Fiction tends to be my genre of choice and this book is certainly now at the top of my favorites in the long list of titles I have read by many authors. I won't spill all of the details here because I think you should read it for yourself but of the details of the book were so well written. The sisters and their relationships, the emotional struggles, the faith lessons, the picture of life in the gritty, rowdy West and especially the romance all made this book wonderful, all of it was my favorite part! It is hard to believe that this is author Heather Blanton's first book, her style of writing is fabulous and I cannot wait to see what she will come up with next. I will definitely be reading this book again and I am certainly anxiously awaiting the sequel!
January 28, 2016
For to long this book was on my TBR list waiting patiently for me to read, and finally I had time to read it. It was everything I thought I would be and more.
A strong message of obedience was at the heart of this book. God's challenges real facts to sharpen us and equip us for the task.
It is about forgiveness of one self, accepting the redeeming love of Christ and change. To be the man or woman God has called you to be.
Trails and tribulations are part of our Believers walk, and the author portrait it with compassion and sincerity.
A great book I can recommend, you will leave with a clear message of God's love and what it means, and the true meaning of grace as demonstrated by the characters in this book.
Thanks for the promotional gift.
A strong message of obedience was at the heart of this book. God's challenges real facts to sharpen us and equip us for the task.
It is about forgiveness of one self, accepting the redeeming love of Christ and change. To be the man or woman God has called you to be.
Trails and tribulations are part of our Believers walk, and the author portrait it with compassion and sincerity.
A great book I can recommend, you will leave with a clear message of God's love and what it means, and the true meaning of grace as demonstrated by the characters in this book.
Thanks for the promotional gift.
August 4, 2016
This was a surprising book! I have been burned by freebies on Kindle and this one turned out to be a diamond in disguise!
After her husband dies,Naomi must decide where she and her two sisters who had been traveling across country will do. They turn into a mining town called Defiance and become proprietresses of a hotel.
There is resistance from the town, especially when the girls set out to redeem the soiled doves of a nearby brothel.
I enjoyed reading about these ladies and their devotion to God as they reached out to others with God's forgiveness and love. You will even get to read a bit of sweet romance in the book :-) Well worth picking up.
After her husband dies,Naomi must decide where she and her two sisters who had been traveling across country will do. They turn into a mining town called Defiance and become proprietresses of a hotel.
There is resistance from the town, especially when the girls set out to redeem the soiled doves of a nearby brothel.
I enjoyed reading about these ladies and their devotion to God as they reached out to others with God's forgiveness and love. You will even get to read a bit of sweet romance in the book :-) Well worth picking up.
October 14, 2014
A Lady in Defiance
I truly enjoyed this book. Three sisters end up in a town of the wild (very wild) west. Their trials are heavy but God's love gives them strength, love and ability to survive and thrive.
I really like books set in the old west - although I am glad that I didn't live back then because I really do like indoor plumbing, electricity and the other conveniences of my modern world. This book evoked the mental images I have from watching tv shows like Bonanza and The Rifleman and The Lone Ranger.
Thank you Heather Blanton for the great story and giving me hours of western life.
I truly enjoyed this book. Three sisters end up in a town of the wild (very wild) west. Their trials are heavy but God's love gives them strength, love and ability to survive and thrive.
I really like books set in the old west - although I am glad that I didn't live back then because I really do like indoor plumbing, electricity and the other conveniences of my modern world. This book evoked the mental images I have from watching tv shows like Bonanza and The Rifleman and The Lone Ranger.
Thank you Heather Blanton for the great story and giving me hours of western life.
July 4, 2013
Very well written historical fiction. The characters were well developed and the plot was intriguing. I don't understand people who complain about a Christian book being "preachy".....the Gospel of Jesus Christ is the only hope for a historical western town called Defiance or a modern country called America, Europe, etc. I also liked that the sisters were human but surrendered their wills to God. Looking forward to book 2. Thanks to the author for allowing this to be a free ebook via Amazon for a limited time, otherwise I would have missed out on another very talented writer!
February 28, 2015
I have received this book for free through Goodreads First Reads. A Lady in Defiance is a thoughtful and spiritual journey for three sisters and a town called Defiance which enables them to change and grow with one another.
The writing was beautiful and well-crafted. The characters were each their own person and had a different approach to life and why they did the things they did. The story itself was enjoyable and gave hope to those who thought themselves beyond help and salvation. It's a book worth rereading. 5 stars.
The writing was beautiful and well-crafted. The characters were each their own person and had a different approach to life and why they did the things they did. The story itself was enjoyable and gave hope to those who thought themselves beyond help and salvation. It's a book worth rereading. 5 stars.
August 20, 2014
I like! I like! I like!
Finally a clean read! I really, really like this book! It always pleases me when an author, literally weaves the "salvation" message with such loving compassion that it gently woos the reader, to an greater understanding of the eternal sacrifice that was made for me and you.
Finally a clean read! I really, really like this book! It always pleases me when an author, literally weaves the "salvation" message with such loving compassion that it gently woos the reader, to an greater understanding of the eternal sacrifice that was made for me and you.
August 30, 2016
A Lady in Defiance by Heather Blanton, Book 1 in her new and very exciting Inspirational Western Historical Romance, "Romance in the Rockies", set against the Colorado Gold Rush period, in Defiance, Colorado.
WOW! What a complex and emotionally charged Inspirational Western Romance!
While, some readers may find this story a bit usual, and unconventional, I was definitely intrigued at how the author brought Christian values into a story filled with so much sin. But Ms. Blanton definitely did this and so much more!
Three sisters, Naomi, Hannah and Rebecca face many hardship and struggles along the way, but can they find God's redeeming love, peace, and healing in Defiance, Colorado? A town of corruption, that's definitely filled with sin. Has God forsaken them, for they have faced grief and loneliness already? Or has he brought them to Defiance to find love, healing and their HEA?
Then there's Charles McIntyre, the owner of most of Defiance, a hard man to be sure, Ian, Daisy, and Emilio, to name a few of the intriguing characters in this amazing, highly explosive story.
While, "A Lady in Defiance", may not be your tradional Christian Romance, as it most definitely weaves sin throughout. Such sins as, debauchery, violence, prostitution, drunkeness, spiritual and personal struggles, gambling, some mystery, definitely sins of the flesh, is woven throughout, it is a most compelling, and explosive story. It also has God's promise of unconditional love, forgiveness, healing, peace and mercy, if we only have faith in his love.
Readers will find Ms. Blanton has woven scriptures and spiritual quotes, throughout. As we all know we fall short of innocence in one way or another. For we all have sinned. I ask you not to judge "A Lady in Defiance" without reading it first. There is definitely something intriguing, about "A Lady in Defiance". Rather, it's the reassurance of the power of healing, faith, redemption, forgiveness, and finding one's personal and spiritual faith, or the power of love, acceptance and redemption, I think each reader must judge for themselves the power of this tale. Personally, I found it to be powerful and emotionally charged. As a reader of Inspirational Historical Romance, I found Ms. Blanton's writing of this story intriguing, powerful, captivating and most compelling. A unique but mesmerizing, Western Inspirational Historical Romance. Mimics today's world, with realism and I admire how she had the courage and faith to write such a unconditional, unconventional, well written, fast paced, tale of God's amazing grace and mercy. Not "preachy" but with reassurance and the power of love. Well done, Ms. Blanton! I look forward to Book 2 in this amazing and powerful "Romance in the Rockies". I was definitely entranced and enthralled by this story! Rather, you're a fan of Christian Historical Romance or a fan of romance in general, I hope you will give "A Lady in Defiance", a chance to prove, you, really shouldn't judge a book by its cover! A must read Western Historical Romance!
Received for an honest review. However, all opinions, insights and thoughts are my own personal opinions.
Rating: 4.5
Heat rating: Sweet to Mild due to the "negative" element.
Reviewed by: AprilR
WOW! What a complex and emotionally charged Inspirational Western Romance!
While, some readers may find this story a bit usual, and unconventional, I was definitely intrigued at how the author brought Christian values into a story filled with so much sin. But Ms. Blanton definitely did this and so much more!
Three sisters, Naomi, Hannah and Rebecca face many hardship and struggles along the way, but can they find God's redeeming love, peace, and healing in Defiance, Colorado? A town of corruption, that's definitely filled with sin. Has God forsaken them, for they have faced grief and loneliness already? Or has he brought them to Defiance to find love, healing and their HEA?
Then there's Charles McIntyre, the owner of most of Defiance, a hard man to be sure, Ian, Daisy, and Emilio, to name a few of the intriguing characters in this amazing, highly explosive story.
While, "A Lady in Defiance", may not be your tradional Christian Romance, as it most definitely weaves sin throughout. Such sins as, debauchery, violence, prostitution, drunkeness, spiritual and personal struggles, gambling, some mystery, definitely sins of the flesh, is woven throughout, it is a most compelling, and explosive story. It also has God's promise of unconditional love, forgiveness, healing, peace and mercy, if we only have faith in his love.
Readers will find Ms. Blanton has woven scriptures and spiritual quotes, throughout. As we all know we fall short of innocence in one way or another. For we all have sinned. I ask you not to judge "A Lady in Defiance" without reading it first. There is definitely something intriguing, about "A Lady in Defiance". Rather, it's the reassurance of the power of healing, faith, redemption, forgiveness, and finding one's personal and spiritual faith, or the power of love, acceptance and redemption, I think each reader must judge for themselves the power of this tale. Personally, I found it to be powerful and emotionally charged. As a reader of Inspirational Historical Romance, I found Ms. Blanton's writing of this story intriguing, powerful, captivating and most compelling. A unique but mesmerizing, Western Inspirational Historical Romance. Mimics today's world, with realism and I admire how she had the courage and faith to write such a unconditional, unconventional, well written, fast paced, tale of God's amazing grace and mercy. Not "preachy" but with reassurance and the power of love. Well done, Ms. Blanton! I look forward to Book 2 in this amazing and powerful "Romance in the Rockies". I was definitely entranced and enthralled by this story! Rather, you're a fan of Christian Historical Romance or a fan of romance in general, I hope you will give "A Lady in Defiance", a chance to prove, you, really shouldn't judge a book by its cover! A must read Western Historical Romance!
Received for an honest review. However, all opinions, insights and thoughts are my own personal opinions.
Rating: 4.5
Heat rating: Sweet to Mild due to the "negative" element.
Reviewed by: AprilR
May 19, 2016
When God leads three sisters to a town called Defiance, they had no idea how He would use them to shine His light in the darkest of places.
"Naomi found it mind-boggling and quite humbling what God could do if you let him."
Location 3665
About the Book
Charles McIntyre is the founder of Defiance, a town riddled with lust and drunkenness. He is determined to clean up the town so that the railroad will lay tracks there. The only problem is, he has forgotten what it takes to be a man of honor. Recently widowed Mrs. Naomi Miller and her two sisters, Hannah and Rebecca, know that they were led to Defiance by God. Intent on opening a respectable hotel, they face challenges that they have been unprepared for. Following the Lord's lead...and sometimes that of a feisty personality, the sisters aim to earn a decent reputation in the town and share the love of God with those around them. Showing them that no one is perfect, and that our Heavenly Father loves us no matter our past. Repentance and salvation is available to us all. Will Naomi be able to see past the sins of the man and see his heart? With more than one disreputable man in town, will the sisters remain safe?
My Thoughts
I have not read many books that so blatantly show us the black and white of sin and salvation. There is a lot of language referencing the work of the prostitutes in the story. But I do not feel that the profession was glamorized at all, far from it. There is a lot of reference to the prostitutes' low cut dresses and ogling of the females in general by the men. But as the sisters remain pure, their attitudes and behavior rubs off on those around them. Giving us a perfect example of being in the world but not of it. They held firm to their beliefs and were not swayed by the godless world around them. And through them God brought a change to the town and the occupants. While this is not a book I would recommend for young readers, I never felt uncomfortable reading this and I am planning on reading the rest of the series. I would also like to honor Heather for writing what she was called to write. She shares the true grit of the west with the pure love and acceptance of our Lord Jesus Christ.
My Rating
★★★★☆ - You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you. (More Info)
Published by Rivulet Publishing. I received a free digital copy of A Lady in Defiance in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
"Naomi found it mind-boggling and quite humbling what God could do if you let him."
Location 3665
About the Book
Charles McIntyre is the founder of Defiance, a town riddled with lust and drunkenness. He is determined to clean up the town so that the railroad will lay tracks there. The only problem is, he has forgotten what it takes to be a man of honor. Recently widowed Mrs. Naomi Miller and her two sisters, Hannah and Rebecca, know that they were led to Defiance by God. Intent on opening a respectable hotel, they face challenges that they have been unprepared for. Following the Lord's lead...and sometimes that of a feisty personality, the sisters aim to earn a decent reputation in the town and share the love of God with those around them. Showing them that no one is perfect, and that our Heavenly Father loves us no matter our past. Repentance and salvation is available to us all. Will Naomi be able to see past the sins of the man and see his heart? With more than one disreputable man in town, will the sisters remain safe?
My Thoughts
I have not read many books that so blatantly show us the black and white of sin and salvation. There is a lot of language referencing the work of the prostitutes in the story. But I do not feel that the profession was glamorized at all, far from it. There is a lot of reference to the prostitutes' low cut dresses and ogling of the females in general by the men. But as the sisters remain pure, their attitudes and behavior rubs off on those around them. Giving us a perfect example of being in the world but not of it. They held firm to their beliefs and were not swayed by the godless world around them. And through them God brought a change to the town and the occupants. While this is not a book I would recommend for young readers, I never felt uncomfortable reading this and I am planning on reading the rest of the series. I would also like to honor Heather for writing what she was called to write. She shares the true grit of the west with the pure love and acceptance of our Lord Jesus Christ.
My Rating
★★★★☆ - You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you. (More Info)
Published by Rivulet Publishing. I received a free digital copy of A Lady in Defiance in exchange for my honest review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
April 11, 2016
In A Lady in Defiance- Rebecca, Naomi, and Hannah are sisters traveling on a wagon trail headed West to California when disaster strikes. As the women contemplate their next move, Naomi feels God’s gentle prodding — urging the ladies to settle in the Colorado mining town of Defiance. They find a lawless, godless town overwrought with greed and debauchery.
Of the three sisters, I felt a sort of kinship with Naomi. She reminded me a little of the OT prophet Jonah when she prayed, “I don’t like these people, God, and I don’t have compassion for any of them.” I’ve prayed a similar prayer during my own ministry work, and like Naomi, God honored my prayer by softening my heart. Despite her belief in God, trials cause Naomi to question God’s plan and purpose for the sisters in Defiance. Her doubts play out in a spattering of humorous, willful, and quick tempered interactions with Charles McIntyre. Their tension filled and sometimes explosive relationship held me captive to the very end.
The Audible version of A Lady in Defiance is narrated by Angel Clark. By fluctuating her tone and pitch she gives voice to a minimum of 8 women as well as a number of gentlemen. Each unique character depiction kept the path of conversation straight in my mind. My only critique would be that her accents, particularly her Irish brogue and Latina sass, sounded a little stereotypical. Whether this should be attributed to the narrator’s performance or the author’s writing I am not certain. Regardless, her interpretation and delivery of the story was entertaining.
This story had all of the elements I would associate with a Western — booze, brawls, and working girls. Yet from the beginning, the story coveys an overtly Christian message about reaching the lost with the gospel. The sisters live as missionaries by praying for and serving their new community. Overall, I am pleased that my first foray into Western fiction came through the gifted pen of Heather Blanton.
I received this book from the author for my honest review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Of the three sisters, I felt a sort of kinship with Naomi. She reminded me a little of the OT prophet Jonah when she prayed, “I don’t like these people, God, and I don’t have compassion for any of them.” I’ve prayed a similar prayer during my own ministry work, and like Naomi, God honored my prayer by softening my heart. Despite her belief in God, trials cause Naomi to question God’s plan and purpose for the sisters in Defiance. Her doubts play out in a spattering of humorous, willful, and quick tempered interactions with Charles McIntyre. Their tension filled and sometimes explosive relationship held me captive to the very end.
The Audible version of A Lady in Defiance is narrated by Angel Clark. By fluctuating her tone and pitch she gives voice to a minimum of 8 women as well as a number of gentlemen. Each unique character depiction kept the path of conversation straight in my mind. My only critique would be that her accents, particularly her Irish brogue and Latina sass, sounded a little stereotypical. Whether this should be attributed to the narrator’s performance or the author’s writing I am not certain. Regardless, her interpretation and delivery of the story was entertaining.
This story had all of the elements I would associate with a Western — booze, brawls, and working girls. Yet from the beginning, the story coveys an overtly Christian message about reaching the lost with the gospel. The sisters live as missionaries by praying for and serving their new community. Overall, I am pleased that my first foray into Western fiction came through the gifted pen of Heather Blanton.
I received this book from the author for my honest review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
July 4, 2016
I found myself not able to put this book down. This isn't a simple Christian Historical Romance. This book (and I hope the series) is raw, pure relatable feelings.
Naomi is the main female character, and within the first ten minutes of the book, she loses her husband. Now alone with her sisters, Rebecca and Hannah they travel into a town called Defiance.
Defiance is what many who live in mining, railroad towns would say is the image of the Wild West. The men and women are rough and tough. Charles, the man running the town is the most enduring man. Yes, he isn't a Christian, yes, he does run a brothel/saloon and chase people out of town with a losing hand in blackjack. But if as a Christian you were to meet this man during this time. Flashing arrows wouldn't be the sign needed to know he needs God and a kind hand.
Naomi is not a strong believer, but if the naysayers would recall, there is a point where she is talking with God about having put her husband ahead of the Lord. This is the true journey of Christian growth learning to put God first, the human battles of feeling and emotions of a struggling Christian.
I loved that this was a raw emotion and rough western Christian book. The west wasn't a kind area, there was more than even this author could detail, yet she did a fabulous job of bringing the west to this book. She did a fabulous job making faith real and accepting in this book.
Thank you for reminding me that the Lord will take us all, and forgiveness can happen.
Naomi is the main female character, and within the first ten minutes of the book, she loses her husband. Now alone with her sisters, Rebecca and Hannah they travel into a town called Defiance.
Defiance is what many who live in mining, railroad towns would say is the image of the Wild West. The men and women are rough and tough. Charles, the man running the town is the most enduring man. Yes, he isn't a Christian, yes, he does run a brothel/saloon and chase people out of town with a losing hand in blackjack. But if as a Christian you were to meet this man during this time. Flashing arrows wouldn't be the sign needed to know he needs God and a kind hand.
Naomi is not a strong believer, but if the naysayers would recall, there is a point where she is talking with God about having put her husband ahead of the Lord. This is the true journey of Christian growth learning to put God first, the human battles of feeling and emotions of a struggling Christian.
I loved that this was a raw emotion and rough western Christian book. The west wasn't a kind area, there was more than even this author could detail, yet she did a fabulous job of bringing the west to this book. She did a fabulous job making faith real and accepting in this book.
Thank you for reminding me that the Lord will take us all, and forgiveness can happen.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 8, 2016
Heather Blanton is a new author to me, and a very good one at that. Reading A Lady in Defiance was like going back in time to the days when I watched "Westerns" on black and white television with my family. Those were good old days! During that era people watched those programs without concern for the outlaws, drunks, gunfights and loose women with low-cut gowns and heavy makeup. They were just good old television shows that we all knew were not indicative of our lives. They were entertainment! We didn't take them seriously. At the same time, reading Heather's book left me with those same feelings of past Westerns.
Varied characters created a depth of humanity and acceptance of the differences in individuals. All types of characters were represented in honest and down-to-earth techniques. This novel is very descriptive and incited many emotions as the story moved along, at a fast pace with no room for boredom.
I enjoyed all aspects of this novel. There is an earthy, authentic, coarseness to the community of Defiance. This is definitely a good versus evil kind of book that kept my attention right through to the end. I highly recommend A Lady in Defiance, and look forward to the sequel!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from The Book Club Network's For Readers Only program in exchange for my honest review. All expressed opinions are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
Varied characters created a depth of humanity and acceptance of the differences in individuals. All types of characters were represented in honest and down-to-earth techniques. This novel is very descriptive and incited many emotions as the story moved along, at a fast pace with no room for boredom.
I enjoyed all aspects of this novel. There is an earthy, authentic, coarseness to the community of Defiance. This is definitely a good versus evil kind of book that kept my attention right through to the end. I highly recommend A Lady in Defiance, and look forward to the sequel!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from The Book Club Network's For Readers Only program in exchange for my honest review. All expressed opinions are my own, and no monetary compensation was received for this review.
January 20, 2015
With free Kindle books, you never know what you're going to get but this book was a pleasant surprise. I found it to be very well written, thoughtful, and interesting. I loved the humor interspersed with the elements of historical romantic fiction. It was fun to get to know the characters and I hope there are sequels!
July 9, 2013
A Lady in Defiance was an enjoyable, interesting (and somewhat scandalous) read. If you want to find out more about what I think, visit my blog http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/....
March 3, 2016
A Lady in Definace, is book one in the Romance in the Rockies Series written by Heather Blanton. Naomi and her husband John on their way to California. They also have Naomi's sisters with them. Rachel is Naomi's older widowed sister and Hannah is their younger sister whom is pregnant and unmarried. They are on a narrow road along a cliff when John's horse is spooked by a snake and the mules pulling the wagon, driven by Naomi, went backwards, sending a wheel of the wagon over the cliff. After getting the horse settled down, Naomi and John were able to get the mules to pull the wagon back on the road. Just when it looked like things were going to be OK, the yoke holding the mules to the wagon broke and one of the mules and John flew over the cliff. The girls continue on by themselves and one night the Lord speaks to Naomi telling them to go to Defiance.
Just as the sisters get to Defiance, Charles McIntyre, the leader of Defiance wins the local mercantile in a poker game. After much talking, McIntyre turns the mercantile over to the sister. McIntyre owns the local bar and has prostitutes. McIntyre's girls do not take well to having the sisters in town and start causing problems for them, especially Rose.
McIntyre has his partner oversee the renovation of the mercantile into a restaurant and inn. His partner starts to have feelings for one of the sisters. The sisters try to spread the Word of the Lord in the mining town. McIntyre wants to make the town a more respectable town to get the railroad to come through.
I liked this story. I likes how despite all the problems the sisters have had they are determined to move forward with their lives and cling to their faith and spread the Word of the Lord. I do however have a hard time imagining a business owner just turning over a building and helping strangers the way McIntyre helps the sister.
I was given the book by the author and Book Club Network for an honest review.
Just as the sisters get to Defiance, Charles McIntyre, the leader of Defiance wins the local mercantile in a poker game. After much talking, McIntyre turns the mercantile over to the sister. McIntyre owns the local bar and has prostitutes. McIntyre's girls do not take well to having the sisters in town and start causing problems for them, especially Rose.
McIntyre has his partner oversee the renovation of the mercantile into a restaurant and inn. His partner starts to have feelings for one of the sisters. The sisters try to spread the Word of the Lord in the mining town. McIntyre wants to make the town a more respectable town to get the railroad to come through.
I liked this story. I likes how despite all the problems the sisters have had they are determined to move forward with their lives and cling to their faith and spread the Word of the Lord. I do however have a hard time imagining a business owner just turning over a building and helping strangers the way McIntyre helps the sister.
I was given the book by the author and Book Club Network for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 169 reviews