2.5-3 stars
This is a difficult book, not only because it's about Lord Blaize Minshom, whom we've come to hate as a horrid BDSM abuser at the Pleasure House, as well as obviously being a man who manipulates and enjoys others' pain in every day life, but also because of the subject matter that we wade into.
It seems as if these books aren't going to ever be about true HEA. Not even just "flawed" people, but damaged people. These aren't typical romances (not even in the erotic-romance category), because they deal with a lot of pain - pain suffered at the hands of others.
Part of my issues with all of this is that, regardless of what's been done to us in our lives or what we've done, at some point, we must take responsibility for our OWN actions. Ultimately, as adults, we choose how we go on - how we behave, how we treat others, how we live our lives. I don't mean by the standards of Society (the "ton") of this day or even of our day; I mean that WE CHOOSE.
So, while I know I'm supposed to see Lord Blaize Minshom in a new light after reading his story, it's still difficult for me to like the man - to feel much empathy for him. And his "change" in this book is almost too much for me to take.
Lord Blaize Minshom has a monster for a father, but one who upholds certain traditions - like The Little Gentlemen's Club, a "fight club" of 12-18 yr old boys 'nominated' by their fathers; except the fathers gamble on the matches, and the losers of the fights are publicly raped by the winners. In fact, Minshom's father kept the tradition alive, by being the 'manager'. He even carefully documented each fight each year.
He expected his son to win, of course - trained him by beating him up throughout his life. His father was even the first to rape him - his first sexual experience. So, of course, Blaize became a winner - a bully, a man hungry for power and domination over other men. A cruel man, seemingly without a heart, who uses and abuses others for his own amusement. Just like his father.
EXCEPT
1. Blaize seemed to like sex with other boys/men. Enough that when his father caught him having sex with Robert Brown, a stable boy that his father threw into the ring as someone for his son to train on, his father had a stroke while beating Robert within an inch of his life. Blaize just allowed his father to lie there, not going for help. Unfortunately, his father didn't die, but slowly recovered. And his father hounded him about how Blaize preferred men to women - his unnatural and damnable nature - how he wasn't a real man.
2. So Blaize married Jane - a woman who defied her family to marry him. A woman who didn't seem to mind his almost insatiable sexual appetite, nor did she seem to mind any of the ways that he wanted to have sex. She willingly did what he wanted and asked. HOW did he find such a woman? She was 17 and he was 19 when they married.
They had a son, Nicholas, who died when he was a toddler - a mysterious death. Blaize had argued with his father about not leaving any heirs, certainly not for The Little Gentlemen's Club, but also not to carry on the Minshom name. And that night, while the little boy was sick with fever and being held in his father's (Blaize's) arms without any servants or nurse around, little Nicky died. His father claimed Blaize killed the child deliberately, to make good on his vow. Jane, in her profound grief and confusion, believed her father-in-law - enough to throw her husband out of Minshom Manor and demand that he never touch her again - that he leave her alone.
In a fit of pique, Blaize made sure that his father saw him and Robert Brown (now Blaize's valet) having sex, and when his father attempted to shoot Brown but Blaize intervened, his father had another stroke - this time a massive one. One that still has him abed at Minshom Manor, where Blaize left him in Jane's care.
So *this* is how Blaize Minshom went into Town seven years ago; this was the supposed start of Lord Minshom and his horrific sexual practices and villainry.
3. In the previous book (Anthony's), we discovered that Major David Grey was one of Minshom's victims. When Anthony came along and willingly submitted to Minshom, Grey was tossed aside. But in this book, we learn there's more to the story... Not only was Major Grey part of The Little Gentlemen's Club, but when he was involved with Minshom, Grey and Robert Brown "fell in love". No details, exactly, but obviously, Minshom allowed and forced the two to have sex, otherwise, how would they.... anyway. So Grey has his own sub-plot this time. He's hopelessly in love with Robert, who won't ever leave Minshom out of misguided loyalty and love for Blaize saving his life twice and allowing him to be his lover - whenever it suits Blaize. (Of course, it's all horridly complicated with fighting, pain, and domination.) So can poor David and Robert get their own HEA?
The book opens with Minshom taking numerous hits from Society, who love to gossip about him, about losing Anthony - about Anthony walking away and choosing Marguerite. Minshom is furious, of course. Then Jane, his wife, shows up and demands that he give her another child. The two of them haven't had sex in 7 years, since Minshom left, and unless I read the book wrong, Minshom hasn't had sex with women since then, either. Only men - only in his horrid way.
Somehow, Jane is able to throw Minshom off his game - off his life. She's able to not only get under his skin, but also to stand up to him. It's quite a battle of wills, and you have to admire Jane's strength. She even shows that she can pick and choose her battles. Minshom tries everything to force her to leave - cutting off her money, forcing her to take back new dresses and purchases so she looks presentable about Town, forcing her to watch Robert suck him off, and even forcing her to watch and participate in his BDSM-heavy-on-the-sadistic sexual activities on the upper floor at the Pleasure House.
Once again, we're faced with men who must have sex with other men. And given this story line and the others we've encountered in this series, where it seems that rape was a common power play between boys at school, punishment by teachers and parents... well, it's amazing to me that any man in Regency-Victorian-Edwardian England wasn't gay or bi-sexual! And to top it off, getting caught having m-m sex was a hanging offense! So everything must be kept so secret... this type of thing is like an infection or cockroaches - they thrive on darkness, secrecy, hiding, until they take over and kill or destroy.
But I digress... because in the midst of all of this - in the midst of Jane coming to fully accept Blaize's kinky and weird ways, we see Blaize changing. He actually shows up at the engagement ball of Anthony and Marguerite only to wish them well. He starts realizing that he might just love his wife.
And then another kink: Another major, Thomas somebody, shows up, offering apologies to Blaize for besting him 3 years in a row in The Little Gentlemen's Club. Thomas thinks he was was Blaize's "first", only to discover that Blaize's father had that honor. But it seems that Thomas is still in love with Blaize and wants a relationship with him. REALLY? When he discovers Blaize has a wife - literally as Blaize and Jane are having public sex at The Pleasure House - Thomas tries to back off. But Jane pleads with him to have sex with them. YIKES! And so, when Blaize does finally scare Jane off, who wants to pick up the pieces, but Thomas?
But Blaize does go back to Minshom Manor after 7 long years. He does find a way into his father's room to tell his father that he'll always care for him. HUH? He doesn't forgive his father, as well he shouldn't. But somehow, that's supposed to give his father peace - to settle what's between them - so his father can finally die. OK. And Blaize makes up with Jane, but tells her that he hopes she'll welcome Thomas into their lives and into their bed. THE END.
I find myself longing for a story about a man who, despite anything in his past, actually falls in love with and prefers a woman. What a change of events that would be. Is Anthony supposed to be that man? I doubt it, since at the end of that previous book, we were led to believe that he and Marguerite might welcome a threesome.
So... while I know I'm supposed to change my mind about Blaize - to see him as a victim and now a changed, healed man... I just can't. Yes, the festering puss was finally dealt with; the wound was finally cleansed. But can someone so damaged truly be healed? Changed? I don't think so. And I still think that Minshom's character is set; he's still going to be cruel, domineering, and sexually sadistic. It's such a part of who he is, even if he tempers it, I don't believe he can change and be the "hero". And while I admire Jane, I think she's masochistic; she won't change, either, but always welcome whatever Blaize throws at her, because that's her nature. Which, IMO, isn't a real HEA, but I suppose it's as good as it gets for these two... or three, if you count the addition of this Major Thomas.
Honestly, I don't know if I can continue reading these books. They're titillating and addicting in their own way, but I'm finding them so depressing. So many damaged people. And we're supposed to welcome their HEA as if they're truly happily ever afters... happy endings - change - healing. With the exception of Anthony and Marguerite and possibly Madame Helene aned Lord Philip, I don't truly think anyone's been healed or has a HEA. Valentin and Sara still have the question of Peter, and possibly Abigail. Abigail has faded to the background, as has their child; Peter seems more attached to Valentin than ever. And now Lord Blaize and Jane? Not sure I want to learn the depravity of Helene's twins, Christian and Lisette.