I thought this would turn out to be a tedious read, because right in the very first paragraph of her prologue Pilar Wayne offers up a misquote from what is likely the most iconic role her husband ever played. In describing the mountain meadow scene from True Grit Pilar claims that Ned Pepper, played by Robert Duvall, called Rooster Cogburn "a one-eyed, fat, old man". Any Duke fan knows that Duvall actually says: "I'd call that bold talk for a one-eyed fat man." The word "old" in there actually breaks up the rhythm of the insult.
As you can imagine, I read the rest of the book with a critical eye. Sure enough, I spotted some more mistakes. For the aquatic fistfight in Sons of Katie Elder Wayne is dragged off the shore into the water, not pulled from a horse as claimed by Pilar. And on Page 173 she identifies Rita Hayworth as Rita Hayward, but that could be a deliberate feminine insult instead of a sloppy mistake. Pilar was rather jealous of the pretty ladies who had been rubbing up against her old man.
In spite of the minor mistakes, I found that I was intrigued by the goings-on in the Wayne family. Pilar starts right at Day One, revealing that Duke was supposed to have been named Robert Michael Morrison and that name was duly entered on the birth certificate. The Robert was changed to Marion by his mother in order to curry favor with a moneyed relative. There are all sorts of details about Wayne family dynamics and peregrinations in here. Some of Duke's confidences about his feelings for his parents are contained in these pages, and I kept wondering if he would have said anything if he had known the words would end up in print.
I'm always a little reluctant to take memoirs like this at face value, because essentially the reader gets one person's point of view unleavened by any input from any of the other principals in the story. It shocked me to learn that the Duke had a nasty streak, but I had to ask myself: "nasty in response to what?" There are two sides to every story, and one has always to bear that in mind when he is absorbing information from either side.
I'll add one bit of a Duke speech I find pertinent to our times. Everyone knows he was a staunch Republican, as far right as you can get. But when Jimmy Carter was elected, Duke gave a speech welcoming him to the Presidency which concluded: "I know I'm considered a member of the loyal opposition -accent on loyal. I'd have it no other way." Wouldn't it be nice to see more of that thinking these days?
All things considered, I think this is an essential read for any John Wayne fan. Of course Pilar was his third wife, so the reader is coming in near the end of the story here. It doesn't help that Pilar seems to have been somewhat at odds with Wayne's progeny from his first marriage, particularly Michael, and she gets a few swipes in at him in here. In the nicest possible way, naturally. Too bad his other wives didn't put their thoughts on paper as well.