I had a hard time getting into this book because I could not keep track of the characters. It was hard to tell what was going on at first and to know which people the author meant for me to keep track of because they were going to reappear in the coming pages. It seems like the reader gets dropped into the middle of a movie, so it's hard to know where you are or what precisely is going on. But once I decided I was going to stick with it, I did get it all sorted out and began to care about what happened to Rat, her mother and her brother. Once I got into the meat of the story, there were many details I would love to discuss with other readers, such as talking about Rat's mother and her refusal to believe the truth of what Rat reported to her. Was the main character justified in leaving home? Was the ending satisfactory? Was it plausible? I liked the characters, as far as feeling like they were truly drawn, and I was interested in the plot, but the other elements of Eberstadt's writing were a little harder to pin down. I can't say that any of the writing was impressive as far as the language used by the author. The descriptions of the setting were OK but not outstanding. I had read a review in which the reviewer loved the winds that were described in this novel, so I was expecting to blown away (ha ha) by that detail of the writing, to be more engrossed in the setting, to get a real feel for the place where the events occurred. But I found instead that I was more impressed by the reviewer's fascination than I was by the original text in the book. Anyway, I guess I expected more from this read.