This was a fun and creative little read that took me back to CS Lewis’ fantasy works, like the Space Trilogy or Till We Have Faces.
I can imagine some people being bothered by the creative license of it all, but it’s fantasy fiction, not a theology/doctrine book, and I can appreciate that.
I found it interesting to consider the birth scene, not from the perspective of the nativity in Luke’s or Matthew’s gospel, but from John’s Revelation, in Revelation 12. I can’t say I’ve read that cosmic battle that raged and connected it to the birth of Jesus before - that was new to me. I’m certainly not a Revelation scholar. I’d like to read up more on the history of that interpretation.
The only major negative came on the very last page…
“He also tells us who matters. You do. Imagine, if God will fight such a fight to save you… He must really think you’re worth the effort.”
Yes, we have immense value as image bearers…but this feels a little too…I’m not sure. Me-centered, maybe? I think I I just cringe when we describe God’s rescue mission in terms that highlight our value and worth, rather than highlighting His chief objective: to highlight His glorious grace. His highest priority in this plan isn’t to affirm the value of the ones being saved, but to highlight the glory of the One doing the saving. The primary effect of the gospel isn’t for us to say “Wow, I’m special” but “Wow, He’s good.”
His arrival and sacrifice for mankind as a huge demonstration of HIS love, grace and mercy - not our worthiness.
Perhaps this is too nit-picky - after all, I understand the sentiment to affirm others’ value and inherent worth. Forgive me if I’m being unfair. But I just believe that our greatest need isn’t to tell the story in a way that highlights our worth, but to tell it in a way that captures our imagination and deepens our affection for the glorious grace of a God who loves us with a ridiculously inexplicable love – us! People who DON’T deserve it and aren’t worthy.
When we emphasize our spiritual neediness, it highlights His grace. But when we speak of our worthiness, it feels like it dims His grace and steals from His light, moving the spotlight slightly toward us.
I’d love to change the line from “He must really think you’re worth the effort” to “He must really be full of unimaginable love and grace to leave heaven and come for people like you and me..”