Pros: a pretty thrilling read if you like high fantasy. I am a fair weather fantasy reader myself, and it was nice to dive into something like this that I haven’t read in a long time. Especially towards the last few hundred pages, I couldn’t put it down. Some nice little twists and turns here and there to keep you on your feet. Compelling characters, especially a lot of the side interludes. I can’t wait to see if and when story lines come together. Very impressive world building, on the whole. Like, a massive project that has been undertaken, and I can tell it’s a labour of love. Massive props.
Cons: clunky language was my biggest issue with the book; I say, if you’re going to get real fantastical with the world, go all the way when it comes to language and names. Make up a new language, new names, new curse words, new gods. Don’t just take regular old English names and words and whatever and change a couple letters to make them into fantasy names. Like, it’s weird to me that this land is populated by people who are SO far removed from anything we’d describe as “Earth”, but they still say “fuck”. That’s just my pet peeve tho, and I’m just one dude who has never written a book. So. I just found it took me out of the world that the author has clearly been hard at work constructing.
Also, a lot of sexual violence in the book that kind of comes out of left field. Sometimes bordering on fetishistic. It’s a gory, bloody, violent read for sure….but there’s something about the rape/rape adjacent scenes that feels out of place to me. I don’t want to say that fantasy worlds aren’t subject to sexual violence, I just found them almost….tacked into scenes as an afterthought, like “how can I HAMMER home that this person is a bad person? Oh by the way, they’re also a rapist”. So I suppose a trigger warning is a good idea, for anyone reading this review.