The Big Book of Christian Mysticism: The Essential Guide to Contemplative Spirituality

by Carl McColman

Mysticism is a topic many people associate with eastern spiritual practices such as Zen Buddhism or yoga. But Christianity has its own mystical tradition with a long and rich history that reaches back to the New Testament -- and remains surprisingly relevant today. The Big Book of Christian Mysticism explores this rich tradition and shows how it can be a powerful tool for transformation and the experience of the Divine.

One of the greatest Christian theologians of the twentieth century, Karl Rahner, once said "The Christian of the future will be a mystic or will not exist at all." Such a statement challenges Christians of our day (we live in Rahner's future!) to consider the role of mysticism in the Christian life. The Big Book of Christian Mysticism does just that.

As an introduction to Christian mysticism and an exploration of why mysticism remains relevant in our time, the first part of the book explores the question of what mysticism is, examining its Biblical roots, its paradoxical nature, and how Christian mysticism has evolved over time. The second part of the book considers how mysticism can make a difference in the lives of ordinary Christians today, considering how spiritual practices such as lectio divina , meditation, and contemplative prayer can foster a deeper openness to Divine presence. An extensive list of the greatest Christian mystics, a recommended reading list, and a bibliography round out this in-depth introduction.

Selected as one of the best spiritual books of 2010 by spiritualityandpractice.com, The Big Book of Christian Mysticism has been highly praised by a variety of spiritual teachers and authors.

Genres: Spirituality, Religion, Christianity, Mysticism, Nonfiction, Christian, Reference

320 pages, Paperback

First published August 1, 2010

About the author

Carl McColman writes about the spiritual life, covering topics like mysticism (The Big Book of Christian Mysticism), contemplative prayer (Answering the Contemplative Call), monastic spirituality (Befriending Silence), Celtic traditions (An Invitation to Celtic Wisdom), Paganism (The Complete Idiot's Guide to Paganism), and Wicca (When Someone You Love is Wiccan).

He is also a blogger (www.patheos.com/blogs/carlmccolman) and podcaster(www.encounteringsilence.com) .

Why did Carl McColman, a Catholic author, write books about Paganism? Read the answer here: www.patheos.com/blogs/carlmccolman/20...

Reviews

[David Huff · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Mysticism does not change the gospel. But it does shine an entirely new light on it that can help you see what has always been there in powerful and exciting new ways." -- Carl McColman

The very term "mysticism" to some may sound ... well .... mysterious, or even a little spooky. If that was your reaction, then this thorough and well-written book will bring helpful clarity and perspective in understanding a facet of Christian spirituality that has deep roots in church history. This "Big Book" is the more comprehensive companion to McColman's "Little Book of Christian Mysticism", which I reviewed here about a month ago (primarily a resource book of great quotes from mystics past and present).

Christian Mysticism describes those who, through contemplative reading (especially of Scripture), meditation, prayer and silence seek a deeper and more intimately personal relationship with God. This book covers the topic very well, and also contains a generous, annotated reading list of many other books on this subject. Highly recommended.

One serendipitous note - I by chance discovered that the author and I live about 30 minutes from one another. I had the delight of spending part of an afternoon with him last week, made a new friend who is warm, engaging and very knowledgeable, and enjoyed a great and edifying time of conversation together.

[Jessica Manning]

There was time about 7 years ago when I was dabbling with the idea of Christian Mysticism and embarking on a journey towards being a contemplative myself. There is definitely something about that way of life that I am undeniably attracted to. I started reading everything I could get my hands onto from St.John of the Cross, Thomas Merton, Evelyn Underhill, Madame Guyon and so many others. Carl McColman had commented on a blog I had written in regards to the practice of Lectio Devina at that time and because of this, I was lead to his personal blog. I found him to be very interesting and a great source for learning. A lot of things have happened in life since those days and now I find myself on a different path with Christ. Just a few months ago I picked up this book as I had been waiting for years to read it and now I see that his theology is radically different from what I've grown to learn as Truth. I haven't finished the book but I intend on it and will re-write this review.

[Deacon Tom (Feeling Better) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Superb in Every Way

I absolutely loved this book. It is actually a reference book for those who want to go beyond recited and rote prayers (no judgement from me).

Give this a try. It is a good blend of theological and practical.

[David · Rating 3 out of 5]

If you’re looking for a decent introduction to Christian mysticism, with some ideas for contemplative practice, this book could be a good place to start.

Overall, its a good intro. There are two reasons I hesitate to give it a glowing review.

1. Its kind of dated. In one chapter the author emphasizes the importance of going to church. He lists a variety of different churches, including “Emerging Churches.” For those who forget or weren’t around, the Emerging Church was a thing in the 2000s. It’s not a thing anymore as other terminology has taken over. Most Emerging church leaders either joined Mainline churches, went back to evangelical or left the faith altogether.

This is a minor point. But in a book where everything else is not really rooted in any specific real-world time, this portion sticks out like a sore thumb.

Also, the whole argument for going to church rings kind of lacking in self-reflection. He is writing to those who may desire to be spiritual, but not want to be part of a community. Yet he misses the point that a good many people have dealt with trauma from church. Churches have hurt lots of people. Recognizing the damage church has done to many ought to be at the forefront. Not doing so and practically going the “suck it up and go to church” route rings hollow.

I agree on the importance of community. I simply did not like how this section was written.

2. Paradoxes are cool - not everything is a paradox.

The longest chapter, and the best, lists a series of paradoxes that mysticism embraces. For example, “God is One. God is also Three.” And “Pray methodically. Prayer cannot just be a method.” Good stuff. But the final one he offers is that “Heave is a free gift. Hell is reserved for those who reject divine love.”

Nope.

You cannot look at the idea of an image-bearing human suffering forever, unending torture, and slap the word “paradox” on it to justify it. He spends two pages on this and does not examine any relevant scripture. Though he does, maddeningly, quote CS Lewis to say the doors from hell are locked from the inside. I get that this is not a book on heaven and hell. But he’s the one who brought it up.

Just calling something a paradox is not helpful. If a Father loves on child and tortures the other, this is not a paradox. This is a contradiction. Yet when it comes to God, all of a sudden our understanding of love changes?

Further, plenty of the mystics in the church tradition, including those referenced in this book, either believe in universal salvation or are sympathetic to it: Origen, Gregory of Nyssa, Julian of Norwich, Richard Rohr.

Like the first point, this is a minor point in the book. But it sticks out and really adds nothing. It actually detracts, for it forces the reader to wonder what other complex issues were oversimplified and misrepresented over the course of the book?

Overall, as I said above, this is a decent book to learn the basics of Christian mysticism. But I imagine you could find a better book out there. Or maybe just dive right in to reading the mystics - George MacDonald, Gregory of Nyssa, The Cloud of Unknowing, Evagrius, Thomas Merton, Theresa of Avila, and so on.

Maybe this is why I’m so tepid on it. I’ve spent time reading these writers. Primary sources are better than secondary, or at least, better than this secondary source.

[Christine · Rating 4 out of 5]

A really good introduction on Christian mysticism and its role in history; as well as how it can be practiced in practical ways. If you're new to the topic this could be very beneficial. At times, the author's personal views obviously shaped how he discussed other religions, but read those with discernment and you should be fine.

[Elizabeth Forshee · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book answered and confirmed so many questions/thoughts I've had about Christian Mysticism in a concise and provocative way. I enjoyed the first half more than the last as I found it quite defining. I felt the second half, which dove more into the practicalities of mysticism, to be a bit lacking, but I realize there is more literature in which to read that would put more flesh onto the practice or understanding. That truly would be my only complaint. Recently there are books watering down the depth and beauty of Christian Mysticism in order to make it trendy while also leaving out the lasting historical treasures that are the Church's legacy, I believe this book redeems much of that and gives Christian Mysticism it's dignity once more as well as reinstates its place in our worship and pursuit of God. For anyone wondering about Christian Mysticism, I think this is a good introduction to the many nuances that make up this aspect of our Christian faith. I found it gave me words, and confirmation for so many experiences I've had in my faith journey that have often been disregarded or ignored by the evangelical church that have in turn left me wanting. I believe this is a part of our faith that will continue to make its way back into our way of worship in the church due to the richness, beauty, and genuineness that it fosters.

[Joey Dye · Rating 4 out of 5]

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Many may come to this book expecting either biographies of famous Christian mystics or a how-to guide for starting on the path. This is not such a book, although there are cameos of mystics and guidelines for how to engage certain practices as lectio and contemplative prayer. Rather this book reads like an overview and manifesto for Christian mysticism as it is lived, embodied, and experienced in the faith as it is lived today. Carl McColman does an excellent job of making this a book for Christians of many traditions, particularly liturgical traditions, rather than a book solely for those of one particular perspective.

[Logan Streondj · Rating 5 out of 5]

A great introduction to Christian Mysticism for lay practitioners and those just starting out or curious about mysticism.
It talks a little about the history of mysticism in general and how most mystics are actually interfaith since mystical experience is the underpinning of all faiths.
It then talks about Christian mysticism and that while in Orthodoxy it was preserved in some other areas it was lost, and is only now being found again.
It also talks about how to start with Christian mysticism one should join a Christian church, and that it doesn't have to be a supportive one, as few are (according to the author), and then to read up about Christian mysticism and practice various forms of prayer, including reading the bible, centering prayer and contemplative prayer. Also has long reading lists of further reading at the back.

[Christian · Rating 3 out of 5]

Decent absolute beginners book on christian mysticism which basically showed me that this isn't my cup of tea (anymore) - to vast are the theological, ontological and what have you differences. But for everyone else, this is a easy to comprehend entrance, although the work comes afterwards. What I disliked is the often used sweeping generalisation of "xy is all about..." (where I always find myself shaking my head) and the depressing chapter about paradoxa, only that he lumps everything under that title which only remotely makes the impression of being at odds with another notion. Albeit not being very strong on the philosophy-side, his appendix with a lot of ressources is actually quite valuable.

[Brett Folkman · Rating 5 out of 5]

I absolutely LOVED this book!! I'm a big fan of the historic mystical writers, Julian being my favorite. Carl's book is very well written, accessible to the average person who might or might not know much about Christian Mysticism. He isn't preachy or dogmatic and allows the reader to keep a very open mind about topics covered. It's very non-judgmental and the key messages of love and seeking unity with the Divine hits the mark! I'll be reading some of his other books now - a big fan!!

Brett Folkman, Doctor of Ministry

[Wendy Dominguez · Rating 4 out of 5]

Excellent description of Christian mysticism including the historical and biblical references. Provides helpful guidance on how to develop one’s contemplative prayer life. This is a great book for those who are looking for a deeper, more meaningful relationship with God, following a path that is aligned but different from the more common Christian rote prayers. References also provided on history’s great Christian mystics and recommended reading to enrich one’s knowledge and understanding of Christian mysticism.

[Lori Shinkō Snyder · Rating 3 out of 5]

I read this for a class on Christian mysticism and it was at times inspirational, and at times painful. Inspirational in that we are all mystics if we open to this beautiful practice. Painful since the author occasionally speaks of Zen Buddhist practices, but incorrectly for most all instances. As a Zen Buddhist reading this, I was saddened that the author is spreading wrong perceptions of my faith. I hope he finds resolution and writes an updated edition that omits these correlations.

[Gilbert Donahue · Rating 5 out of 5]

excellent, well-written explanation of mysticism for the modern Christian

McColman has written a fine overview of mysticism in the Christian tradition, tracing it from the time of the apostles to the 20th century. He demystifies the concept and the practice, provides useful pointers, and references many famous mystics and their experiences. Highly recommended for those interested in this subject, and experiential religion.

[Abigail]

This was another book for my Foundations of Christian Spirituality class and I found this one to be the easiest to read, everything was explained in fairly simple terms. I really enjoyed the author's discussion about mysticism and how it doesn't necessarily mean "new age". McColman really knows what he's talking about! I will be referring back to this one again and again.

[Neil Saltmarsh · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a really good read for beginners to intermediate which most of us would be. This should be re-read. If you have read many texts on Lectio Divina there is not too much you will learn but some of the other parts are quite informative and explained well. The appendix for further reading will spur me further.

[Christopher · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a long read for me as it took a while to digest all that McColman shares. He opens up the reader to understand Christian Mysticism in all of its complexities. For many, this book will open up Christianity in a new way. I highly recommend this book for anyone interesting Christianity.

[Meade Adams · Rating 4 out of 5]

This was a good book. A very thorough examination of Christian Mysticism, what it is and what it isn’t. It also provides an entire section on the practicality of it for current seekers or practitioners. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone interested in Mysticism

[Angi · Rating 5 out of 5]

I’ve been studying mysticism for a little over a year now. This book brought all my thoughts together in an orderly fashion. The reading lists were particularly helpful - showing me I’ve read a lot of mystical writings in the past. I guess I’m already a mystic.

[Jonathan Jones · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed this book, both for the information it provided and the inspiration it gives. The author explains what mysticism is; and is not! I see it as a distillation of of Christian mysticism and what other authors one can turn to for guidance.

[Kenneth Mortimer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Pure Gold

This is my first serious read on mysticism. I was not disappointed. This is a treasure trove of resources, both the core writings and the appendices, which illuminate the path to Divine union.

[Andrew L · Rating 5 out of 5]

so good

This book makes me excited about Christianity again.
It unfolds mystery, and digs through scripture in ways my Soul has been craving. I am almost done with the book and will be sad when I reach the final page.

[Julie Girardi · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved. Use this book for reference from time to time.

[Jared Walker · Rating 5 out of 5]

I feel really blessed to have found this. Carl is a great writer, and this book left me really inspired.

[joe leal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fabulous, essential very important book like no other very comprehensive highly recommended

[Tim Olson · Rating 3 out of 5]

The book is a kind of primer on Christian Mysticism for those unfamiliar. I listened to the Audible book which had perhaps the worst narration I've ever experienced.

[Lori Ingram · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a heave subject not to be taken lightly. Yet I found it deep, thought provoking and informative. I want to get a hard copy ànd read it again.

[Brian · Rating 2 out of 5]

This book is a mix of good and bad. McColman covers his topic well, offering readers a clear picture of what contemplative spirituality is like and the practices it involves. But he leans too much into paradox, in my view, to the point of making unbiblical assertions and blatant contradictions. For example, his statements about kenosis suggest that Jesus emptied himself of the divine nature itself, while his statements about theosis and deification suggest an ontological blurring of distinctions between human persons and God himself. He says that "everything that reveals God also conceals him," a statement I find hard to square with the scriptural teaching on divine revelation. Ultimately, I have concerns with certain beliefs germane to mysticism itself.

[Caroline Mathews · Rating 4 out of 5]

Although not really essential to one's library, mine represented as it is with similar books, this is indeed a BIG book. The thing about mysticism is that there is really no guide, history doesn't help, and the person who "chooses" to become a mystic has to work infinitely harder than the one born to it. The subject is indeed a challenge and one worth learning about.

Mother had her angels and her angelic-related experiences, Grandmother listened to and with her heart which was full of the Holy Spirit, and I was blessed to have my mystical experiences as a child so that I grew up knowing how all-encompassing yet unfathomable the mystery.

I am saying (gentle smile) that reading books and articles, blogs and self-help manuals by famous and well-learned authors is invaluable but not the skeleton key to participation in the many faces of mysticism.

I became engrossed in the book for various reasons and therefore tried to conjure up a bit of humor whenever McColeman quoted sources and proceeded to paraphrase them. Also when he enlightened his reader as to what he just said. "In other words...."

[Jesse · Rating 5 out of 5]

Having studied mysticism in a secular, academic setting, I can attest to the difficulty of writing about something that truly is ineffable. Carl does a terrific job of attempting to express the inexpressible. Some may not like that this is not a How-To guide, but as the author makes clear, there is no such thing as a How-To guide to mysticism. He points us in the right direction and gives us plenty of resources in the back of the book to continue in your own, unique quest.

[Yaholo · Rating 4 out of 5]

By his own admission, Carl McColman sets out to revisit the initial efforts of Evelyn Underhill in bringing the "Ivory Tower" distance of mysticism to the life of everyday Christians. I think Carl does a great job of "hand-holding" (and I mean that in the best sense) and in that sense is more verbose and repetitive than Evelyn's style. Those finding the somewhat aged work of Underhill a bit inaccessible will most certainly enjoy Carl's approach.