I enjoyed this. The characters were pretty vivid and likeable, and the situation was compelling. I particularly liked the hero and heroine, and I related to both of them well. The kid was okay, if a bit surly. The writing was fine, and the dialogue was realistic and occasionally quite charming. It held my attention, and made me glad to read it.
However, I can honestly say I hated, hated, hated this frigging town. This book could not have a full HEA, in my opinion, unless it ended with them driving off, and possibly tossing a match behind them. Why we're supposed to see this place as idyllic is beyond me. Perhaps if you thought old Bomont in Footloose was an ideal place to settle down, you might dig this place. As for me, that's a big no.
One caveat for possible readers: This book was rather churchy; it didn't put me off too badly, as the spirituality is fairly liberal and personal, but it did surprise me, seeing as how this is not an "inspirational romance," nor does the cover/back copy really give you much indication it's a Christian novel, aside from a slight mention of the heroine teaching Sunday School. Still, this is balanced quite nicely with an honest, non-preachy romance, and even a good element of heat, so I was able to roll with it. Your experience may vary, of course, but I still liked it a good deal, and found this to be a pretty realistic portrayal of love alongside religious views. It was actually kind of nice to see spiritual, yet not saintly, people.
One criticism I can give is that the minor "crime story" feels very tacked on, and inconsequential - a dope panic gripping Mayberry, and not a major part of the story. This didn't bother me too much, though, since I was only focusing on the romance, and didn't really notice the brief mentions of the crime "B plot".
Further, there was some mild, typical anti-women stuff, largely regarding the common romance novel upset over the potential sissification of boys that characters often express about women playing too large a role in the raising of male children. It's irksome here, but not constant, and not too over the top. It's mostly confined to pretty conventional "I don't understand women" and "women are silly/panicky/emotional idiots" stuff, which is pretty hard to avoid when reading in this genre. Still the hero tends to come out looking fairly rational about gender, and often took an admirable stance against the heroine's antique father.
Overall, a nice read.