Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

DC Connie Childs #4

The Shrouded Path

Rate this book
An irresistible autumnal mystery helmed by a complex heroine, perfect for fans of Val McDermid. November, 1957: Six teenage girls walk in the churning Derbyshire mists. Their voices carrying across the fields, they follow the old train tracks into the dark tunnel of the Cutting. Only five appear on the other side. October, 2014: a dying mother, feverishly fixated on a friend from her childhood, makes a 'Find Valerie.' Mina's elderly mother had never discussed her childhood with her daughter before. So who was Valerie Where does her obsession spring from DC Connie Childs is partnered up with new arrival to Bampton, Peter Dahl. Following up on what seems like a simple natural death, DC Childs' old instincts kick in, pointing her right back to one cold evening in 1957. As Connie starts to broaden her enquiries, the investigation begins to spiral increasingly close to home.

Audio CD

First published September 4, 2018

45 people are currently reading
445 people want to read

About the author

Sarah Ward

10 books314 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
169 (23%)
4 stars
339 (47%)
3 stars
161 (22%)
2 stars
34 (4%)
1 star
5 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews
Profile Image for Paul.
1,184 reviews74 followers
August 7, 2018
The Shrouded Path – The Mysteries of the Peak District

Sarah Ward has once again brought DC Connie Childs back to Bampton, a quiet Peak District Town, where time stopped in about 1950. Or so it seems. Once again Sarah Ward has delivered a macabre masterpiece, that deals with the present while looking back to 1957.

Connie Childs is busy working away chasing up paper work and checking up on unexplained deaths, Bampton has not been this quiet for a while. It does not help that DI Sadler has actually bothered to go on a holiday and Matthews is acting up in the role and is making sure all the paperwork is up to date, she does not want Sadler pulling her up about it when he is back.

Connie is given a new partner DC Dahl who has transferred in from Glossop, which is on the edges of Derbyshire, could all most be in Greater Manchester. They are cannot find anything suspicious, but both have a gut instinct that something is not right. When a suspicious death in hospital things seems to be connected, but they cannot quite see how. With what looks like a saline drip murder, reminiscent of the murders at Stepping Hill Hospital not to far away, Sadler is called back from holiday.

What they do not realise is they will have to discover what happened in 1957 to crack the case. For Sadler that means things are a little too close to home. Especially when the drowned village of Derwent is central to the story. A story that stands in the mists of time and only ever reveals itself when Ladybower reservoir levels drop.

While Sadler slowly puts the picture together, Connie Childs has a more important task of finding a missing vulnerable teenager who has been missing. This teenager seems to be the centre of everything that has been happening, but not sure how.

I love what Sarah Ward writes, and always is able to keep my Mancunian prejudices alive about the Peak District towns. Down here in the valleys of the Peak we tend to think of people up there as owners of three armed cardigans and six fingered gloves, where your brother can also be your uncle!

Once again Sarah Ward has written a macabre thriller that draws the reader in and keeps them hooked throughout. Sarah Ward is one of the most able crime writers we have at the moment.
Profile Image for Joanne Robertson.
1,405 reviews647 followers
September 10, 2018
Oh what a twisty path this was to follow! Having read and loved all the previous DC Connie Child’s books I was thrilled when I got a copy of The Shrouded Path to read. It’s one of my very favourite series, with likeable characters and a setting that has become almost a character in its own right. The Derbyshire Peak District has never before seemed quite so chilling and eerie as when Sarah Ward explores the area she obviously loves and knows well.

When Mina visits her mother in hospital, in her confusion the older woman says that she has seen an old school friend but then remembers that she can’t as she is dead! This leads Mina into some complex investigations as it is obviously very important to her dying mother. But what’s the connection to the schoolgirls at the start of the novel, when one girl of a group of six girls goes into a tunnel and doesn’t come out again? And who is the mysterious Valerie?

The relationships between the characters and the slowly built storyline were the most enjoyable parts of The Shrouded Path for me. DI Sadler is away on “holiday” for a week when he unwittingly meets self employed gardener Mina, thus involving him in the search for her mother’s schoolfriend. And there was a feel of “An American Werewolf in London” at one point with the unfriendly and unhelpful locals in the village pub that made me wonder what the whole community were trying to hide.

Connie is working with Dahl, a new addition to the team, as they start to tie together cases that may be connected. Her new colleague breathed a new lease of life into the station and worked really well so I do hope that he stays for a bit as I really liked him. The investigation was as twisty and imaginative as ever, I rarely manage to interpret the clues dropped along the trail that Sarah Ward leaves but I enjoy her books all the more for that.

A perfectly pitched and warmly received storyline that was a great addition to this much loved series for me.

Profile Image for Kim.
2,691 reviews11 followers
January 4, 2019
This is the fourth in the crime series featuring D.C. Connie Childs and set in my home county of Derbyshire. Wonderful characters, including the landscape itself, combine with a gripping storyline to make yet another fabulous read from this relatively new author. More please, Sarah! 9.5/10.
Profile Image for Christopher Williams.
629 reviews2 followers
January 26, 2019
Very good police procedural set in the Peak District. I enjoyed the other books in this series and this is also great. Set partly in 1957 and the present, a technique which seems to work very well in thrillers now. A convoluted plot that is almost impossible to out-guess but is told at a good pace and all unfolds convincingly for me.
Profile Image for Noelle.
Author 8 books288 followers
October 6, 2018
Set in Derby the reader is faced with fear, change, an urban legend…or is it? secrets, the past, guilt, village mentality, childhood relationships, jealousy, friendships and the search for the truth.

Wowsers! What a fantastically chilling opening chapter – eery, atmospheric and had me biting my nails in anticipation of what would happen next! 😱 The story has a dual timeline, expertly written so as not to confuse the reader and told in three parts from third person POV. There is a huge mystery happening and I loved the flavour of urban legend woven into the mix – dabbling on the verge of horror, I simply loved this aspect! This author has a knack for creating characters that seem real and that readers are easily drawn to, so it’s no wonder that I raced through the pages in record time. I was hooked, plain and simple, and enjoyed every moment of this read!

The dual timeline allows the reader to get to know characters from both the past and present – and what a bunch of characters it was! I adore DC Connie Childs – she is just wonderfully written – a no nonsense attitude and determination to solve a case, I just find her to always be relatable on all levels. I even warmed to Sadler in this novel and loved the fact that a newbie, Dahl, was also thrown into the mix. The banter between Dahl and Childs was awesome and I can’t wait to see where the author takes this.

Another character I want to mention is Mina Kemp – I was unsure about my feelings throughout the whole story…and I loved that! She came across as confident but also very secretive and I wondered how reliable she was throughout… mistrust just oozed from her! Fantabulous!!

I also wanted to mention the sense of place in this novel – I thought this was superbly done! The small village setting where everyone knows your business, gossip is rife but “outsiders” are not welcome was delivered perfectly. Living in a small village myself, I felt like an outsider for many years, and could relate to the experience well!

There are so many other characters and bits I want to mention but I feel this may take away from the whole reading experience so will zip my lips! 🤐 However, I do want to say that with each novel, this series is just going from strength to strength!

Do I recommend this read? OMFG I absolutely do! I am a huge fan of Sarah Ward and if you love compelling plots, a unique but believable cast of characters and an absolutely unsettling sense of place – this book…this series…is for you! I can’t wait to see where the author takes us next!
Profile Image for Cleopatra  Pullen.
1,551 reviews323 followers
September 11, 2018
With its tale split between the past in 1957 and the present, this book certainly didn’t disappoint and at the risk of being repetitive this was even better than the three that preceded it.

One November evening in 1957 six teenage girls walked into the train tunnel at The Cutting, but only five made it out again. What happened to the sixth is shrouded in a mystery as murky as the mists that swirled around the Derbyshire landscape.

In 2014 Mina Kemp is sitting by her mother’s bed in hospital. Hilary is dying but she has become unusually agitated believing that she has seen her childhood friend. She begs Mina to find Valerie and despite not knowing where to start, her mother never having mentioned Valerie before Mina determines to do her bidding.

Meanwhile the Bampton police should be having a quiet time of it. With just one natural death on the books to follow-up while DI Sadler is on his holidays it is only the temporary elevation of Matthews in his absence that is causing the work to be more arduous than needs be. However there is the new DC, Peter Dahl to show the ropes to so they pay a visit to the deceased, Nell Colley’s home, to see if there is anything at all suspicious about her death.

This series is everything you could want from a crime fiction novel. Even though it is part of a series each book is entirely self-contained, although of course the characters develop from book to book. One of my favourite aspects is that all the characters are great, they are all genuine people, police as we like to imagine our local police force to be; caring and diligent with an absolute drive to get to the truth. This isn’t a series overburdened by police politics or gripes about how the force has changed. These are detectives in the old mode, ones that really want to detect. Of course one of the most striking The setting is superb, as one who has holidayed in the area the village of Bampton is as you’d imagine a typical village in the area to be and by taking us back as far as 1957 that feeling s reinforced even more in The Shrouded Path. Best of all there are multiple threads that are meticulously plotted so that there is a real sense of satisfaction at a well-told story by the time you turn the last page.

In a book that changes from past to present and back again we get a flavour of life in the 1950s not by way of obvious signposted items but from the everyday context from a girl not allowed to sing carols before Christmas Eve (and not arguing about her father’s strict order) to the simpler times where life was about making your own entertainment, riding bicycles to choir practice and secrets being hidden well away from prying eyes.

This is the perfect autumnal read – my only disappointment is now I need to wait a while before I learn what Sarah Ward will serve up next for DC Connie Childs.
Profile Image for Kerrie.
1,292 reviews
September 9, 2018
Susan definitely saw 6 girls enter the tunnel and then only 5 emerged at the other end. She walked through the tunnel in trepidation but did not find the missing girl. For her it simply confirmed the sinister and evil nature of the place. After that she avoided going near the tunnel and and years passed, then decades.

Six decades later Mina's mother Hilary is hospitalised with an aggressive cancer. She has a raging temperature which doesn't seem to respond to treatment. Hilary becomes frightened when she receives a visit from someone from her past. She is unable to explain much to her daughter Mina about who this person is. At one stage she tells Mina that she killed Valerie, that Valerie is dead, and then asks Mina to find Valerie. When Hilary dies Mina becomes determined to find Valerie, but then the possibility arises that Hilary has been murdered.

This story is a real page turner. The story is full of mysteries and fascinating scenarios.
Profile Image for Anke.
2,506 reviews97 followers
September 16, 2018
Not as good as the other books, but still very engaging. Parts were a bit slow.
Profile Image for Jo.
3,877 reviews141 followers
September 28, 2018
DC Connie Childs and her fellow Bampton detectives find themselves investigating a couple of mysterious deaths that link back to the 1950s. Another excellent novel from Sarah Ward.
217 reviews4 followers
April 12, 2025
An enjoyable story which jogged along and had a few twists and surprises. The characters were well drawn and the writing style easy.

I did find the police procedural side of the story rather superficial and some of the coincidences a little too unlikely but not enough to spoil the flow.

6 out of 10
Profile Image for Lance Greenfield.
Author 31 books252 followers
November 23, 2021
What I immediately loved about this story was the familiarity that I had with the setting. Having grown up in the area of North Derbyshire and South Yorkshire, I felt very at home. Even though the author, who also comes from the area, has skilfully interwoven reality with fiction, I found it easy to imagine the land that I know.

I am often disturbed and distracted by stories that switch between times. They can be difficult to follow. This one begins with the mystery of a girl who disappears in 1957 and moves to the present and back again. However, it works. Part of the enjoyment of reading this book is trying to work out the connections between the people in the past and in the present.

The characters, and their relationships and misplaced loyalties are really well developed. There is plenty of tension and mystery. The main character is DC Connie Childs, who is a thorough investigator. In this book, she is joined by DC Peter Dahl, who I really like. I hope that he sticks around in future episodes. There was a minor slip in the middle of the book when he was temporarily promoted to DS but he soon reverted to his correct rank.

The story is very well written. It draws the reader in and keeps their attention to the very end. It is an old-fashioned mystery with a few twists and turns. I recommend this book to lovers of crime fiction and I look forward to reading more by Sarah Ward.
Profile Image for Pgchuis.
2,367 reviews37 followers
October 14, 2018
Six girls enter a railway tunnel and only five emerge. This takes place in 1953, and in the present day Mina's mother is dying and believes she has seen Valerie, whom she thought was dead. There are plenty of twists and turns, and people turning out to be not quite what we had been led to believe. I enjoyed the present day sections where Connie and her new colleague Dahl investigated.

On the other hand, the whole thing seemed to be a lot of fuss about nothing.

Disappointing.
4 reviews
January 14, 2019
I read The Shrouded Path (the fourth book in this series) straight after "A Patient Fury" (the third book in the DC Child series) and to be honest I was a little disappointed. Its a decent read but it was a little bit more obvious that the other books and more "ploddy". Not sure if it was the more "old-fashioned" storyline, although all of the Sarah Ward books I've read have a more classic feel to them, this one just felt a bit too twee. That said I did enjoy reading it and it won't deter me from reading the next book in the series (presuming there is one) I just don't think its as good as the first three books which I really liked.

The Shrouded Path
243 reviews4 followers
January 16, 2020
I’ve read the previous three books in this series and enjoyed the writing and the main characters. I still liked those things but this is a two-star review because there were way too many people involved in the mystery. It made the story very confusing and convoluted but not in a good way.
364 reviews
August 24, 2025
A good mystery: following some deaths of elderly women - a detective’s niggle suspects something is going on. It is. The women shared a past some50 years previously and something has come to light . The investigation is two pronged- with a charming young gardener, whose mum was a victim doing her own enquiries following some confused ramblings the day before her death. The detectives, Sadler and Connie- with a rookie in tow take their time to make connections but make it in the end via Sadler’s own mother. Set in Derbyshire in a small town and a backwater village near Ladybower, the locations sound familiar . Characters come into their own as their local buried secrets start to surface- and at times it is quite tense. Naturally we get the full story later ( though in truth the reader could make links much earlier as we heard both sides of the investigation….) nicely structured with just short sections of 1957, setting the scene at the beginning of each part.
Profile Image for Rachel Sargeant.
Author 10 books164 followers
October 8, 2018
I've read all of Sarah Ward's DC Connie Child's mysteries and this is the best so far. There is a wonderful cosy quality to the story with characters finding unexpected connections . Connie takes a background role for most of the novel, but we get to see a different side to Connie's boss, Sadler, and meet her new sidekick, DC Dahl. Centre stage is professional gardener Mina who has promised her dying mother she will find Valarie, a girl she knew in the 1950s. The plot weaves together buried secrets and present-day murder with a dash of Derbyshire folklore and sumptuous helpings of rugged Derbyshire countryside.
Profile Image for Shelley Lawrence.
2,030 reviews102 followers
March 6, 2021
The Shrouded Path is the fourth book in the DC Childs mystery series. It is a layered, interesting mystery set in the small rural area of Derbyshire. It has past and present POVs, multiple characters or suspects, and centers around a group of school girls. “Six go into the tunnel, five come out.” 😯

This installment of the series has Connie back with the team and right in the thick of things. Sadler is drawn back in from his staycation, and the story introduces a new detective to the gang, a young man with a mysterious past. The story is atmospheric, well-written and an engaging addition to the series.

If you like cleverly-plotted, well-crafted crime fiction, detective-style, you should definitely check this series out. I highly recommend it.
Profile Image for Mark Rose.
22 reviews
August 24, 2025
This was my first book by Sarah Ward, and I thoroughly enjoyed it! It was excellent from start to finish.
Profile Image for Emma.
757 reviews344 followers
September 5, 2018
All of my reviews can be found on http://www.damppebbles.com

The Shrouded Path by Sarah Ward is the fourth book in the excellent DC Connie Childs series and continues to remain a very firm favourite of mine. A series I return to time and time again.

One of my most eagerly anticipated releases of the year is always the next DC Connie Childs book from Sarah Ward. And do you know what? I am NEVER disappointed. Never. It’s that simple really. If you’re a fan of crime fiction and you haven’t read one of Ward’s books, then you’re doing something wrong. Her characters are fully formed, living beings who leap off the page at the reader. You’re drawn into the misty fictional town of Bampton and its surrounding Peak District towns, a landscape which feels as much a part of the book as the characters. And then you’re handed a complex, enthralling mystery to get your teeth into. It’s fictional bliss and I can’t get enough of Ward’s masterful writing.

I adore Ward’s lead protagonist, Connie Childs, but I also have a rather large soft spot for her DI, Francis Sadler, who, unlike many senior officers you find in crime fiction, is supportive of his DC. Sadler offers an encouraging word and a gentle shove in the right direction whilst also providing the authority which spontaneous and impulsive Connie needs at times. They’re a wonderful match and such a refreshing change to many other DI/DC relationships I read about. I must also mention the new boy, DC Peter Dahl. He’s not as fiery as some of Connie’s previous colleagues but he felt a good fit for the team. I look forward to finding out more about him in future novels.

I very much enjoyed the leaps from the late-1950s to the present day. The author has built a wonderfully enjoyable mystery around a small group of school friends, both in the past and in the present. The secrets, the lies and the half-truths made for compelling reading. And yes, I tried from the very start to figure out where the story was headed and who was responsible but I would never have reached the correct conclusion. I was bowled over by how simple parts of the story were, how Ward manages to keep her big reveal, her ‘taddah’ moment away from the reader’s mind. Absolutely brilliant.

Would I recommend this book? Absolutely. And it’s predecessors too. This is one of the very best crime fiction series out there at the moment and Ward’s books are a must read for every crime thriller fan. A dark and brooding mystery which I couldn’t put down. The eerie atmosphere of ‘the Cutting’ sent chills down my spine. I absolutely loved it!

Five out of five stars.

I chose to read and review an ARC of The Shrouded Path. The above review is my own unbiased opinion.
1,405 reviews
April 26, 2019
Villages: Cold Eaton, Bramton.

As Hilary Kemp lies dying in St. Bertram's she is visited by Catherine Hallow, a 14 year old volunteer, who looks like Catherine's grandmother, and Hilary glimpses "Valerie" Ginnie Sadler, a school colleague from 60 years ago. In her agitation and fear, she confusedly asks her daughter, Mina, to find Valerie, though later she says Valerie is dead. Nevertheless, Mina decided to look for Valerie, and in so doing finds herself in the middle of a killing spree.

In 1947 a reservoir covers up a town, forcing its inhabitants to move, and Valerie Virginia is one. She becomes friends with a group of girls who have rituals for the group, and punishments if one digresses. Valerie falls in love with the father of one of the girls, and is subjected to being put into the ventilation shaft of the tunnel of the closed railway. She is rescued by "the naker man", but finds hersefl unable to talk and is put into a local psychiatic hospital for treatments. When she leaves she changes her name and leaves the area, never to return, or to speak of her early life to her family. Her son is DI Francis Sadler.

When Hilary dies and it is determined that her saline bag was tampered with, the police begin to look into deaths of other women, who are linked to Hilary. One of the women was going to write a memoir, and her research had brought the event to light. This is a convoluted and skillfully devised story of a sixty year old punishment/prank that follows the girls who perpetrated it, and it motivates a woman to kill the others to keep the secret and the reputation of her family clear. She manipulates the young girl, Catherine, to help her in the killing.

The story moves back and for between the present and the past event. There is a pervasive sense of foreboding that is set up and maintained throughout, and it is suspenseful to the very end.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
1,096 reviews23 followers
December 19, 2020
3.5, way better than book 3. However, Connie is still an insufferable protagonist, and, as in book 3, the best character is the non-police accidental detective. This must be the series' formula.
The mystery was more interesting this time, but the solution was kind of... "oh, ok."
My only other note is, how old was the girl when she disappeared? Fifth form would be 15 or 16, and she was having an affair with her friend's dad, but the only mention of that being predatory was waved off by the character herself. Made me uncomfortable.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sheila.
2,210 reviews220 followers
December 3, 2018
Connie and her team investigate the mysterious deaths of several elderly women that were once school friends. The investigate leads to a 50 year old crime that has been hidden all these years.
Profile Image for Lizzie Hayes.
586 reviews32 followers
September 6, 2018
I have stated many times that I read crime fiction for the mystery not the crime, and this the fourth book in this series featuring DC Connie Childs, certainly provides plenty of tantalising mystery.

The story opens on a dank November day in rural Derbyshire in 1957, when six teenage girls are walking in the fields following the old train tracks that pass through a dark tunnel to Cutting Lane. Unbeknown to them a watcher is aware that only five girls reappear the other side of the tunnel.

Sixty years on Mina Kemp is called to the hospital where her mother Hilary has taken a turn for the worst. Feverish and confused she tells her daughter that she has seen Valerie and that Mina must finder her and check that she is alright. But Mina has never heard her mother mention a Valerie, in fact her mother has never discussed or kept up with any of her childhood friends and she has no idea where to start.

In CID HQ things are for once quiet for which acting DI Matthews is grateful while she stands in for DI Francis Sadler who has been forced to take outstanding leave or lose it. Determined to succeed in this temporary position she is doing everything by the book and in doing so driving Connie Childs mad. Their latest case is one of the sudden death of Nell Colley an elderly unmarried lady who was found by a neighbour sitting on her sofa dead, seems just a simple death. However, Matthews wants no stone left unturned. So together with the newest addition to the team Peter Dahl Connie sets out to interview the neighbour and check through the house. Although, they can not find anything really amiss, Connie has an uneasy feeling that is reinforced when she learns that Nell had only recently retired in order to write her memoirs. But there is nothing in the house that confirms this. Just a newspaper with the death of another elderly lady circled!

There are both multiple characters and threads to this intriguing story. Slowly the links are uncovered and yet still the reader is at a loss as to how they come together and who and where is Valerie?

There are several third person narrators, that provide background to this fascinating mystery, but still the motive and the identity remain a mystery. A real page turner with a startling revelation. If you love a good mystery this is a must read for you. Most highly recommended.
------
Reviewer: Lizzie Sirett
Profile Image for Anne.
2,431 reviews1,169 followers
September 17, 2018
I have so much affection for author Sarah Ward and her lead character DC Connie Childs. Since reading the first instalment; In Bitter Chill, back in 2016, this series has become a favourite. I eagerly await each new book, as they really do get better with each one.

The Shrouded Path is excellent. From that intriguing, dark and spooky first chapter set in 1957, right through the unexpected and so cleverly developed ending; it's a joy to read.

Set in the fictional Derbyshire town of Bampton and featuring characters from the previous novels as well as the new ones who populate this plot, this is a thrilling and complex mystery story.

In 1957, as the story opens on a misty November day, six young girls walk into The Cutting; a tunnel beneath the train track, but only five walk out. The atmosphere created within these few short pages set the scene for the rest of the novel. Sarah Ward excels in creating such a wonderful sense of place, incorporating real places such as Ladybower into her stories. The reader can almost feel the chill seeping through their bones as she brings the Derbyshire countryside vividly to life.

The story hurtles forward to 2017 and Mina, a local gardener is called to her mother's bedside as she takes her final breaths. One of the last things she says to Mina is to 'find Valerie', but Mina has no idea who Valerie is.
The hunt for the mysterious Valerie begins to take over Mina's life, and she soon finds herself mixed up with unsavoury modern-day events, as well as discovering things that have been kept secret for many years.

DC Connie Childs is investigating the unexpected death of a local elderly woman. At first glance this seems to be a pretty straightforward case, until Connie begins to listen to her inner feelings and realises that there are things that just don't add up. Along with new partner; Peter Dahl, she sets out to get to the bottom of what has happened; uncovering very similar deaths that have happened nearby.

Sarah Ward has cleverly interwoven the modern-day story with the mystery from the 1950s and keeps her readers on their toes throughout. The multiple narrators work wonderfully, allowing the full story to be slowly and effortlessly revealed.

Wonderfully atmospheric and so riveting with such a vivid sense of place. Highly recommended.
Profile Image for Stacey Lunsford.
393 reviews3 followers
August 10, 2019
As with all Ward's books, crimes from the past fester and cause crimes in the present. DI Francis Sadler is on "staycation" while DC Connie Childs meets her new partner, DC Dahl. They have been tasked with following up on the death of an elderly woman in her own home that looks like natural causes. The woman, Nell Colley, had heart arrhythmia. Everything seems normal but Connie feels a sense of unease. Nell was found sitting straight up, fully dressed, on her sofa.

The author weaves several storylines together, occasionally going back in time to fill in the blanks as the detectives and family members of the parties involved in the long-ago crime try to figure out what happened 50 years ago that made five women never speak of their school days and never, ever go to the Bampton railway trail. Families, female friendship, tribes and cliques are feature as themes throughout the book. The author gives plenty of clues for the reader to decipher and a slight twist at the end keeps the reader in suspense. For anyone who enjoys British mysteries and cold case stories.
Profile Image for Ella Harris.
28 reviews2 followers
February 12, 2024
This book really hooks you in and has many different unknown aspects to be resolved, with a clever, albeit slightly confusing plot twist revealed towards the end. I struggled somewhat to fully grasp all the characters and remember what had happened in the book previously, so had to skim back through to refresh my memory towards the end. It was also tricky to understand all the locations used and imagine how they might be laid out in relation to one another. I was stumped as to how a bystander could easily see if a person had exited a 3 minute long tunnel and what this 'above ground' area was actually comprised of. Furthermore, I don't quite get why not seeing someone exit this tunnel would cause a man to panic and pull out into the path of oncoming traffic. I'm unsure whether the plot seemed all that realistic to me and if the final revelations provided closure, but putting that aside, this was a quick and enjoyable read.
Profile Image for Amanda Williams.
77 reviews
November 16, 2018
Set in the Peak District a case begins with a death that has all the looks of natural causes, but something doesn’t ring right for Connie.
Nina’s mom is in hospital and takes a turn for the worst and then she mentions having a little girl named Valerie’s coming to visit but when her daughter ask the hospital staff about the visitor they said no one has been. While looking through her moms things there’s a photo of a group of girls on the back of the photo is the name GIVEN written on the back. She starts investigating who Valerie this little girl is and why her mom is so scared.
When the connection to another death this again recorded natural causes but the woman are recorded as sitting in the same position. Soon Connie and Mina are looking at the same case and not realising danger is round the corner.
This book has atmosphere and keeps you wanting to read one more chapter
Displaying 1 - 30 of 82 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.