This series started off really good and there's some really good parts in them, but there are books that I just don't understand the meandering of the plot. I still think Power of Three is one of my favorite Warrior Cats book series. It's interesting to have the point of view from cats who aren't sure what the future is and definitely make mistakes along the way. I have very fond memories of it and the three are some of my favorite characters in the warriors series. This series starts off with the stereotypical kits that can't wait to be apprenticed to warriors who now have a destiny that are beyond their reach. By the end of the books, we still don't know what the prophecy exactly means, but things have changed drastically. In previous books there are interpersonal relationships between clan lines and now in this book it focuses on certain cats relationships with one another and how that changes. I don't exactly mind that (I mean the three are my favorite for a reason), but I do miss having other clans to look into.
The Sight - 5 stars
Dark River - 5 stars
Outcast - 4 stars
Eclipse - 2 stars
Long Shadows - 4 stars
Sunrise - 3 stars
The Sight
It's interesting to have the point of view from cats who aren't sure what the future is and definitely make mistakes along the way. For example, Hollypaw tries to be a medicine cat and later realizes that isn't the role she wants to pursue or the fact that Jaypaw was put into the role of medicine cat. Even though he doesn't want to be a medicine cat.
On the other hand, Lionpaw doesn't really have much to do in this book. The only thing you can say he did was fight some battles and then get injured by falling into an old badgers den with Breezepaw. He's one of the final three in later books and it just doesn't seem they thought about what powers he would have too much. All his power even is that he can fight well, which isn't that impressive to me. There are loads of Warriors who could fulfill that kind of role.
Dark River
I really enjoyed rereading the lore about the lake territory and how the mountain cats used to live there themselves. I think these books really shine when it comes to new areas, but not so much when you have to travel there. Which is why this is the best of that. No traveling, but a new setting.
I also think that all the main characters are starting to get the hang of their lives as apprentices especially Jaypaw because he seems to have more growth even though he spent most of his time at camp. On the other hand, hollypaw and lionpaw learn some important lessons along the way. I feel like each of the three had an equal amount of time spent with them learning along the way. One of the biggest relationships in this book were between Lionpaw and Heatherpaw. At the end of the book, Lionpaw trades that relationship for training in the dark forest with Tigerstar. This is our first look at the dark forest for the series and it's interesting to see how that changes over time. While Lionpaw didn't have much of a role in the first book, I think he really shines as a character here.
Outcast
It's no secret that I really don't enjoy some of the travel books and this one is a perfect example of that. I really don't like when characters travel to new areas and focus on how weird the new cats/people are and then try to impose their own ideals on them. The Tribe is it's own group of cats and I don't see why they had to force their clan ideals on them just because they're struggling a little. This book does answer why Stormfur and Brook came to Thunderclan in The New Prophecy, so if you're curious about that then I guess you can read it. At the end of the book, Jaypaw decides to tell Lionpaw and Hollypaw about the prophecy.
Eclipse
A lot of this book deals with the rising conflict of Thunderclan and Windclan and ends with the Eclipse happening. (Sol having predicted it and taking up residence with Shadowclan) Lionpaw, Cinderpaw and Hollypaw all get their warrior names at the end of the book. There's also briefly a scare that Cinderpaw is injured and now that she's reincarnated she's just going to be a medicine cat again, but Jaypaw manages to heal her.
I personally didn't find it that entertaining to read just because a lot of the book focuses on those plot lines. I feel like there are better ways to rise conflict, while also introducing the eclipse plot line and cats loosing faith in starclan. The eclipse was the most interesting part of the book and it was just gone as quickly as it happened. I also found the fact that all four clans were fighting on Thunderclan territory and the last time they all fought was when the prophecies began.
Long Shadows
The events in this book: the three fake a sign from starclan and blackstar kicks Sol out from Shadowclan. There's a green cough epidemic and Firestar looses a life. Jay feather goes to the past as Jays Wing and convinces the ancient tribe cats to go to the mountains. Lionblaze finally sneaks into windclan territory, has a confrontation with Heathertail, and brings back cat mint to cure the green cough. There's a fire and the three discover their parents aren't who they think they are and Ashfur is going to expose that secret at the next gathering, but Ashfur is murdered.
There's a lot of events in this book and some of them are pretty good, but I found others very frustrating.
I don't understand why they introduced Sol at all if they're just going to write him out of the series, as far as I know he doesn't appear again. I also understand why Lionblaze is hesitant to go get the cat mint, but I really figured somebody else would die due to his inaction. Just killing Firestar is no big deal since at this point he has more lives. It's very anticlimactic. I didn't really mind Jayfeather going to the past, but that wasn't what I was expecting he was going to do at that moment. I really thought he was going to take things into his own paws and do something about the epidemic since Lionblaze wasn't doing anything. For example, one of the tribe cats could have told him another way to cure green cough? Also the fact that we're then told that Jays Wing disappeared at the start of the journey, where did Jays Wing go?? We're never told what happens to him, just that the tribe goes to the mountains as expected.
That being said, the rest of the book is pretty good. I've always loved the fire scene and reveals towards the end of the book. While I don't like it, I can understand why the three are so mad with Squirrelflight. It's very in character for them because they just want to understand who their parents really are and she just won't tell them.
Sunrise
o much of this book is spent trying to find Sol and learning the secrets behind the three's birth. At the end of the book all of the secrets are revealed: Leafpool and Crowfeather are the three's real birth parents and Hollyleaf murdered Ashfur. Hollyleaf can't take the truth, tells all the clans the truth, and disappears in the tunnels.
The best part of this book is just the ending. I feel like so much time is wasted on Sol and what he's planning. When in the end, it doesn't matter what Sol was planning at all. As far as I know and what the wiki says, Sol never comes back in any major way. It just feels like a waste of time. It makes me think of how Mudclaw was just tacked on as a villain just for the sake of the climax in The New Prophecy. I would understand if Sol came back, but he doesn't.