Well, this was a book club read, I'm embarrassed to say. I got halfway through, and I just couldn't waste any more reading time on it. I have a lot of complaining to do, though, so...
SPOILERS FOLLOW: IF YOU WANT TO RETAIN ANY ILLUSIONS ABOUT THIS BOOK DO NOT READ FURTHER
I think perhaps what I will do is make a list of all the ridiculousness. I'm not even going to go into the politics of the book ( although I lean left myself) because the right wing villains are so very cartoonish that it's embarrassing again. Although I did like the reference to the Gingrich Moon Base (or something like it) made by the author in 2002. A bit of trivia that will undoubtedly be lost to the ages.
1. Names. There's no actual physical description of anybody except for the "icy" beauty of the evil ex-wife (hey, you married her, dude! you are not the victim here- you used her for her political connections!) but it seems the default is white, because at least the oh-so-ethnic ethnic Hispanic names try so very hard to show that the author is inclusive and trying to put people who are not of western European descent in his book. We get Jorge Montero, his wife Rita, son Carlos, and daughter Maria. Then we get the Asian doctor, the only other non-white person around that we know of. Mr. Montero didn't name his son, say, Carl and his daughter Monica? I am not disparaging the fact of Hispanic names, here, but the fact that the author is taking the short-hand of using names instead of description or any other method of inclusivity. It made the book feel dated and clunky and obvious- this was the way that people introduced non-white characters when they wanted to show that they were PC in the 80's.
2. The plan is to sleep-gas all the carefully selected colonists and replace them with people who are dissidents against the fascist government who all also happen to be scientists. One scientist is much like another, I suppose, and they all would be equally ready to help with colonization. Actually, this could be true, for a more staggeringly inept group of colonists I have never seen.
3. Everyone is put into cryogenic storage for about 250 years. In the book, cryogenic storage has never been attempted for longer than 18 months, but everyone assumes it will all turn out okay and no one is left to monitor the situation.
4. It does not go okay. One person wakes up a few months or years ( I can't remember which and it doesn't matter) into the voyage. He can't put himself back to sleep, so he uses about 1/3 of the colonists' total food supply as he hangs out over the next 30 years. He does not spend any time trying to learn about the cryogenic system or software coding so he can put himself back to sleep, though. He _does_ find out that there is a saboteur who was supposed to be woken up in order to blow up the ship if anything happened other than a normal voyage- the fascist government didn't want anybody using their ship for non-regulation purposes. So, he decides to warn his captain about this by LEAVING HIM A NOTE. That is what he does. He leaves a note.
5. Everybody gets woken up together when they get to Planet Coyote, even though the first people woken know that 30% of their food supplies have been consumed. Oh, by the way, "everybody" includes a contingent of Marines that tried to stop the hijacking of the spacecraft and were cryogenically stored against their will, and the saboteur, which the captain knew about, because he got his note.
6. The captain persuades the loyalist Marine sergeant that he might as well go along with the colonists, because the space ship "was only made to go one way" and can't take them back, and even if it could go back, it would take another 250 years. Fair enough. Then he and the Marine captain stay behind all the other colonists to confront the saboteur, who gets shot. Fade away... in the next scene the captain muses sadly over the fact the the first BBQ party on Planet Coyote is marred by him having to tell about the "accident" the saboteur had- the first colonist death besides the guy that got woken up early. The captain thinks, " I never thought I'd have to be explaining that a man died." Dude. You set it up so the man would die. You should have expected it. Captain Robert E. Lee (yes that is his name) has a real victim complex, between his ex-wife and not understanding loyalty, even if it is misplaced.
7. So, this hasn't even covered the utter stupidity of how Planet Coyote is colonized. First, they fly a surprisingly low-fueled shuttle to scope things out. Because of the surprisingly low fuel, they just pick the first flat spot near water they see and land. This is where the colony goes. Planet Coyote is amazingly hospitable. They know that it has water, oxygen, and nitrogen. So, "because they've had their shots" everyone decides that they don't need to keep on helmets or use a pressure chamber to leave the shuttle. They'll just open the big door and go on out. "After all, everyone was going to have to breathe the air eventually." Yes that was their logic. But fortunately this is a book, so they all live.
8. I get that the point of the book is to have a hardy colonization story in an earthlike world, so Planet Coyote is earthlike. The point isn't a Mars-like terraforming, but sturdy back-to-the-land colonists. Heinlein did this stuff all the time. But man, these people don't deserve to live. All the seeds they've brought will grow in defiance of any biological sanity, because this is a book. All the livestock they've brought will live, because this is a book. And even though the colonists brought only one year of food and even that was partially taken from them, they won't have too much problem with that, because this is a book.
9. Everybody leaves the ship and comes to the planet. No one remains on their STARSHIP. Hasn't anyone read the Pern books? Or any other science fiction book?
10. This hasn't even considered the vanishingly small possibility that the people sent 250 years away to a different star system would even have found a planet remotely habitable, even if it was in the theoretical "habitable planet" range. The odds were so vastly against it that really, it was essentially a death sentence for anyone aboard their "one-way" ship with vanishingly small food supplies and no organized plans for leaving a minimum crew awake until favorable conditions could be ascertained.
After all this, I could not take any more stupidity. God knows what the characters of this book will do once they've got an actual planet to screw around on.
The fact that this author has won any awards is about as amazing an improbability as that of Planet Coyote being hospitable to human life. He has no grasp of science, of character development, or of story development. Anyone who's read any science fiction about colonization can point out dozens of gigantic plot and logic holes here. Any author who wants to write a book like this should already be miles ahead of where this author is, should have read other -any other- science fiction books about space colonization, and have something original to say. I can't find any redeeming value here.