Sluggish alternative "future" history epic about disinteresting, disconnected people I cared nothing about
John Birmingham is an Australian novelist who writes postmodern lifestyle comedies set in Australia, sci-fi space operas set in outer space, and alternative histories one of which is the "Disappearance" series of which this is Book Two (Book One is Without Warning). He really likes to write trilogies, I suppose, because, judging by how I feel about this one, he doesn't focus on a single story arc long enough to make a simple soul like me give a care about the characters or the plot. Birmingham is a competent writer, but the emphasis is on clever world building, not clever storytelling or characterization.
Dang, I almost ALWAYS love anything about the end-of-the-world-as-we-know-it (TEOTWAWKI). But this one didn't work for me.
Sheesh... okay, full disclosure: I did not finish this. Wouldn't for all the tea in Sydney (if that were what Australians drank). This one was like walking on a treadmill staring into a blank wall without a screen to watch or a person to talk to... or even look at.
And calling this an alternative history is weird. It's a speculative novel about a future without an American Superpower due to a mysterious "disappearance" of most of the people in the United States that leads to a collapse of the global order (and an Indian-Pakistan War, a civil war in China, a revolution in France, an invasion of NYC by jihadist pirates, and an immigrant purge in an economically dysfunctional UK...among other things). But that's how some describe it. Maybe because the Disappearing Event takes place around the same time as Y2K and the author isn't going to change the timeframe or something... I don't know. And maybe as the first book in the series, Without Warning, sold fairly well, Birmingham decided to drag it along into the future a bit. For the publisher. Maybe.
Anyway, I know some fan will chastise me for starting the trilogy in the middle instead of getting all the backstory in Without Warning, but this 2011 Del Rey Mass Market paperback doesn't give a hint about this "trilogy" until you are well on your way... slugging it out in the mud of four or five story arcs about people you don't know... or care for.
(Or because Book Three wasn't written yet? Or because Del Rey was hedging its bets on sales?)
Synopsis: America is fragmented. Millions have vanished in an event eerily similar to the Christian Rapture or Dean Koontz's The Taking. NYC is under attack by African Pirates. Texas is an autonomous region called the Texas Republic that is run by a duly elected strongman we are told is a bad guy (and his followers are called "Republicans".... hmmmm.... our Aussie friend was researching this by watching Stephen Colbert or reading Rolling Stone articles for that hip, anti-George W. Bush stuff that resonated with the cool NYC literary crowd circa 2008). The new US president is named Kipper, a conflicted western American liberal type who was a city engineer from Seattle (uh, sure) before being elected President of the diminished United States. Good immigrants, encouraged to migrate from overseas to Texas by the good President Kipper, are being savagely persecuted by rednecks and the Texas State Defense Force (uh-oh!). An American female secret agent boss girl living in the UK rescues her emasculated US-Airborne-Ranger-turned-UK-commune-farmer from some bad guys who want HER dead. Can I stop now?
This book is an un-thrilling thriller and an unsuspenseful suspense novel with unrealistic action scenes. According to author John Birmingham, the bad guys are armed with "cutting edge" Type 56 rifles (Chinese AK-47s which haven't been cutting edge since the Tet Offensive). And Birmingham's bio says he was a researcher once for the Australian Defence Force? Not good, John!
Zero character development here--again, I will be chastised for skipping Book One -- but I LIKE a little descriptive prose and third person POV once in a while so my brain has something for my imagination to digest, and my heart can decide to love, hate or be curious about the people who populate the story and the places the story takes them. This book is long on telling, long on disinteresting scenes, and I get it, Birmingham is going after a world-building for his alternative speculative reality and that means covering the map with people and story arcs. But too much of that without an interesting plot or interesting characters is not interesting.
Here is a tip: Read Dean Koontz's The Taking instead. Now THAT is a great, eerie, suspenseful, end-of-the-world novel I HIGHLY recommend.
But if you LOVED Birmingham's predecessor novel, Without Warning, then by all means, read this to find out more about the people from that novel.
I warned you.