Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

This Side of Heaven #6

Falling for a Father of Four

Rate this book
THE DADDY DILEMMA

Four rambunctious children and not a wife in sight. Struggling single father Orren Ellis needed someone to care for his brood, and the only applicant was Mattie Kincaid. Though the beauty could cook, clean and courageously keep his kids in line, Orren considered her simply too young to take the job of his bride.

But years were not important to Mattie. She had quickly fallen for the endearing father of four and sensed he felt the same. And no matter how loud Orren thought to protest, Mattie was determined to make herself part of this ready-made family.

186 pages, Paperback

First published May 1, 1998

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Arlene James

202 books92 followers
Arlene James has written romance for four decades, and has published 100+ novels. A mother of sons and now a happy grandmother to the brightest, most talented, and lovely of all granddaughters, she is finding her sixth decade to be great fun.

She and her very supportive husband of 45 years (whom she agreed to marry on their first date!) enjoy a busy social life and have visited much of the world. After calling Texas home for three decades, they now live in beautiful NW Arkansas.

Arlene grew up on a ranch in south central Oklahoma and still maintains strong ties in that area. She firmly believes that writing has afforded her the best of all possible means of earning a living, and credits a junior high school English teacher with proving to her that her dream of being an author was entirely achievable.

After 4 decades of deadlines and multiple-book contracts (for which she is deeply grateful), she is enjoying the ability to write exactly what she feels led to write on her own schedule.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (17%)
4 stars
10 (43%)
3 stars
6 (26%)
2 stars
2 (8%)
1 star
1 (4%)
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
Profile Image for JillyB.
860 reviews93 followers
July 1, 2022
2-4 stars for this one. I feel confused about my ability to rate certain books. What I mean is that I may rate an Alexa Riley story 4 stars with the understanding that I am rating it against the same type of books like a Flora Ferrari, etc. They are insta love stories that IMO are not in the same league as a Harlequin Presents, but they are good for what they are.

Then you have a story like this. It is sweet. It is low on drama/angst(has some though) and has Christian values woven throughout. It was a nice story and would make a great movie for wholesome tv. Unfortunately, as much as I love sweetness in my real life there is a little bit of a sinister side to me that loves a dark, cruel hero. Hence my dilemma with my rating. This is probably a 4 star for someone who wants that type of story. Sadly, for me it is probably more of a 2 star. However, recently I have read some stories online, that I am way to embarrassed to admit to as they were a shade darker then 50 shades could even think of being. So, this was a nice book to bleach my brain cells for a bit.

STORY: Hero, Orren, is a 28 year old father of 4(Darn, I really wanted a May/December romance but that isn’t happening with a dad that young!) He fell in LoveLust with 21 year old Gracie when he was 19. She got pregnant. They got married. They continued to have sex as most married people do, and popped out 3 more children(although the last one was unwanted by his wife). She took off shortly after the last baby was born to rejoin the rodeo circuit with her new stud muffin. So here you have a single 25/26 year old man who is the father of 4 children all under the age of 5. Let that sink in….he was 25/26 years old. Now he is 28 and can’t get someone to care for his children. The divorce really hurt him financially and his credit took a dump due to his wife’s spending habits. He is barely surviving and needs to work to keep his children fed and clothed. His oldest, is his 8 year old son, who has taken on a fatherly role with his younger siblings, all of which are sisters. The house is in a state of remodel so he even has to share a room with his sisters. This house is in need of someone and someone quick. The good news is that England isn’t the only place to find Mary Poppins, she has a younger protege living in Texas, and her name is Mattie.

Mattie is 19 years old going on 4020. I guess we are introduced to a younger Maddie in her Dad’s story Most Wanted Dad Mattie is in college and is home on summer break. However, Mattie is struggling. She isn’t really interested in college. She is not sure what she wants to do or should I say she doesn’t want to admit to what she wants. You see although it is 1998 our heroine really wants to be a wife and mother. Her own mother died when she was 12, so she took on that job until her dad remarried. She is excited about the chance to work taking care of children this summer. She just hopes it is a big family!

When the 28 year old hero meets Mattie, he is struck at how young she is. He sees her as a kid herself. But once the heroine gets her foot in the door she is like a hurricane. (Not like the Scorpion’s song though) Anyhoo, she takes control of the household. She redecorates with what is available as the hero is low on funds. She plans nutritious filling meals on a budget with left over money to boot. Gee, shucks, she probably even darns socks. She begins crushing on the responsible, handsome hero right away. She starts to change up her wardrobe so she can appear more womanly and less childlike to him. So, she dons lots of flirty outfits to combat the scorching heat of the Hero. Texas.


It doesn’t take long for the hero to fall under her spell, but this time around he is falling for the person that is Mattie..it is love first then lust because of the love. Of course our story isn’t without some roadblocks along the way.

Well first there is her Daddy Sheriff. He still sees his daughter as a 12 year old. Plus, he thinks she needs to get out there and enjoy life, especially college.



Then there is plot moppet 2…
She is a red headed menace who is old enough to remember her mom, but not old enough to remember the bad parts. She fights the addition of Mattie to their lives any chance she can. She starts to come around, but once she sees her Dad and Mattie kissing she sees it as a threat not only to her position in the household but also as a reason her parents will never remarry. So, she manipulates her younger sister to get under their dad’s skin and try to contact their mom for a visit. And mommy arrives to cause the big black moment in the story.

Gracie makes an appearance when she finds out the hero is looking for her. She has divorced husband 2 but got to keep her new boobs in the settlement. She is off to California to start her movie career, so she has no intention of taking up the mantle of devoted mommy and housewife. She tries to shimmy up to the Hero and tells him he was always the best, but at this point it is more of her knowing that he has someone else in mind to fill that position. So she insults him and ends up spending the night. She takes over her daughter’s bed and the daughter was under the impression mommy was going to cuddle with her. The next morning the hero leaves for work expecting the ex to be gone before Mattie arrives. She isn’t. Even though she doesn’t want the hero for herself, she doesn’t mind causing mischief for the 19 year old Mattie. She even points out how she is more developed in areas that the h cannot compete.

The hero clears up the misunderstanding quickly and they engage in a passionate kiss. The h’s dad comes upon them kissing and is not pleased. They have a family meeting with the local pastor and it looks like the dad isn’t going to budge. The hero and heroine want to marry before school starts back up for the kids. The story ends with the marriage, the dad arrives to walk his baby girl down the aisle, and although there is not an epilogue, it is mentioned more than once that the h plans on adding to their brood at some point. We also get a little insight into the hero’s motivations for marrying his first wife. Basically, he had a bad upbringing with an alcoholic distant mother. He isn’t even sure if his parents are still alive. Therefore, the first wife was giving him attention he craved. Then the kids came, and he finally had a family..just the wrong woman to share it with.

So, like I said it was a pleasant cotton candy read. There were a few times I got distracted by other things, but I kept chugging away to finish the story. As I said before, I think the author is a pretty good writer. I will probably pick up another of her stories at some point. It is probably a little too tame for my personal preferences to be on automatic read list, but if the plot sounds interesting I will give it a whirl.

Profile Image for Debra.
3,513 reviews13 followers
January 18, 2020
Falling for a Father of Four

This story was one I enjoyed. Mattie was almost twenty years old and after two years at college still didn't know what she wanted to be. She ends up watching four very rambunctious children whose parents were divorced. Orren didn't know what hit him. She was able to get not only his kids but his house in order. He had been left with his children after his wife left. At twenty right he had his hands full. But with the help of Mattie things start to get better. But what happens when his ex comes back? Will Mattie be able to convince him that she is what he needs?
Profile Image for Kay.
1,978 reviews130 followers
March 5, 2012
4 ½ Stars! ~ Our heroine, Mattie is the hero's daughter from Most Wanted Dad. It's been a few years, and Mattie's home from university for the summer. She takes on the job as nanny and housekeeper for single dad, Orren. These two are made for each other, not only is Mattie perfect in the role of mother to Orren's four children, she's the perfect woman to complete his life. It takes a bit of convincing on Mattie's part that she's actually old enough to know her heart. I love the growth of both these remarkable characters. This is a truly lovely love story!
Profile Image for Stacey.
9 reviews1 follower
May 6, 2012


I was a little disappointed in the book in that there are a few curse words (not severe) and a few instances of too intimate touching. I've several of Arlene James' books in the "Love Inspired" and those are all super clean, so I was taken aback that this book was not written in the same fashion. I really liked the story line and the plot but I wasn't enraptured by this book as I have been with others.
Profile Image for Shelley.
2,582 reviews168 followers
February 11, 2010
This was rereleased with a new cover and sent as a free copy. For me, it works best to eliminate all references to VCRs and cellular phones and consider this as set in the 1950s. It took me a while to figure out that it wasn't actually set then - it definitely felt older than 2009, and even the 1998 I discovered that it had been originally published in.
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews