‘The entire span of British submarine history has been carefully recorded the tragedies in both peace and war … the successes too.’ — Geoffrey Moorhouse, DailyTelegraph
‘This is a unique picture of life in Britain's submarines… Naval enthusiasts will find some of the detailed personal accounts quite unforgettable.’ — WarshipWorld
‘An immensely readable book.’ — Lloyd’sList
‘An excellent collection of firsthand accounts of service in British submarines’— Robert Guttman, historynet.com
British submarines played a vital part in naval warfare between 1901 and 1999, from the first Holland boats through to the giant Trident nuclear vessels.
This selection of personal accounts of life aboard the Royal Navy's submarines includes vivid first-hand descriptions of tense patrols of the First and Second World Wars, torpedo attacks on enemy warships, U-boats and merchant vessels, the horrors of depth charging, the daring clandestine operations by bodies such as Force 136, and the midget-submarine attacks on the Tirpitz. There are accounts of the deterrent patrols of the Cold War, and what happened in the controversial sinking of the GeneralBelgrano during the Falklands War.
Drawn from personal memoirs, official reports, logbooks and private journals, John Winton skilfully weaves together compelling stories of survival and heroism in times of the most intense danger with welcome lighter moments, anecdotes about daily life and domestic arrangements aboard.
The Submariners is an authoritative anthology of enterprise, endurance and valour expertly compiled by an author who himself served seven years in the Submarine Service.
‘a highly effective writer on naval subjects’ – The Telegraph
A former officer in the Royal Navy, John Pratt was the author of a variety of fiction and non-fiction works published under the pen name John Winton. Pratt also served for 14 years as an obituarist for The Daily Telegraph.
Overall it was OK. It's a collection of different primary sources about British submariners. I needed it mainly for the Pre-First World War and First World War sections. No bibliography or citations which is disappointing.
I have a friend who was a submariner in the Australian Navy. Reading Winton's book, I now realise why my friend is as sharp as he is. This book is a tribute to a special breed of men. Detail is extraordinary, and many of the key moments are covered with up-to-date information, given at the time, the Soviets would have loved to get their hands on the data. Highly recommended.
The Submariners: Life in British Submarines, 1901-1999 by John Winton is a fascinating look at the experience through the eyes of those who lived it.
I am a submariner, albeit American and from the late 70s and early 80s. and found a lot that was similar and a lot that was different from what I experienced. Part of that difference stems from the time periods, early diesel boats have far fewer things in common with nuclear boats than one might think. But the essentials of life in cramped quarters knowing that what would be a minor accident on a surface ship can be fatal on a sub are largely the same.
I learned a lot about the Royal Navy through this book and came to better appreciate the importance and value of the submarine force for a nation surrounded by water. I was aware, as anyone with any background in history would be, of the importance of their Navy, but hearing it firsthand made it hit closer to home. I was struck by a sentiment that is mentioned in the first pages of the book about the opinion toward submarines prior to their development into what we know today: they are for the weak nations. I understand the genesis of that idea, but having lived only during the time submarines were important not only in warfare but in the balance of world power, it gave me pause. What a different world.
I would recommend this to anyone with an interest in military history, naval history, or just with a fascination about life onboard a submarine and how it has evolved.
Reviewed from a copy made available by the publisher via NetGalley.
Thoroughly enjoyed the read. Earlier pages were very interesting regarding the life in the old boats. Refreshing my memories from the mid 50s to later 60s I was pleasantly surprised by the pages by my old friend who later became 1st Sea Lord but as Captain of HMS Ganges sentenced me to a flogging !! (cuts - in return from my request - a long story) but during the rest of my service time we became good friends. Great respect. Also Captain Submarines J.S. Stevens remarks on reunions. I have enjoyed a few reunions since leaving the service. I think I'm glad he didn't review me. You can't win 'em all. Altogether a good read.
As an ex Polaris submariner, now a guide at the Submarine Museum, I found the stories most enlightening and they have re-enforced and corroborated my knowledge about submarine life that I pass on to visitors when guiding them through the boat.
Some great stories in here with heroism and bravery to the gunwales. Clearly a very very dangerous game, tread carefully any potential recruits. Well worth the read and no I won’t be a submariner in any life.