The story had a lot of potential that I feel was ultimately lived up to more in the character of Bane during knightfall.
The KGBeast was an imposing villain for a time in Batman's career when he had yet to deal with world-class assassins every other day, and there was a lot of fun in the back-and-fourth between them. In particular, the focus on their similar levels of experience gave a good dimension to the conflict, making it feel more like a clash between master tacticians.
The problem is with the story itself. The stakes just weren't there for me. As opposed to an ever escalating plan that unravels as Batman pursues the villain, it's a series of assassinations targeting Americsn intelligence operatives. And if that's the angle, you'd at least hope for a murder mystery? Maybe an inside job? A double agent? Sadly, no. The battle lines are made clear from the start of the story.
What's worse is that Batman is only getting in KGBeast's way, he never feels like a major consideration for the villain so there's no interesting dynamic between them. And nothing is learned about who the KGBeast is. We're never given much more reason to care about stopping him beyond saving the lives of nine guys who I honestly couldn't care less about. Oh and Ronald Reagan. Batman saves Ronald Reagan.
Batman is given more to do in the form of an incompitently run taskforce set up to stop the killings and who don't much care for him, but since Gordon is in his corner all the way, it didn't seem to affect him. It was all a bit of manufactured drama to act as filler since the main villain's presence was only really felt in the admittedly explosive action sequences.
To be fully transparent, I was looking forward to the ending. I knew it was one of the few stories in which Batman can be seen killing someone, so as long as it stuck the landing, I'd be satisfied. I was hoping for more deliberation. More guilt. Batman facing a villain so ruthless that it was either their life or his, and he would forever live with the choice he made. But it kind of just happens. An agent implies it may be necessary beforehand, and apparently, that's all it took. It's a bit chilling, actually. The ruthlessness with which he traps the man with no intention of letting him escape, paired with Jim Aparo's art giving us a sequence of Batman slowly closing the door from KGBeast's perspective is all very potent in a weird way. It'd almost be humanising for the beast if he hadn't cut off his own hand and replaced it with a Canon in cartoonishly evil fashion at the start of the issue.
At the end of the day, no one's ever claimed this to be the greatest Batman story ever told, and I think it's partly on me for building in up in my head so much before hand. But my disappointment is real. So Starlin, Aparo, the Jims, take my two stars and I'll see you after you've exploded me a Robin.